4 ms·
I cannot even quote those blasphemies. Sure, if you believe you are born to yell at cars or whatever, the day you will do something different will be for the e
by mdp2021 4y ago
I cannot even quote those blasphemies.
Sure, if you believe you are born to yell at cars or whatever, the day you will do something different will be for the enjoyment of a duly exceptional vacation. But if you do not see the value of something, all chances are the issue is with your "eyes".
Incidentally: among the well recognized functions of books, they are there to have selected, better company that those in mentioned "social networks gone bad" - even taking special cases into account. (Of course, you have to be able to perceive what "better" is.)
- xsmasher 4y agoCan you rewrite or break down your last sentence? I can not understand it.
- bityard 4y agoIt's not worth the bother. This is an exceptionally good example of intentionally obtuse writing, otherwise better known as good old fashioned BS!
- mdp2021 4y agoIf you cannot understand what people write, of course it will appear BS to you. The writing from here looks like the right one. Edit: about that «'intentionally'»: this is the way I think, this is the way I write. (Not precisely so, but the expression will be clear enough to those who want to understand it.)
- mdp2021 4y agoNo problem! > among the well recognized functions of books, they are there to have selected, better company that those in mentioned "social networks gone bad" - even taking special cases into account. (Of course, you have to be able to perceive what "better" is.) -- The text of a book represents, in the "good cases", an as-best-organized-as-possible expression of the refined thought of an author. That communication from such author is "company" you choose. It is a "selected acquaintance", picked to enrich you. It can be better than many other options, which will contain less value. -- With possible exceptions of very selected containers (whatever their elected term - 'subs'?) in «mentioned "social networks gone bad"», the general quality in the content found by commenters is very, very poor. So, the competition with a selected writer would be "not in the same league". If you took special cases of very well moderated, luckier containers, the collective effort could bring special value, yet we would be comparing quite different things (and the book would still be superior in some areas, e.g. structure). -- So, you may compare "material intended for growth" (the book) and "an involving experience" (the popular social network), but of course there is value to be recognized in order to appreciate the difference. You have to be able to recognize "better company" - otherwise, of course you will see little difference.
- alexb_ 4y agoTranslation into actual English: >I think you are very wrong. >Sure, if you think you were born to have fun, doing something such as reading books will be "fun" too, since it's different from your normal life. But you aren't actually seeing the real value in reading. >One of the main reasons books exist is so my company can be more "high-class", since those who don't read often are usually not as fun to hang out with. FTR I think this is an insane way of thinking, but I thought I would try and translate it to the best of my ability to words people can actually understand
- mdp2021 4y agoYou have translated it, and you have not understood it. The correct approach with text is to give an interpretation and a level of confidence - and wait until the confidence is high. I do not think the ideas of the poster are just "wrong" (though it's a very good term, originally meaning "giving the reaction of disgust (which can also be given by disapproval)"): I wrote «blasphemies» because the depreciate what has high value. And those mentions of «high-class» and «fun to hang out with» are completely out of what was meant. And completely out of perspective: nobody told you you are there to have "fun". And one does not even meet people for "fun". It's your time, you are not there to waste it; "fun" is one part of it - "break", "completeness", "recovery" or whatever. More that "«insane»", that way of thinking would be "childish" (and surely more), but it was not what was expressed - you put that in. And your reading fails on the guidelines about "strongest plausible interpretation" and "assum[ption of] good faith". Edit: Nonetheless, the translation «Sure, if you think you were born to have fun, doing something such as reading books will be "fun" too, since it's different from your normal life. But you aren't actually seeing the real value in reading» was quite close to the original intention - though not overlapping. With "«yell at cars»", for example, I meant to stress the improductive side, the "consuming the day without much focus on growth". In the idea that the opposite of "growth" is "waste" ("fun" already may contain some value).
- zemvpferreira 4y agoI grew up in a family of bibliophiles. When my grandfather died, I helped move part of his collection of thirty nine thousand books from the three apartments where he kept them. Thankfully he had files on all of them so it was not a big process to select which to keep, which to give and which to auction. One of his two deathbed regrets on was not acquiring a certain first edition when he had a chance, I believe these days. He was, as I am and my father is, a very well-read man. It hasn't made us better people but it's sure made it easy to spot silly pseudointellectual BS. Books are just dead trees wrapped in dead cows. I keep maybe 20 in my house. No better or worse than trying to signal with a Rolex or an instagram following. No better to learn from than YouTube or HN or any number of street corner conversations. Get your head out of your ass.
- mdp2021 4y agoAnd that «pseudointellectual BS» would be mine? If so, is not that contradictory with your statement that being «very well-read» gave you abilities for discrimination? (Note: if the above is correct, and they are incomplete, then it's duly to roll the sleeves again, and be back to the "discrimination builders". Like for all of us.) I am not sure about that «trying to signal»: it seems as if you interpret that somebody uses books to "show off". That would be completely nonfactual. They are there for you, why should one use them to display - that would be strongly inconsistent with their nature. Now the core point: ** books are explicitly the concretion of an effort towards development ** as such, they are symbol and object "incarnating" something very high. I do not understand the expression «Get your head out of your ass», but I consider it a friendly encouragement, for which I am sincerely grateful. To actually meet in communication, we would probably need more exchange though - I think we have probably not understood each other.
- GoodbyeMrChips 4y ago> No better or worse than trying to signal with..... "Signalling" ? Part of me has just died. Have you ever thought about not giving a toss what others think and just reading?
- mdp2021 4y ago
- throwaway675309 4y ago"Incidentally: among the well recognized functions of books, they are there to have selected, better company that those in mentioned "social networks gone bad" - even taking special cases into account. (Of course, you have to be able to perceive what "better" is.)" Zounds, this might be the most deliberately obfuscated and yet simultaneously poorly written diatribe I've ever read. You seem to possess a penchant for verbosity but an inability to smoothly couple your thoughts together. And yes, just like any physical matter from a hobby, it can act as either a beacon or a warning signal to other like-minded people.
- mdp2021 4y agoYou are the second one going along the lines of "deliberately obfuscated": I do not see why, it seems to me "deliberately properly written and clear"! «Verbosity»: it seems to me condensed, precise... Where is the "extra fat"? Edit: to show that «inability» you mention, somebody should provide better expressions. Mine are constructed with much consideration, and I have not found examples of better equivalents. Help me/us instead with your «And yes ... like-minded people»: I do not understand it. (I do not understand «physical matter from a hobby», and I do not understand what is 'it' that «can act as either...».)
- LesZedCB 4y agoto help you understand: you wear a band t-shirt, you meet people who like the band. the fact you think you're being highly precise and terse and laughable at best. the guilletes are absolutely pretentious as fuck. I assume for somebody like you, your favorite fictional character is Ignatius Reilly. something about feeling seen
- mdp2021 4y ago> laughable at best You can have all the reactions available in the drawer, but without "showing why" they are pretty wasted expressions. > guilletes I have no idea what that is. A web search did not reveal anything. > Ignatius Reilly Not acquainted, sorry. > feeling seen No idea what you are trying to say. Who should "feel seen"? In which terms, paranoia? Look: sorry, but I hope you do not consider yourself clear in turn. > you wear a band t-shirt, you meet people who like the band Ok, but I do not see how this is relevant to this whole discussion. > being highly precise and terse Sure, that is part of the attempt. The burden to interpret, analyze and synthesize etc., remains with the other side. I try to be as precise as possible to facilitate that (meaning: when you analyze something, the "mechanism breaks" if the pieces are "loose", "ill chosen").