4 ms·
To the extent either of those is a problem, it would be much better to raise a flag, investigate, diagnose, and resolve it outside of scoring system. Especially
by dragonwriter 4y ago
To the extent either of those is a problem, it would be much better to raise a flag, investigate, diagnose, and resolve it outside of scoring system. Especially since the problem with the latter could well be that the institution doesn't offer challenging enough courses.
Also, I don't think most individual exams in courses have enough test-retest validity for an individual score to be a strong signal that either of these problems exists. For a course with a large number of exams (more typical of secondary than higher ed, IMO) you might diagnose a problem by a consistent pattern of very high scores, but an individual score is too weak of a signal.
If you penalize high grades, people will try to avoid them by intentionally dropping answers if they feel too good, and then the utility of your scores for assessing anything, goes down.