2 ms·
> In that sense, a contract can be considered void if it doesn't reasonably specify time. The judgment states pretty clearly that a contract is void if the two
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> In that sense, a contract can be considered void if it doesn't reasonably specify time.
The judgment states pretty clearly that a contract is void if the two parties, at the time they made the contract, did not agree on what it meant.
> the moment it appears that two ships called the “Peerless” were about to sail from Bombay there is a latent ambiguity, and parol evidence may be given for the purpose of shewing that the defendant meant one “Peerless,” and the plaintiff another. That being so, there was no consensus ad idem, and therefore no binding contract.
[The words are from the defendant's lawyer, but the court appears to have agreed immediately.]
So this isn't formally a "win" for the defendant - formally, there never was a contract, and the suit was dismissed for failure to state a claim.
- asah 4y agoMy point is that NO CONTRACT perfectly spells out every detail => this argument can be used to null any contract => weak legal reasoning. A buyer could make up any sort of nonsense to escape a contract, like (to pick a random example) arguing that a certain social media site has x% fake accounts. Far stronger reasoning (for example) is that a contract must spell out time, which is a special property of contracts because (for example) 1000000 years is virtually never an acceptable period for which to fulfill on your end of a contract.
- NoboruWataya 4y agoThis isn't really how contract law works. There may be minor details that are not specified in the contract but unless it can be proven in court that those details were actually within the contemplation of one of the parties and connected to his or her decision to enter into the contract, their absence would not be sufficient to nullify the contract. A contract is an agreement, so it stands to reason that if the parties do not, in fact, agree, there is no contract. The piece of paper we call a contract is, in fact, only a (strong) evidential tool to help the court figure out what the parties agreed. > Far stronger reasoning (for example) is that a contract must spell out time, which is a special property of contracts because (for example) 1000000 years is virtually never an acceptable period for which to fulfill on your end of a contract. How is this "far stronger reasoning"? It isn't even reasoning at all, because there is no existing rule that a contract must spell out time, so it's simply an untruth. Unless you were suggesting that the court create a new rule out of nowhere that all contracts must spell out the time for performance or else become void. A court would obviously never do that in light of the huge disruption it would cause.
- greendestiny_re 4y agoMaybe when contracting with the devil?