3 ms·
The problem is that separation of powers make most frauds a state matter. If you were ripped off in NY, a local county district attorney would prosecute you. T
by Spooky23 4y ago
The problem is that separation of powers make most frauds a state matter. If you were ripped off in NY, a local county district attorney would prosecute you.
The problem with that is state laws and capabilities are inconsistent. Even in New York, where there is a well established body of law for things like financial frauds, the local prosecutors make lack capability or venue. If you live in Lake Placid, NY and are scammed, it’s unlikely that the Essex County DA (probably 4 attorneys) has the capability to prosecute a complex financial crime. If you live in Manhattan, different story - that DA has thousands of attorneys and expertise.
The Federal government side-steps turf issues and inequity by using more “umbrella” laws that are easy to approve. If you commit a fraud that has a connection to the mail, “Mail Fraud”. If you use a phone, “Wire Fraud”. If you take money that isn’t yours from an FDIC insured bank, that’s a Federal crime. If you lie to a Federal agent, that’s a crime.
- stingraycharles 4y agoOh, this makes sense: since mail and phone spans the whole nation instead of states, it becomes a federal matter?
- Spooky23 4y agoYou got it. A lot of newer or expansive federal powers are based on interpretations of the power to regulate interstate commerce. The Senate is by design very conservative (or regressive depending on POV). Stuff gets done by squinting at the law and finding new ways to get shut done.