5 ms·
So my understanding here is that the largest consumer of water in most (all?) of the places served by the Colorado River is still agriculture. The article hint
by kelnos 4y ago
So my understanding here is that the largest consumer of water in most (all?) of the places served by the Colorado River is still agriculture. The article hints at fallout from this around 2/3 of the way through, when talking about grocery prices going up due to water scarcity (the hypothetical $14 head of lettuce).
Why do we still do so much farming in regions that have such marginal water supplies? Are there no better-irrigated places in the US to grow all these crops? Obviously all these farms can't move overnight, and presumably the owners of the farms wouldn't be happy with their revenue moving elsewhere, but it seems necessary.
Has farming been slowly (too slowly?) moving out of these water-strapped regions? Or are they just all sitting there, expecting someone else to bear the brunt of the problem? I know there have been shenanigans with farmers deliberately growing water-hungry crops because the water allocations have always been a "use it or lose it" system. That is apparently changing (far too late, IMO); do we expect this to have a meaningful impact?
Either way, I would suggest that it's a lot easier to move farming activities to regions with a more stable water supply (assuming such regions exist) than it is to move hundreds of cities of people.
- Aarostotle 4y agoI am not a farmer nor an expert. My guess: Drier areas have fewer pests, less rain means there is less risk of flooding or crops washing away, and problems like mold or rot are rarer. Also, the sun is always shining. More photosynthesis means happier plants. I hope someone here can share the details of the economics here. It's probably a very interesting cost-benefit analysis.
- mc32 4y agoHistorically these areas supported very low population densities so it wasn’t a problem. The lab was fertile but arid: enter waterworks and irrigation. Great fecund farmland! For a few adventurous farmers. And then came the droves upon droves upon droves of people who now live in what is arid but land of mild climate and desert land, but for artificial irrigation.
- bloudermilk 4y agoAdd to that: proximity to major ports for international distribution and no tornadoes or hail
- steve_adams_86 4y ago> Are there no better-irrigated places in the US to grow all these crops? There are plenty of better irrigated places, but none so warm and bright. I think that's a major challenge; the amount of light and heat south and west from Colorado is incredible, and growing a lot of crops without that year-round opportunity and productivity is virtually impossible. There is also the problem that places with naturally high amounts of rain tend to have more acidic, treed, less arable soils. Around the Colorado river there were of course dry, barely arable, hard-to-farm lands which required extensive conditioning, but a lot of it mostly required water to bring it to life. Some of the ecology was oak meadow or brush, which was far easier to convert to farm land than a cedar and fir forest. Another thing to consider is that the rest of the USA, including places with more water, are already growing other crops. The centre of the USA from north to south is quite active in agriculture, and actually more so than the east and west. If you wanted to grow more things away from the Colorado River, where would you do it? We need more arable land, we need to grow more climate-appropriate crops, and... Well, we need to eat more plants. We can get by just fine if we dedicate fewer crops and less water to raising meat. It's a hard solution psychologically, but an extremely effective one technically.
- pasttense01 4y agoWell remember that 40% of the U.S. corn crop is used to produce ethanol. Ethanol use can be eliminated (electric cars and getting rid of the ethanol subsidies...). Land and climate good enough for corn is good enough for other crops.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoAbsolutely, corn is a very nutrient, heat, and light intensive crop. The added buffer would allow for doing crop rotations including more legumes and cover crops to reduce fertilizer usage. If we need to grow less food, we can be less demanding from the soil as well. Perhaps we could build soil rather than destroy it. Several studies show that these models yield excellent crops with fewer inputs, but it’s hard as hell to compete when you go low and slow with ag. I suppose as long as we want to export food, we’ll need to continue our insane resource intensive methods, ignoring the externalities, in order to stay competitive.
- thematrixturtle 4y agoNot so hypothetical: here's a $11.99 lettuce in Australia last month. (Admittedly 'only' $8.30 in freedom dollars.) https://www.theguardian.com/food/2022/jun/03/why-does-this-iceberg-lettuce-cost-1199-and-how-long-will-australias-high-vegetable-prices-last https://www.theguardian.com/food/2022/jun/03/why-does-this-i...
