6 ms·
There is a long history of identifiers being reused in world shipping. One of the staples of contracts class in the first year at many law schools is Raffles v
by tzs 4y ago
There is a long history of identifiers being reused in world shipping.
One of the staples of contracts class in the first year at many law schools is Raffles v Wichelhaus, an English contract case from 1864.
There was a contract for someone to sell a bunch of bales of cotton from India to a buyer in England. The contract called for the cotton to be sent on a ship called the Peerless to Liverpool from Bombay.
Unknown to both the buyer and the seller there were actually two different ships called Peerless both sailing from Bombay to Liverpool, one arriving in October and one in December.
They seller was thinking of the December one when signing the contract, and the buyer was thinking of the October one.
The buyer needed the cotton in October and when it did not arrive on the Peerless in October the buyer considered the contract broken and refused to accept the cotton that came on the December Peerless.
- sigstoat 4y agowell you can’t stop halfway through the story. what was the outcome of the case?
- yashg 4y agoSo Peerless wasn't really peerless afterall.
- jameshart 4y agoThere's the beginnings of an Abbott and Costello skit here. "I went to the pier to meet the Peerless but the cotton didn't appear" "Did you talk to Captain Pierre?" "Captain Pierre of the Peerless? No, the captain of the Peerless was Captain Pearce" "Well did you talk to Captain Pearce?" "Yes, on the pier." ...
- stevekemp 4y agoThat's strongly reminiscent of the old Two Ronnies sketch, about misheard orders: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pV1IP4N9ajg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pV1IP4N9ajg Even now "Fork handles" will get a smile from me.
- linksnapzz 4y ago"I need some Os!" "No! Not hose! Os!"
- bityard 4y agoMy high school english teacher ordered something that had cardboard cut outs of the alphabet and when it arrived, a few of the letters were missing. When she called the company to straighten it out, she said (calmly) that the packet was missing the F and G. The woman on the other end gasped and said, "we're happy to send you a replacement letter, but there's no need to be rude!"
- jameshart 4y agoI think you’re right. If we add in some business about a portly porter who departed promptly from the port to go to a party while we were peering off the pier waiting for poor Captain Pearce of the Peerless to put in an appearance, I can practically hear it in Ronnie Barker’s voice. He might be the only person who could actually get through the script without stumbling.
- glimmung 4y ago"LO! FUNEX?"
- causality0 4y agoSometimes I think there must be something wrong with my brain because for the life of me I cannot figure out what is funny about homophone jokes.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y ago
- mikro2nd 4y agoNaah... it was a peerless-to-peerless network.
- tshaddox 4y agoYou’d think serious contracts would normally have provisions that would require mentioning expected dates, since late shipments would presumably be a common occurrence you’d want all parties to consider explicitly.
- raincom 4y agoLessons from such cases(or case law) make one specify expected dates.
- wahern 4y agoAccording to A.W. Brian Simpson, "Contracts for Cotton to Arrive: The Case of the Two Ships Peerless", Contracts Stories, p43, > A contract for cotton "to arrive" was a contract for forward delivery, or, as it is sometimes called, a "time contract". One might expect that such a contract would normally specify a time for delivery. For it is the moment when the goods become available in the market that is of paramount importance to the purchaser, particularly if the purchaser wants the goods for use. But the world in which such contracts originated was one in which this was not really possible. Although one could discover, after an interval, when a sailing ship had left or, more approximately, proposed to leave its port of departure, it was very uncertain when, if ever, it would arrive at its destination. Even when it did arrive, there were uncertain delays in finding a berth to unload its cargo. Hence such contracts did not originally specify the time of arrival, much less delivery, even within some fixed period. All they did was to identify which shipment of cotton was being sold; presumably the rationale of this was that the buyer, so long as he knew which shipment was being sold, would be able to form his own estimate of the probable time of arrival. This would not, of course, be a point in time but a period. It is said that originally such contracts were made only when arrival was imminent, the ship typically having been reported off Point Lynas, which is on the north coast of Anglesey, some fifty miles from Liverpool. Presumably there was a signal station there. No doubt also cotton was sometimes sold as the ship lay in the river, waiting to berth. In such cases the date of delivery could be guessed with some precision, though a square-rigged vessel, if it did not employ a steam tug, could take a long and unpredictable time to cover even fifty miles. The author also provides the broader context, which is that this was likely a form contract in the nascent commodity futures market. Additionally, this occurred during a period of particularly overheated speculation in cotton. In other words, just as is common today, financial speculators were pushing the legal and technological envelope of the instruments available to them. (Futures markets go back much further, but the mid-19th century is in many respects when modern futures markets began to take on their current shape. He cites another source pointing out that in "'in certain offices in Liverpool today the futures department is still called the Arrivals Department.'")
