2 ms·
I understand all that perfectly fine. I didn't say that I would decrease public land, simply that these organizations should focus on making the conserved land
by giantg2 4y ago
I understand all that perfectly fine.
I didn't say that I would decrease public land, simply that these organizations should focus on making the conserved land public. Often times land is willed to the trust and then the trust sells it. This keeps it in private circulation when it could be made public access.
Why would a private individual go through the legal risks of opening their land to the public? I highly doubt these lands will become public access in the future as there's zero incentive for it, despite the joke you stated.
Land is finite. By placing the restriction on some parcels, that makes it much less likely to find unrestricted parcels due to the demand. Also, people don't live forever. Putting a restriction on future generations is not something of their choosing.
My experience with these land trusts has been negative. A friend bought one that permits agricultural use. They wanted to put down gravel in an area for that purpose. The trust said that couldn't do that because it's impermeable... perhaps we can go to the desert and leave you there for a few days with 5 gallons of water poured on a gravel pile. If it's really impermeable, then you'll be fine. The point is, you have to deal with idiots like this and risk getting into legal battle that will exhaust your resources to enforce your (limited) rights on the land.
If effect you end up with extremely powerful organizations that have rights over an increasing amount of land, while the "owners" have to bear all the costs and comply. Sounds a lot like being a serf or tenant farmer to me. Is there some choice in there? Not much if you want land. The vast majority of people can't afford real land in the areas where these trusts (and billionaires) are operating, pricing them out due to the constrained supply.
- atourgates 4y ago> "Why would a private individual go through the legal risks of opening their land to the public? I highly doubt these lands will become public access in the future as there's zero incentive for it, despite the joke you stated." Because they're community-minded, and doing that aligns with their values? Our small local land trust is currently in the final stages of two easements brought to us by private landowners who wanted to open their land to the public. One of them was I would say "community" oriented, in that their land had been informally open to the public, and they wanted to formalize that access, and use it to educate the public on the value of the ecosystems in place there. The other is I would say is also community minded, but coming more from a place of principle in that they believe more people opening their land to public use is the right thing to do, and what we should be doing as a society. It also helps that in our state, liability for public access is essentially zero, and we have very strong legal protections for landowners who open their land. > Is there some choice in there? Not much if you want land. Don't buy land that's encumbered by an easement? But it's gonna cost you more. IDK about your friend's specific situation, but one of the big benefits of agricultural easements is that they significantly reduce the value of the land, allowing (perhaps) people like your friend to afford to buy farm land who wouldn't otherwise be able to. In the area we operate, agricultural land has shot up from about $5K/acre, to $20K+/acre in less than a decade. At those prices, no family farmers can afford to buy farm land, and the only people who can farm are multi-generational farming families who bought land decades ago and haven't sold out yet, or large corporate farms. But that price increase is being driven by developers who want to build houses. Take away that ability, and suddenly new farmers just starting out can afford to buy some land to farm on. True, they don't have the freedom to turn around and sell that land to housing developers, but I think that hardly turns them into serfs.