7 ms·
How many factory or construction jobs does "hard-science" funding create? I love science but defense invests in the entire "stack". It creates factory jobs but
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago
How many factory or construction jobs does "hard-science" funding create? I love science but defense invests in the entire "stack". It creates factory jobs but it also creates jobs for basically every STEM field.
From a practicality standpoint- military spending is difficult to beat. Improves defense, improves the defense of allies, creates factory jobs, creates science and engineering jobs. It has everything.
The only thing that comes close is if there were some green arms race where we are funding and building wind, solar, nuclear, fusion, etc.
- xg15 4y agoIf job creation is the only factor, why not invest the 10B into digging holes and filling them up again?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoWhere do I say that it's the only factor?
- vanattab 4y ago> From a practicality standpoint- military spending is difficult to beat. Improves defense, improves the defense of allies, creates factory jobs, creates science and engineering jobs. It has everything. I mean he explicitly said it was not the only factor...
- DaveExeter 4y agoCongratulations! You have discovered the broken-window fallacy! [1] [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- hervature 4y ago"The belief that destruction is good for the economy" That's not at all what GP is saying. Government investment into industries have different return on investment. This is why governments heavily invest into healthcare. But, if we're talking investing in a military vs. university researchers, I think you have to be fairly elitist to say that adding 100,000 academics is better for society than providing a good life for 1M soldiers. At its core, military spending is the greatest experiment of UBI ever done. Now, downvotes from the left and right.
- DaveExeter 4y agoI don't believe in downvotes, so I upvoted you instead. :-) I agree with what you see. You see 1M soldiers (freeloaders?) and their salaries, housing, and healthcare provided 'free' by taxpayers. The problem is what you don't see, or as they say in French, ce qu’on ne voit pas!
- hervature 4y agoWhy thank you. I know that many believe that militaries can only be used for destruction. Of course, we've had 70 years of peace (for the most part) that was really only possible with the largest military movement (10% of the US) to counteract a true force of destruction. I'm the first one to ream on the US's use of drone strikes and getting involved in the Middle East in the first place, but the GPS system and the US Navy probably contribute $1T each to the functioning of the global economy per year. If that takes a large amount of soldiers to be combat ready (definitely not freeloading) then I'm personally fine with that.
- forgetfulness 4y agoThey're freeloading in the sense that they're paid to not meaningfully produce anything, cleaning guns, loading and unloading crates, doing calisthenics and polishing up boots are some fairly unproductive uses of able bodied people, not to speak of the pencilpushers setting up the logistics for this. Paying people to churn butter by hand non stop would probably be more of a contribution, or doing actual UBI.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoYou have a cynical view. I have a humanitarian service medal from rendering assistance to Indonesia after their earthquake in 2009. While I was deployed my friends got theirs helping Japan after their devastating tsunami. What about police and firefighters? They don't "produce" anything but you need them.
- greedo 4y ago
- TrapLord_Rhodo 4y agoNasa is defense funding. >wind, solar, nuclear, fusion, etc.green arms race where we are funding and building wind, solar, nuclear, fusion, etc. We have over the last 10 years. Now we need a grid scale battery race as we are realizing that all the green energy in the world is useless if we can't store it.
- carlmr 4y ago>we are realizing that all the green energy in the world is useless if we can't store it. Most of us realized this 20-30 years ago.
- greedo 4y agoNASA is not defense funding. It might benefit from some military technologies, but its funding is not under the DoD.
- M3L0NM4N 4y agoI wish more people realized you don't need necessarily batteries to store energy. There are mechanical ways to store large amounts of energy, like pumped-storage hydroelectricity.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 4y agoyou mean hydroelectric batteries?
- _greim_ 4y ago> How many factory or construction jobs does "hard-science" funding create? An infinite amount, in the long run.
- danny_codes 4y agoEh, everything except useful output. Sure, a by-product of military research could be something useful, but that money would go a lot further if we just went for the useful thing immediately. The F35 is a good example. Whatever technology gains came out of that project are likely useful in general, but presumably it'd have been several orders of magnitude cheaper to just directly invest in that tech instead of building a weapon.
- felipemnoa 4y ago>>but presumably it'd have been several orders of magnitude cheaper to just directly invest in that tech instead of building a weapon. True, but virtually nobody would be motivated by just directly investing on the tech instead of an exciting fighter jet.
- ISL 4y agoI don't know if you've ever met any ... aircraft metallurgists, for example, but holy poops are they motivated by doing anything awesome with advanced alloys.
- felipemnoa 4y agoYeah, but you need to motivate the people that will be footing the bill and also the ones that approve the budget. The tax payers, the legislators... The regular person will not care about technical stuff like that, but they will care about a shiny new fighting yet.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm an engineer, and I'm motivated by the end product, not the just inventing a machine.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoIndeed. Some people defend war spending by saying that it leads to, say, medial advances. Seems to me that you can fund medical research without spending a trillion dollars sending humans around the planet, causing another trillion in infrastructure damage, air-conditioning tents in a desert, blowing limbs off the aforementioned humans, flying them home and then still spending the money on the research to fix them (and in the US especially, then also denying these hard-won fruits of this whole taxpayer-funded endeavour to the taxpayers).
- lamontcg 4y agoDefense spending tends to create its own demand though via "adventurism" in foreign countries, which has a fairly enormous collateral costs.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoWhy can't we fix and improve infrastructure... and spend less bullshit like the F35 program? I believe research, development, and program maintenance costs are expected to exceed $1.7 trillion dollars. With $1.7 trillion dollars you could, for example, give every household in the country a small rooftop solar array (@ ~$10k/ea).
- criddell 4y agoIf you try to buy that many solar panels, you're going to move the market a lot. Would the price go up or down?
