4 ms·
Isn't it sad that Elon has been so successful with Tesla and SpaceX, revolutionary success at that, that people feel impelled to dis him? Let's face facts. Wit
by WalterBright 4y ago
Isn't it sad that Elon has been so successful with Tesla and SpaceX, revolutionary success at that, that people feel impelled to dis him?
Let's face facts. Without Elon, there would be no SpaceX, and no Tesla. Musk deserves credit for two great achievements.
- camdat 4y agoTesla already existed before Elon. Can you make the case that they wouldn't have been as successful without him? I don't see any specific performance that would indicate that he's instrumental to their success.
- jdross 4y agoI hope this is trolling because the details of this are widely reported and discoverable. There is no Tesla without Elon, and there barely was an entity called Tesla before Elon. Even with Elon the company barely made it many times
- camdat 4y ago> Even with Elon the company barely made it many times This is the crux of my argument. If Tesla failed, would it been because of Elon? Did X.com, Boring Co., etc fail because of Elon?
- WalterBright 4y agoYes and yes.
- camdat 4y agoIf I were to argue that Tesla succeeded in spite of Elon, how would you disprove that? I could point to his bitcoin investments, many discrimination cases, failure to release Autopilot (against his own promises), SEC action, and Tesla share price manipulation as examples of him hurting the companies success, and directly connect them to his actions. Could you do the same for the companies success?
- WalterBright 4y ago> how would you disprove that? Easy. Nobody else's electric car company succeeded. What's the common factor in Tesla's and SpaceX's highly unlikely successes? Elon Musk. What's the common factor in Pixar's and Apple's recovery from near bankruptcy and catapulting to the top? Steve Jobs.
- camdat 4y ago> Easy. Nobody else's electric car company succeeded. Define "succeeded"? Tesla was definitely not first to market, Ford is expected to surpass them in EV cars shipped by end of this year, and Tesla is well known for their poor car QA + service (as an owner myself). The comparison between Steve Jobs and Elon Musk is very apt, but I think you lack the historical knowledge to understand why that is.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Define "succeeded"? You might not be aware that your replies to me have exhibited 3 characteristics of losing the point: 1. inserting extra words into what I wrote so you can then attack the strawman 2. diversion into arguing about the meaning of words 3. lobbing a personal insult I'm sure you can do better.
- camdat 4y agoI'm aware. It's difficult to have a causational discussion with someone continually using correlational evidence. If I say with "provide a reason why Elon is necessary to the success of the company", and you respond with "Look at the success of these two companies he led" that's completely tangential to the question. So in exchange for "doing better" answer a simple question for me: What specific actions did Elon take that led to the success of Tesla and/or SpaceX? I've provided several specific actions that were to the detriment of Tesla, so it should be straightforward to do the inverse.
- WalterBright 4y agoYes, I know he bought a struggling company. > Can you make the case that they wouldn't have been as successful without him? Easy. They never, ever would have sold it to Musk if they knew it could be such a runaway success and make them container ships full of money. They had no idea how to do it. Musk did.
- camdat 4y agoSo the willingness of the founder to stay/leave is the only metric for the long-term success of the company?
- WalterBright 4y agoDid I say "only"? Nope.
- camdat 4y agoThen how is that a convincing argument that Elon is the reason that Tesla is successful.
- WalterBright 4y agoYou're confusing Elon with the founders.
- camdat 4y agoHow so?
- WalterBright 4y agoA => B does not mean B => A
- andrepd 4y agoMan I had no idea that Tesla had only one employee! It's nothing short of amazing that Musk can design and implement a car and a rocket from the ground up and still have spare time to man the machines in the factories and shitpost on twitter every day! My respect for him grew immensely.
- bell-cot 4y agoI'm sure it's just random chance that Elan has been very closely involved in managing 2 different companies (SpaceX, Tesla) which have seen such massive growth over the past 2 decades. /s By your "make the case" criteria - has there been any business leader who clearly deserved credit?
- camdat 4y agoSurvivorship bias. Elon has led many failed companies, success doesn't imply correlation.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm sure Michael Jordan has missed many shots at the basket, too.
- camdat 4y agoThis is a great analogy. Would you say that Michael Jordan is only successful because of the owner of the team he played for?
- WalterBright 4y agoJordan was successful on more than one team. Other players on the same team were not remotely as successful.
- camdat 4y agoAwesome, so we agree that Elon isn't attributable for the success of Tesla. The owner of the team matters less to the success of the team than the participants, as is easily proven by the argument you have just made. If Elon had consistently led successful teams, as Jordan has, then the correlationary argument would be more convincing. Since he has led a mix of failures and successes, the likely indicator is the teams that worked for him, not his own ability.
