4 ms·
Apple re-enables Bluetooth on every OS update on purpose
- h4waii 4y agoThis might be for connecting to a keyboard or input peripheral, many users, especially Mac ones don't use wired keyboard or mice. Security and user hostility aside, I can see this being one of the main reasons to re-enable it during "important" OS updates.
- lapcat 4y agoIf you had a Bluetooth keyboard or mouse, then Bluetooth would have been enabled before installing the update, otherwise how could you type or click to install the update in the first place? Also, the same thing happens on Mac laptops with built-in keyboard and trackpad. Moreover, it happens on iPhone too, which has no peripherals. Not sure why you changed "every" OS update to "important" OS updates.
- walterbell 4y agoAlso iPads with $100-$300 Apple keyboards with Apple's proprietary magnetic connector to avoid the insecurity of wireless keyboards. Apple is undermining their own products.
- vineyardmike 4y agoOr because the connector provides power to a device that is battery-free?
- walterbell 4y agoEveryone has their own reasons for buying an expensive Apple keyboard. Logitech iPad keyboard, 2+ years of power from one battery, https://www.logitech.com/en-us/products/ipad-keyboards/slim-folio-ipad-keyboard-case.html https://www.logitech.com/en-us/products/ipad-keyboards/slim-...
- bradwood 4y agoStop using Apple's products if their "functionality" or "user hostility" is a problem for you. I used to be a fanboy. But I've moved to a (mostly) FOSS setup now. It's more rough around the edges but if I decide my computer/phone should not do something, then it FUCKING WON'T and I generally have the power to make it so.
- lapcat 4y agoI'm not sure how this comment is useful. Most of us here are fairly technically sophisticated and have chosen our operating systems for our own reasons. There's no perfect OS, each has upsides and downsides. As you admit, yours is "more rough around the edges". It's a matter of personal priorities and preferences. It's frustrating whenever someone points out one problem, and a bunch of responses are "just don't use Apple products". There may be good reasons to stop using Apple products, but no, this Bluetooth issue is not a reason for me. As I'm aware of the issue, I check Bluetooth status after every OS update and re-disable it, problem solved for me. This blog post is just about awareness raising and hopefully pushback to get Apple to change it. I think most people are unaware that OS updates are silently re-enabling Bluetooth. In the grand scheme, it's not the biggest issue in the world, which is precisely why public pushback might get Apple to change it. I would at least like to hear their explanation.
- neilalexander 4y ago> I think most people are unaware that OS updates are silently re-enabling Bluetooth. At this point I’d be far more surprised to find more than a small minority of people who care about permanently disabling it, given the number of things Apple use Bluetooth for (i.e. Continuity, Apple Watch, Find My Items, Apple Pencil) on top of the usual uses (like Bluetooth headphones, in-car phone connectivity, portable speakers and so on). I get there can be security motivations for disabling Bluetooth but my feeling is that reactivating automatically is probably a conscious decision motivated by real world usage patterns and/or support cases from less technical users.
- lapcat 4y ago
- walterbell 4y agoApple also re-enables Wi-Fi after every OS update, which is unhelpful if you had it disabled on a docked device with wired ethernet. Good for radio baseband attackers and harvesters (including nearby Apple devices tracking "Find My Phone") of WiFi and Bluetooth device presence. https://www.riscure.com/blog/security-highlight-evil-never-sleeps https://www.riscure.com/blog/security-highlight-evil-never-s... > the researchers find that the Bluetooth chip is not well protected, and its firmware could be analyzed and altered by an iPhone user with privileged access. While this is a complex process, it may also lead to discovering and exploiting new vulnerabilities that would introduce even more risk. It would be great if Apple would address the Bluetooth chip weakness and migrate to better firmware security.
- _gllen 4y agoAlso love how they nag me to enable siri and make safari the default browser every update.
- lapcat 4y agoI'm not seeing that on every update, but in any case there is a workaround on Mac to stop Safari from nagging you: https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/TRYTHENEWSAFARI.html https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/TRYTHENEWSAFARI.html
- navjack27 4y agoThe only keyboard I have connected to my M1 Mac Mini is a Bluetooth keyboard and I would be extremely pissed off if I did an update and I couldn't use my computer without having to grab a wired keyboard.
- lapcat 4y agoThis is completely missing the point. As I said in an earlier comment: "If you had a Bluetooth keyboard or mouse, then Bluetooth would have been enabled before installing the update, otherwise how could you type or click to install the update in the first place? Also, the same thing happens on Mac laptops with built-in keyboard and trackpad. Moreover, it happens on iPhone too, which has no peripherals." The point is pretty simple: if you had Bluetooth disabled before an OS update, then it should stay disabled after the update. And likewise, if you had Bluetooth enabled before an OS update, then it should stay enabled after the update! In other words, an OS update should not silently change your settings. It's astonishing to me that people with Bluetooth keyboards somehow believe that I want their keyboard to stop working. That's absurd.
- navjack27 4y agoWhen I first got this computer basically when it first came out there was a point during the initial setup or it was an update soon after I originally set it up where I had bluetooth enabled and then I rebooted and then Bluetooth wasn't enabled anymore. I think Apple got a lot of complaints about that and now they just want to make sure that it defaults to on no matter what just in case.
- lapcat 4y agoThat sounds like a bug. It would be strange for Apple to "fix" a bug by introducing a different bug. Why not just fix that bug? Macs have supported Bluetooth for almost 20 years, as have iPhones since their beginning. It's unclear why, after all that time, this change needed to be made in the year 2020.