3 ms·
Or self-driving cars. Every incident is Big News, while ignoring the fact that 40,000 people die every year in traffic accidents (and 4.8 million injuries) -- i
by jfengel 4y ago
Or self-driving cars. Every incident is Big News, while ignoring the fact that 40,000 people die every year in traffic accidents (and 4.8 million injuries) -- in the US alone.
People are of course famously bad at putting statistics into context.
- intrepidhero 4y agoIt's not just that people are bad at statistics (we are though). It's also that we place value on individual agency. Getting into a self-driving car (or onto a train) means giving up some of my agency and because of that I have higher expectations of safety from the self-driving car (or train driver) than I would if I had retained that agency. I don't think that's weird or unreasonable. We do need to get better at statistics and realizing that when we take on risk, we rarely are the only person impacted if something goes sideways. When I take the wheel of a car I become a risk myself and to others and I need to place as much value on their agency as my own.
- djmips 4y agoI completely agree that we put a lot of value into personal agency but I do think it's a bit unreasonable. Agency when driving is only perceived. You could have a heart attack and smash into pedestrians. Your car could fail mechanically. You could be rear ended by a large truck. You could be killed by a drunk or inattentive driver. Your agency can not entirely prevent that. Also you may be in the top percentile in driving but like everything, everyone thinks they are a great driver so you can't take how you feel and generalize it to the population. I'm not arguing that self driving cars are solved but maybe they aren't quite as bad as people feel. We need proper statistics.
- intrepidhero 4y agoThat's a great point. Often the perceived agency is an illusion.
- simion314 4y ago>People are of course famously bad at putting statistics into context. We can\t , current self driving is limited in many ways and Tesla is notorious for having the driver save the day multiple time in 30 minutes and Elon is not publishing this incidents. I can't stand the fanboys coming up with fake stats that only 5 people ddied this month in a Tesla where in fact you have video evidence of more people would have died if the driver would have not saved the AI, A Tesla employee should leak the data and we should then talk about stats, do Tesla saves the driver more then the driver saves the car. (i know that in reality FSD does not mean what the words imply and OP probably had no idea that there are no real FSD cars around that drive with no limitation so we can do real statistics)
- criley2 4y agoThe accident rate for "self-driving cars" (a nebulous term including both actually autonomous cars like waymo cars as well as driver-attention-required cars operating under the false advertising of "full self driving") is higher than human operated cars. Currently "self driving cars" get in twice as many accidents as humans do per million miles driven.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- belorn 4y agoIt wasn't that long ago that a driver instructor illustrated in a video how often they needed to correct the self-driving car in order to drive legal. It was multiple corrections per minute in a busy city. In term of statistics, the error rates of human drivers are still lower than current self-driving technology. This is why the only certified fully self-driving mode is limited in Germany to operate at speed of less than 30 km/h, only on highways with congestion, and then outside any construction zones.
- mwint 4y agoI mean, how often would the instructor need to correct a human to drive legal in a busy city? The null hypothesis here is that driving legally in big cities is not practical.
- UncleMeat 4y agoI'll never forget driving across Georgia on Jan 1st a bunch of years ago. They've got signs up that say to drive safely and show how many traffic fatalities there have been in the state that year. On a random day it just looks like a number. But driving on the highway and passing a sign that said how many people had died today doing precisely what I was doing at that moment was affecting.
- Spivak 4y agoAssuming people are ignorant en masse says more about your understanding of people than the people. Not all self driving car accidents make the news — self driving car accidents that any human diver could have easily avoided make the news. Statistically safer something something miles driven means nothing to the family of someone who died in a completely avoidable accident. Until self driving cars reach the point of handing emergency situations — storms, ice, obstacles, children, other accidents, sudden lane changes, tire blowouts — better than humans and stop punting anything less than ideal conditions back to the driver it’s pointless to talk about safety.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoSelf-driving cars aren't safer than humans, though, and I doubt they ever will be. All the real love for self-driving cars seems to be in the US, where they are basically competing with completely untrained drivers and a strong drink-driving culture. No self-driving car on the road today would even come close to passing a UK driving test. They wouldn't last the first five minutes.
- sixQuarks 4y agoEvery time I bring this up when Tesla bashing is going on here, I get downvoted. The hate for Elon here blinds people to statistics