- asah 4y ago(IANAL) Reading this case, I'm surprised at the outcome. The seller fulfilled on the terms of the contract. The contract also didn't specify the precise color or weight of the cotton, the exact destination, etc etc etc so the defendant could make similar claims to renege on the contract. Granted, time is arguably special inasmuch as it allows the seller to construct a scenario for fulfillment, e.g. the seller could've delivered 100 years later on a new boat that happened to be named Peerless. That's clearly not the intent. In that sense, a contract can be considered void if it doesn't reasonably specify time.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> In that sense, a contract can be considered void if it doesn't reasonably specify time. The judgment states pretty clearly that a contract is void if the two parties, at the time they made the contract, did not agree on what it meant. > the moment it appears that two ships called the “Peerless” were about to sail from Bombay there is a latent ambiguity, and parol evidence may be given for the purpose of shewing that the defendant meant one “Peerless,” and the plaintiff another. That being so, there was no consensus ad idem, and therefore no binding contract. [The words are from the defendant's lawyer, but the court appears to have agreed immediately.] So this isn't formally a "win" for the defendant - formally, there never was a contract, and the suit was dismissed for failure to state a claim.
- asah 4y agoMy point is that NO CONTRACT perfectly spells out every detail => this argument can be used to null any contract => weak legal reasoning. A buyer could make up any sort of nonsense to escape a contract, like (to pick a random example) arguing that a certain social media site has x% fake accounts. Far stronger reasoning (for example) is that a contract must spell out time, which is a special property of contracts because (for example) 1000000 years is virtually never an acceptable period for which to fulfill on your end of a contract.
- NoboruWataya 4y agoThis isn't really how contract law works. There may be minor details that are not specified in the contract but unless it can be proven in court that those details were actually within the contemplation of one of the parties and connected to his or her decision to enter into the contract, their absence would not be sufficient to nullify the contract. A contract is an agreement, so it stands to reason that if the parties do not, in fact, agree, there is no contract. The piece of paper we call a contract is, in fact, only a (strong) evidential tool to help the court figure out what the parties agreed. > Far stronger reasoning (for example) is that a contract must spell out time, which is a special property of contracts because (for example) 1000000 years is virtually never an acceptable period for which to fulfill on your end of a contract. How is this "far stronger reasoning"? It isn't even reasoning at all, because there is no existing rule that a contract must spell out time, so it's simply an untruth. Unless you were suggesting that the court create a new rule out of nowhere that all contracts must spell out the time for performance or else become void. A court would obviously never do that in light of the huge disruption it would cause.
- magicalhippo 4y agoWe encounter this all the time at work. New customer, so new integration. What's your unique shipment reference? This one? Ok fine. Go into production, and after a few months we get missing shipments. Support check, missing shipments have same reference as old shipments. "Oh, yeah we reuse the references after about 90 days... And, no, we don't have any globally unique references." This is fun when so much of the flow is based on these references, think goods arrival scanning, and sometimes shipping does take a long time so 90 days or whatever is cutting it close.
- auggierose 4y agoWhy would you ever reuse an identifier like that? Is there some kind of material cost associated with a new identifier?
- magicalhippo 4y agoThis is what we've never understood. Trying to ask why is almost always futile, the people who're there now never knows. I suspect it's often some legacy stuff, like a certain system only had 6 chars available for the reference, and so that's how they ended up working around it and nobody realized that limitation no longer exists. But yeah, does not make much sense to us either.
- namdnay 4y agoJust like passenger name records - 6 characters for legacy reasons, so they’re constantly recycled
- martyvis 4y agoIs it a fully computerised B2B system? I mean when I order some patch cables for a project, I do it via a web shop and pay with my corporate credit card. The vendor generates an order number but also asks me for customer purchase order reference. I just make something up that might have my initials and date and a serial like "MV-20220723-1". Others may not be so methodical.
- petesergeant 4y ago> Consequently, as there was no consensus ad idem ("meeting of the minds"), the two parties did not agree to the same thing and there was no binding contract ... therefore, the [buyer] did not have to pay.