3 ms·
Also anyone who used the results without sufficient due diligence should be barred from working as researcher or receiving grant money. They are not quilt free
by Ekaros 4y ago
Also anyone who used the results without sufficient due diligence should be barred from working as researcher or receiving grant money. They are not quilt free either.
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoWhat is due diligence though? Are they supposed to do a forensic analysis of every paper they cite? It's sad if it's arrived to this point. Reproducing the original result can be prohibitively expensive and difficult in many fields (ideally, this wouldn't be a concern - but generally, research groups aren't rolling in cash and resources, plus you need to be fast not to get scooped for the next paper and lose future grant money)
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoGiven the replication crisis, more questions should be asked. Everyone knows a disturbingly large number of papers are on shaky foundations, but nobody is good at picking which ones
- dash2 4y agoSteady on now. Scientists rely on each other, they're not supposed to be fraud investigators.
- evandijk70 4y agoWhat about a researcher that measures the kinetics of AB-aggregation in vivo, performs X-Ray crystallography to determine the structure of this (or another amyloid), or performs simulations to determine free binding energies of various antibodies with the oligomer and cites this paper as the reason it has clinical relevance? I know people in the field that do all this kind of research and do not know much about mice-experiments or even about the experimental techniques used to obtain these results. To me, they are victims of this fraud more than anything.