- superchroma 4y agoI don't feel pushed to dislike him for his success, I think the way he leverages his unmatched popularity and global reach to manipulate markets (whether pumping bit/dogecoin or promising FSD by a date) is not in line with the standard of excellence he has otherwise delivered with Tesla and SpaceX. It smacks of either a disdain for investors or a desire to attain even more wealth (or both), neither of which is is particularly flattering. That's really my primary complaint. He shouldn't be let off the hook for allegations of racism at his firms either, but that's between claimants and him, nothing to do with me.
- bell-cot 4y agoYour "facts" viewpoint appears to be based in a multi-dimensional model of human achievement - wherein a person can be great in some dimensions, but far less admirable in others. Most people have a far more scalar worldview. :(
- WalterBright 4y agoYes, I'm well acquainted with the popular stance of focusing on a great person's irrelevant flaws, and justifying it as having some sort of "balance". Even Einstein has been attacked in this way. People try to dismiss him as a great man because he treated his wife poorly. Steve Jobs disowned his daughter. He rooked Woz in the Atari deal. He's been nasty to a lot of people. It doesn't detract from his incredible success. The point is, we all have our flaws, and zeroing in on a great person's flaws as a way to diminish his achievements is, frankly, small and petty.
- peddling-brink 4y agoWhy shouldn't we remember that great people often have great flaws? They aren't gods. They have a particular set of skills and circumstances that made them wildly successful. And that's great, but it doesn't mean they aren't human, with human flaws.
- memish 4y agoIt's a tell tale sign of one's own insecurity when they obsess over the flaws of achievers. "nu uh! they suck because unrelated thing" is an expression of insecurity.
- bell-cot 4y agoJudging by (say) the success of the British tabloid press, there are a whole lotta petty & vindictive little people in this world. But when it is less malicious, public, and monetized, such a focus-on-flaws way of viewing people would seem to have some utilitarian value. Regular news of palace scandals does not do much damage to the national welfare. Vs. having a very flaw-focused outlook on whether the great, royal Prince Andrew should be trusted around your under-age daughter might prove extremely beneficial...
- jfengel 4y agoHe does deserve credit for two great achievements. But that credit does not extend to letting him get away with being an asshole. He is frequently deliberately offensive. He promotes dubious ventures. He's frequently in trouble with the SEC for violating securities rules, including the latest debacle with Twitter. He has been over-promising and under-delivering on Tesla's FSD for a really long time. I own Tesla stock because I believe in the company and think it has, and will, do great things. But that doesn't make Musk less of a jackass.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm not suggesting Musk should "get away" with doing bad things. I am saying it does not diminish his contributions. Being a jackass is hardly the worst thing a person could be. In fact, it's pretty ordinary. We've all been a jackass in our own lives here and there.
- ahahahahah 4y agoWhat great achievement is Tesla? They caused the entire industry to delay broader releases of electric vehicles because they didn't want to compete with a company willing to lose $10k per vehicle.
- peddling-brink 4y agoWhat industry? Tesla reinvigorated that industry. Did the miss when the EV2 was going to be released?
- retrocryptid 4y agoTesla did a very good job marketing battery technology from energy.gov with the $1.2B Nevada gave them. A lesser man would have squandered all that cash. In all seriousness, however, Musk did a great job of convincing Compass and SDL to give Eberhart and Tarpenning money.
- retrocryptid 4y agoIt allows rich people in California drive in the HOV lane when they're alone in their cars. That's a pretty good trick.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y ago> Without Elon, there would be no SpaceX, and no Tesla. Musk deserves credit for two great achievements. You achieve something when as a CEO you sign off a consequential improvement in the quality of life of a lot of people, then you pass the baton and the company is still there. Tesla is just a car company that jumped early on a quite singular and unprecedented political trend (limiting ourselves for the benefit of people who'd be alive 150 years from now). If the unprecedented trend disappears, so will Tesla. Space has been driving big entities out of business ever since the Apollo program days, there is no quality of life and no ROI for us up there. Musk has nothing in the bag as a matter of accomplishments because his companies are not 'in the bag' type companies. Examples of 'in the bag' type companies are : Microsoft, Google, Facebook, Amazon, Tencent, Exxon, Shell etc. He's essentially a politician
- TMWNN 4y ago>Isn't it sad that Elon has been so successful with Tesla and SpaceX, revolutionary success at that, that people feel impelled to dis him? "I'm not at all an Elon fanboi, but" is just a variant of "I hate Trump, but".
- retrocryptid 4y agoThat's an interesting viewpoint. I'm sure if Mueller hadn't been there, Elon would have been just as successful launching Dneiprs to orbit.