- i_am_proteus 4y agoThe sun shines a lot more in California and Arizona (those are yer big Colorado river agricultural states) than it does other places. So, with enough water, the yield per acre of land per year is rather high. The same sun shines during a lot more of the year in CA and AZ. Folks like their year-round fresh vegetables. Even with a good hot house in the middle West or the north East, the yield per acre per year won't be as high. Until the water runs out in the Western states, after which I reckon it'll be quite a bit higher.
- justinpombrio 4y ago> Why do we still do so much farming in regions that have such marginal water supplies? Often farmers don't pay for their water usage. Instead they paid once, long ago, for the right to some portion of the river (not sure how that's measured). As a result the amount that a farmer would save by halving their water usage is often $0, so they don't. (This is my understanding. I heard it specifically in the context of California but assume it happens elsewhere too. Would be very interested to hear more from someone who knows the details.)
- gammarator 4y ago“First in time, first in right.” https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-drought-imperial-valley-20150412-story.html#page=1 https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-drought-imper...
- masklinn 4y ago> As a result the amount that a farmer would save by halving their water usage is often $0, so they don't. It’s even worse than that, these rights are on a “use it or lose it” basis, so not only do farmers pay very little for the water, they’re incentivised to use all they can on extremely water-intensive crops and methods, and waste the rest. The Colorado water compact is complete insanity. And acquirer management is no better.
- darth_avocado 4y agoWe farm in Central Valley California because it has year round sunshine and good soil. California no doubt uses more water than it is allocated, but about 80% of water usage is in agriculture. And when we say agriculture it’s not just almonds that use a lot of water, it’s also Alfa Alfa and regular pastures that go in cattle feed. And despite having a much smaller percentage of the country’s farms, it produces the most amount of food. A third of the country’s vegetables and two thirds of fresh fruits and nuts are grown in California. If we could farm better elsewhere, we actually would.
- CameronNemo 4y agoDoes the central valley use Colorado river water? I was under the impression they get all their water from California (esp northern areas).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- labrador 4y ago> Does the central valley use Colorado river water? No. Eastern Sierra Nevada Mountain water goes to L.A., Western Sierra water goes to the Central Valley and S.F. The Imperial Valley area of the lowest part of S. California uses Colorado River water.
- guelo 4y agoNo. Most Colorado river water is used for farming in the southern deserts of Imperial and Riverside counties.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoDo they still have good soil? Somebody told me that Napa valley has killed its soil by using extremely aggressive grow techniques.
- jfoutz 4y agoGood farmland also kinda turns into cities. I don't think anybody is really into bulldozing Orange County, but I think the humidity is enough that orange trees don't need a whole lot of extra water. Manhattan was also (apparently) pretty great farmland. It would have been cool if we'd built the cities out in the desert - people need water, but it's just not the same scale. Then we could have left the great farmland for farming. We'd probably find a way to screw it up regardless. Tigris Euphrates was apparently paradise back in the day, same for the Nile. To my modern eye, they're all pretty much known for sand now. Honestly it's pretty incredible we're, well let me rephrase that. It's incredible _you_ produce so much from a damn near desert. I get it's easier to move water than homes. Shame the good land with plenty of water got built over.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Why do we still do so much farming in regions that have such marginal water supplies? Because they are ideal in other ways (potential growing season, soil, etc.) and people like to eat. > Are there no better-irrigated places in the US to grow all these crops Probably not that don't have other disadvantages, if they aren't already being used for agriculture. Note that about 52% of US land area is already used for that purpose.
- femiagbabiaka 4y agoAgriculture here means mostly feed for livestock. Decreasing meat production and consumption would do an immense amount.
- californical 4y ago> Why do we still do so much farming in regions that have such marginal water supplies? You know how you can still buy fresh fruits and vegetables at the grocery store in the middle of winter? Lots of those are grown in the western deserts. If you’re willing to give up year-round fresh produce, we could consider removing farming from these areas. But most people wouldn’t want that.
- pjc50 4y ago> Why do we still do so much farming in regions that have such marginal water supplies? If a region has surplus water, and is reasonably flat, it will get used for agriculture until it becomes marginal. Also global warming is changing the distribution of rainfall and evaporation, so that there may be less water available in the first place. > Are there no better-irrigated places in the US to grow all these crops? "There's a great region for agriculture here, but we have nobody to farm it" -- a thing nobody has said in the US since about the foundation of Oklahoma