- micromacrofoot 4y agooh of course, very likely! but it's an interesting illustration of the massive budget these defense projects get — and this is just one project!
- KerrAvon 4y ago"Improves defense" is such a canard. The US outspends every other military power on earth by a zillion to 1. And most of it is unaudited and except for the rare whisteblowing, we don't really know how much is a total waste. We can absolutely afford to shift a few billion to hard science.
- OrvalWintermute 4y agoThe problem is, you are using an unlike comparison. We as Americans pay based on US salaries, US cost of living, etc. This is why many choose to use Military Purchasing Power Parity (MPPP) [1] instead. MPPP can explain why the USSR had at one point a truly gigantic force regardless of the spend. This explains part of the story around how huge China's military force is becoming [2] Another element to consider is how much of the entire US government (federal, state, local, and tribal) and US industry could be operationally controlled by the US Commander-in-Chief during wartime. China for example could be expected to have unity of command across the board. We wouldn't, despite things like the Defense production Act [3] Yet one other factor is the amount of unidentified military units, such as China's Fishing Fleet [4] (Chinese Maritime Militia) that serve as a somewhat disguised extension to their Navy. For force parity comparisons, you'd have to total up their Navy, their coast guard, and their CMM fleet. [1] https://voxeu.org/article/why-military-purchasing-power-parity-matters https://voxeu.org/article/why-military-purchasing-power-pari... [2] https://www.cassandracapital.net/post/the-colossal-scale-of-china-s-military-buildup https://www.cassandracapital.net/post/the-colossal-scale-of-... [3] https://www.fema.gov/disaster/defense-production-act https://www.fema.gov/disaster/defense-production-act [4] https://www.businessinsider.com/china-has-covert-naval-fleet-disguised-fishing-boats-2017-6?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/china-has-covert-naval-fleet...
- kristjansson 4y ago> How many factory or construction jobs does "hard-science" funding create? Lots? JWST is a schoolbus-sized pile of high-precision high-tech parts, never mind the construction of new facilities to test, transport it. LIGO and friends require substantial construction, colliders are huge construction projects before they're scientific instruments, ... If there's a productive project that costs billions, it's going to employ a lot of people.
- jcrawfordor 4y agoMajor science projects have extremely similar economic impact to military spending for the simple reason that they are extremely similar. The dominant companies involved in high-end scientific projects, especially in aerospace, are the exact same companies that receive the most military spending. Essentially every major defense contractor is involved in JWST, and the prime contractor is a defense company (Northrup Grumman). The only parties with significant involvement that are not directly the military-industrial complex are university coalitions, which operate similarly to the university coalitions that defense R&D programs heavily rely on. NASA is essentially part of the broader US defense organization and operates in extremely close collaboration with defense agencies using largely the same methods, contractors, and funding. Major NASA projects are largely indistinguishable from major weapons projects, and most of the time the two are closely interrelated in that both use technology developed by the other. Sometimes this is more informal (since the same contractors perform both) but sometimes it is quite formal, e.g. multiple defense satellite systems have been developed in parallel with scientific systems so that the design effort can be shared.
- SEJeff 4y agoA lot of military research is done IN CONCERT with NASA, you know that, right? The DoD and NASA work together so much on missiles and avionics it isn't funny. https://www.nrel.gov/workingwithus/defense-partnerships.html https://www.nrel.gov/workingwithus/defense-partnerships.html https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/2356511/nasa-dod-agree-to-collaborate-more-closely-in-space/ https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/23... https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-us-space-force-establish-foundation-for-broad-collaboration https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-us-space-force-estab... etc, etc, etc. NASA's wind tunnel was used to help design DoD missiles. The two have always worked hand in hand.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoI will point out that the military spending that people complained about provided my brother a good job at a factory making a decent wage while he was figuring out his life and college. In addition grew up to a major AFB, which was one of the biggest employers in the region, and these were good jobs too that paid well. Like all this money the government spends on military isn't just suddenly vanishing into thin air a lot of it gets put back into creating jobs, and the communities. Now there may be a lot more that gets diverted through seventeen layers of subcontractors, and more useless bureaucracy than you can shake a stick at but it isn't just being used for a useless purpose.
- worker_person 4y agoThe ideal military size is such that we are strong enough that no one is willing to start WW3. The smaller the budget that achieves this the better. Too small and wars become more common. WW1 we went home, and 20 years later things heated up. WW2 we stayed and it's been fairly peaceful since.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoDon't kid yourself. It's been peaceful in spite of us injecting ourselves into matters that are none of our concern. We could have achieved the same thing with a few dozen nukes. You don't see anyone lining up to invade North Korea any time soon.
- worker_person 4y agoNo one is willing to use nukes for smaller wars; so they are off the board. You need regular military for everything else.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoNo, you're missing the point. You need a military to defend the homeland. That could be done with a few dozen nukes and the national guard. We do not involve ourselves in 'smaller wars' as we are no longer the world police.
- jacob019 4y agoHow many factory or construction jobs do you want? How many should be funded by government. We'll be paying collectively for these jobs forever or they will disappear. And what do we get for this expense? We certainly don't get to be safer. More science research creates jobs too, and those jobs can advance our competency as a country and as a spieces, and advance self-funded market based industry too.
- ErikVandeWater 4y agoCreating jobs is not a goal. Might as well just pay those people salaries to do whatever they feel like doing.
- mr_toad 4y ago> defense invests in the entire "stack". It creates factory jobs Every defence dollar (or any other government spending) comes from taxes that could have been spent or invested and which would have also created jobs. There’s no evidence that government spending causes a net gain in jobs. Every time someone tells you that a new government spending program is creating jobs, they’re only telling you half the story.