5 ms·
> I would think giving it to some federal parks/wildlife agency would come with stronger protections than an NGO could provide. Not really. Federal agencies se
by toast0 4y ago
> I would think giving it to some federal parks/wildlife agency would come with stronger protections than an NGO could provide.
Not really. Federal agencies sell parklands from time to time. It's easier to have an NGO that won't sell the land for a long time.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThere’s two parts. The conservation easement strips the land of its development capacity, and that restriction rides with the land to future owners in perpetuity, while the non profit stewards the land and enforces those legal claims if necessary.
- giantg2 4y agoI hate this process. It effectively gives someone else rights over the current owners land. The person becomes a tenet farmer in effect and is responsible for the taxes and upkeep while under the control of the organization. And the land is not accessible to the public. It's much better for the land to be organization-owned and open to public use. Just my opinion.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThe land absolutely can be open to the public in this model, it just can’t be developed.
- giantg2 4y agoAt least in my experience, th orgs near me buy the land, place restrictions on it, then sell it. Only rarely do they hold it and open it to the public.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThis seems like it would inevitably lead to a limited number of entities owning almost all the conservation land. Stripping it of development value in perpetuity ought to lower the value considerably, making it easier for an interested party to accumulate it. Maybe in hopes that some day they'll figure out how to undo that restriction. Edit: On second thought, after doing a quick bit of research, the conservation easement can be removed. So the value will be impacted, but the land will still have some residual development value.
- giantg2 4y agoGenerally the easement can't be removed except by the trust that owns those rights, and that's not something they will want to give up. So yes, these organizations will eventually hold the rights to vast amounts of land, with limited oversight (compared to a municipality or other democratic org), while the "owner" paying the taxes and upkeep on the land can be individuals (not the org). And yes, the value of that land tends to go down slightly. But it constrains supply which causes all the other land to increase.
- atourgates 4y agoI volunteer with a regional land trust, and I think you're maybe misunderstanding the conservation easement process, or at least it's typical application. The typical process is: Private Landowner Decides they want to conserve their land. They work with a Land Trust to define, and put in place the restrictions of that conservation easement. Those typically restrict development (though the landowner can in some cases "carve out" future building sites), and depending on the goals of the landowner and land trust, could allow things like agriculture, forestry, recreation etc.. I'm sure there's a conservation easement somewhere that restricts public access, but I've never seen one. Most commonly, the land stays inaccessible to the public just like it was before the easement, but nothing in the legal language of the easement prohibiting future public access. (One conservation easement manager half-joked that every easement we do has public access potential, it just might take a few generations for that potential to be realized). Next, that easement goes through the legal process of being put into place. Now, that land is subject to the restrictions of that easement forever. And it's the job (legal responsibility) of the Land Trust that holds the easement to regularly monitor the easements they hold, and make sure they're followed. However, the original landowner still owns the land, just like before. If they sell the land, or someone inherits, it's still (de facto) private land, just private land with restrictions as to what can be done on it. Now, there are private landowners who want to open their land to public access, and that's amazing. (We did our first few public access-specific easements this year at our comparatively-small land trust, and we're super excited). There are also times where a landowner puts an easement on their property, and then sells it to someone like a local, regional or state institution to be managed specifically for public access. There was recently a great story about how private individuals stepped in to conserve land, and then later transferred it to Washington State Parks[1]. There are also times when a property might transfer ownership, as well as the easement, to a Land Trust. We actually have one of these that we basically operate as a public park. But, that's like less than 2% of the total easements we hold. So, to your points, I guess I would say: The process of conservation easements by large _increases_ the amount of land available for public access and recreation, not decreases it. And if anyone is becoming a tenant farmer, it's the landowner choosing to become a tenant themselves. There are times when an outside entity might purchase the easement from the landowner, but again, the landowner's not forced into that transaction. 1. https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/washington/articles/2021-12-21/washington-buys-more-steptoe-butte-land-to-preserve-it https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/washington/articles/...
- rootusrootus 4y ago> in perpetuity Or until the current owners convince a court of law to extinguish the conservation easement.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoYou should research what’s required to do so and the odds of it occurring. Only in rare/limited circumstances can the easement be terminated, and the IRS has some oversight into this because of the tax consequences of these easements (as you can claim a charitable tax deduction for donating and extinguishing the development capability of the parcel).
- rootusrootus 4y agoI've done the first part [0]. But I don't know an easy way to assess the second part. Clearly congress intended for it to be difficult, but the idea that a conservation easement is in fact permanent should always have an asterisk next to it. [0]: https://www.landcan.org/article/extinguishing-transferring-and-amending-conservation-easements/727 https://www.landcan.org/article/extinguishing-transferring-a...
- mcguire 4y agoSeveral years ago there was a kerfuffle in Texas: The Nature Conservancy had traded a piece of land, that had been donated to it, to the state parks and wildlife department with the understanding that the land was going to be under their conservation regime. Several years later, TPWD was reportedly considering selling the land to a group to form a hunting reserve. I don't recall how it ended (but I suspect the sale did not go through), but there were threats floating around that the Nature Conservancy would no longer make those kinds of trades with Texas.
- yonaguska 4y agoInteresting, because a hunting reserve is probably one of the easiest ways to actually monetize conservation and allow it to pay for itself.