4 ms·
I am saying disabled people should pay more, and the state should give them free money to cover the higher costs they incur for day to day services. Trying to
by londons_explore 4y ago
I am saying disabled people should pay more, and the state should give them free money to cover the higher costs they incur for day to day services.
Trying to get every business to charge all customers equally, even when some customers are far more costly to serve is a bad model. Better to just let the business charge whatever the real cost of providing the service is, and directly subsidize the disabled person to cover that increased cost.
/Unpopular opinion
- foobiekr 4y agoWhy should the state subsidize Uber?
- alistairSH 4y agoThat's the wrong view. The state is subsidizing the disabled residents, so they can live their lives without undue burden. Those subsidizes might be used with Uber or a regular cab or some other transit provider.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoIf you reimburse Uber use, they'll nonzero amount of times choose Uber, keeping them in business.
- alistairSH 4y agoAnd? We wouldn’t be reimbursing just for Uber, it would apply to any transit (I’m assuming taxis have the same problem). Running Uber out of business isn’t the point. Making the lives of citizens easier is the point. If Uber can make a business out of that, more power to them.
- wizofaus 4y agoAre you suggesting disabled people receive a regular fixed sum from the government, or that they'd have to individually apply each trip for the compensation? Both seem problematic/inefficient to me, compared to having Uber being able to, for instance, reduce/offset their reportable taxable income to compensate for the cost of providing services to disabled customers.
- FrenchDevRemote 4y ago>Are you suggesting disabled people receive a regular fixed sum from the government, or that they'd have to individually apply each trip for the compensation? In France you get both. A fixed sum for your handicap+a bit more money if you have rent to pay, which amount to +/- minimum wage(which is very livable in most cities besides Paris) And you get free cabs/transportation, my neighbor's kid get a cab every day of the week without having to pay a cent, same for a lot of kids in special ed, cancer patients, any serious disease even temporary mean you can get free cabs.
- Spivak 4y agoNo, rides should be the same cost at point of sale (i.e. rider pays the same rate whether they're disabled or not) and then Uber/Taxi company bills the gov't for compensation for each trip.
- wizofaus 4y agoSounds equivalent to my suggestion (except it works for better for companies currently paying no corporate tax). Just waiting for someone to come along and argue we shouldn't be providing incentives for people to become disabled...
- Aerroon 4y ago>Both seem problematic/inefficient to me, compared to having Uber being able to, for instance, reduce/offset their reportable taxable income to compensate for the cost of providing services to disabled customers. And this is why the US tax code is a mile long with loopholes upon loopholes. It seems far more inefficient to me to get companies to play creative accounting than to give individuals some sum of money.
- wizofaus 4y agoPossibly, but there are surely fewer companies eligible for making such a claim than there are individuals. Depends how automated you can make it I guess. And while I'm not one to get overly upset if certain compensation schemes are slightly vulnerable to fraud, you still need to maintain public trust in such a system for it to have long term viability, and individual- based schemes are surely more expensive to police/regulate.