7 ms·
A lot of people suspect there's ""official"" insider trading at the exchanges; there's no reason for the exchange not to front-run orders or fake the order book
by pjc50 4y ago
A lot of people suspect there's ""official"" insider trading at the exchanges; there's no reason for the exchange not to front-run orders or fake the order book if they think they can get away with it. Or trade against heavily leveraged positions to liquidate them. Or prop-trade with the customers' money.
- ChainOfFools 4y agoCrypto people love to talk about incentives when referring to things like crypto adoption by the market, or corrupt actions on the part of incumbent powers like bankers or politicians. They are much less enthusiastic about discussing incentives when it comes to things like exchange operatiors front running their clients, centralizing forces in crypto generally, etc.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI work for a company that provides financial services to/on centralized exchanges, but none of us really like the centralization there; even if it's our bread and butter (for now) I think most "crypto people" are more excited about decentralized exchanges.
- noobermin 4y agoThis sounds a lot like a no-true scotsman...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- olalonde 4y agoWhat makes you say that? In my experience, centralized exchanges are perceived as public enemy #1 by a lot of crypto people. They are seen as a necessary (but temporary) evil to bridge the "legacy" fiat world.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Forgeties79 4y ago> They are seen as a necessary (but temporary) evil to bridge the "legacy" fiat world. There is no world in which they can put that genie back in the bottle, so I really hope they don’t actually believe it’s “temporary.”
- ETH_start 4y agoThe top decentralized exchange, Uniswap, has overtaken the top centralized exhanges in liquidity depth for several major trading pairs: https://uniswap.org/blog/uniswap-v3-dominance https://uniswap.org/blog/uniswap-v3-dominance So there is a world where centralized exchanges have far less relevance than they do today.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI just don't see it going away. Services like Coinbase have done more for adoption than any crypto-evangelists on message boards ever have if we're being honest with ourselves. People need it to feel familiar, and these pseudo-banks/stock exchange platforms feel close enough to the "real thing" that people are making the jump. I mean the fact that over a decade later and wallets are still this incredibly high-friction experience for users says a lot. Just having an easy place where you go "input debit card, get crypto," makes all the difference - and that's a service large exchanges have covered, thus locking people into their platform(s). Edit: Also, Uniswap...ehhhh. Not a great example for your point.
- HaZeust 4y agoUniswap is *so* easy to slander to the ground from centralized exchanges if push came to shove. It's the primary tool for exit scams, there's barely any qualifications or criteria to mint a coin, ICOs simply don't matter anymore - all are particularly easy points to hit if you're competitors fall short on handling them. And that's just mentioning the pragmatic on how Uniswap neglects fixing the BAD side of crypto, it doesn't even go over how Uniswap delivers only niche features on the good side of crypto - and doesn't do things like foster easier crypto buying/selling for mass adoption from the average person. Please, come back to me when Uniswap's market cap isn't 1/3 of Coinbase's.
- pfraze 4y agoDepends on who you're talking to, but I think the interest by crypto people in Uniswap suggests they're pretty aware of this problem and not excusing it.
- joyfylbanana 4y agoDepends on how you use the exchanges. If you just buy and sell BTC and keep your coins off-exchange, there is little reason to care about whatever schemes the exchanges are doing. If you start playing with leverage, you will be putting much more trust at stake, and it is your individual decision to do that. I have been involved with BTC community for many years and most Bitcoiners I know do not trade back and forth, do not buy that much shitcoins and do not store their coins on exchanges, so these schemes do not affect them.
- SilasX 4y agoSay what? The whole DeFi ecosystem basically exists to bring transparency to operations like exchanges. With e.g. liquidity pools, you can see exactly what trades it's processing and how it handles them.
- pvarangot 4y ago"A lot of people suspect"? Are we being overt? Am I the only one that not very subtly got offered insider trading of NFT tokens as a perk for joining a crypto company?
- xur17 4y agoI'd be very curious to hear more about this..
- pjc50 4y agoNot my intention! I hold no crypto stake apart from the free Keybase one and work for a non-crypto company. But the fact that you read that in my message indicates that it has been a clear part of the "offering" of crypto - that it's permissionless. i.e. there are no rules and no law enforcement.
- xsmasher 4y agoDo you mean you were offered tokens? Or do you mean you were explicitly offered access to non-public information that you could trade on?
- adrr 4y agoIt’s legal for the company to do it. Not legal for individuals. Coinbase could have bought assets ahead of time and done the same thing legally. There was a case where a person had access to the credit card transaction data[1] and used that data to figure out sales prior to earning calls. That same data is available to hedgefunds willing to purchase it from Bloomberg. They call legally get a companies sales data prior to earnings and trade off that information. 1. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-sec-capitalone-insidertrading/u-s-jury-finds-ex-capital-one-analyst-liable-in-insider-trading-case-idUSKCN0UR2KR20160114 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-sec-capitalone-insidertra...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- compsciphd 4y agobloomberg doesn't trade on that information, heck I didn't work on anything financially oriented while at Bloomberg (worked on BLAW) and I was still restricted in the type of investments they allowed me to make. i.e. by definition bloomberg buying the data and making it available to the terminal is making the data public.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nullc 4y agoIf you look at the details in this case it appears that the actual charges are for exploiting confidential company information for his own gain and not insider trading.
- dcolkitt 4y agoMisappropriating fiduciary information is literally the legal basis for insider trading. There's a common fallacy that insider trading is illegal because the government wants to enforce a "level playing field". Nothing could be further from the truth. Insider trading is illegal because as an employee of the company, you're profiting off your job in a way that doesn't share any of the profits with your employer. In other words the "victim" of insider trading is actually the company itself, not the poor schmuck who you dumped a losing trade on. Many things that are colloquially thought of as insider trading, are not against the law. For example it's perfectly legal for a hedge fund to hire a helicopter to circle an oil refinery day and night with an infrared camera, so they can get a precise estimate of how much revenue an energy company will announce in its quarterly earnings. This is perfectly legal because at no point was any of this information "misappropriated" in violation of a fiduciary duty. Very clearly the little guy in this case has no chance of competing, and this isn't a level playing field in any sense. But the law simply does not care.
- nullc 4y agoI appreciate the clarification! But maybe you took it too far? Publicly traded companies themselves are subject to regulations that impede varrious kinds of unfair and prejudicial behavior. Isn't the colloquially interpretation less far from reality than someone might extract from your comment? Since if regulations keep the company from doing it, and 'insider trading' keeps the insiders from doing it-- you're left with those that have superhuman insight from satellite photos or whatever (technically public, but maybe only practically available to billion dollar corporations) -- and at least the hedge funds are vulnerable to noise and misinterpretation. You might get thoroughly out traded, but hopefully not through actually privileged information. The reason I bring it up is was really the reason behind my original comment: I think that nothing about this prosecution should make people investing in crypto-commodities, ICOs, etc. particularly obscure and thinly traded ones feel any safer from exchange insiders trading against them to their detriment. All you we can extract from this is that if exchange staff do it for their personal benefit they might get prosecuted. But the staff doing it personally in their own accounts is probably a minor problem compared to the exchange engaging in it for its own profits.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI mean this is probably true for all exchanges, also for the traditional stock market; it's the financial incentive they have on top of the regular commissions they charge. The person in question was sloppy, and as others said, this is probably just the tip of the iceberg.