4 ms·
I'm as much of a crypto skeptic as the next guy, and there are plenty of decentralization failures in crypto, but you can't have "all these centralized exchange
by lolinder 4y ago
I'm as much of a crypto skeptic as the next guy, and there are plenty of decentralization failures in crypto, but you can't have "all these centralized exchanges". The fact that there are so many suggests something worked.
I don't think the promise of Bitcoin was ever that there would be no exchanges, only that no one would be beholden to any given provider. As long as you can pick up your keys and seamlessly start trading on a different exchange, that part of the crypto world is not centralized.
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y ago>As long as you can pick up your keys and seamlessly start trading on a different exchange, that part of the crypto world is not centralized. I once asked a friend who had signed up to some crypto exchange "Do they just give you your keys when you sign up?". They replied, "What keys?" Eventually they found it. But it's not like they educate the user.
- birracerveza 4y agoThe cool thing is that you can use a centralized exchange and not even know about what keys are, or use the network as it is intended and not rely on a centralized entity. What's bad about having more options?
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoThis is bad because who ever controls the keys controls the coins. So really for all these clueless users, the exchange owns all the coins and you can’t prove otherwise. And they don’t bother educating the user. Or suggesting best practice. That’s not in the users favour.
- hnthrow1010 4y ago>I don't think the promise of Bitcoin was ever that there would be no exchanges, only that no one would be beholden to any given provider. As long as you can pick up your keys and seamlessly start trading on a different exchange, that part of the crypto world is not centralized. Can't you see this defeats the whole purpose though? By this logic, traditional banks are also decentralized because you can also take your money out and go to a different bank. The word "decentralized" has no meaning in crypto parlance, it means whatever the speaker wants it to mean at any given time. And at least banks are FDIC insured, when a crypto exchange loses all your money then you can't really pick up your keys again because everything is just gone.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoNot exactly the same, because with the US Dollar, every bank can be ordered to freeze your assets. This may be considered a feature, but the same is true for the Ruble, or the Real. Having assets on the blockchain means you self-custody them in a more portable way (similar to cash), while still having them in a digital form.
- hnthrow1010 4y agoIt is the same. Crypto exchanges can also freeze your assets when you hold them in that exchange. And actually this is a good thing, the accounts of fraudsters, thieves and scammers should absolutely be frozen and confiscated. Crypto companies are trying to promote this idea that because they've sprinkled some crypto magic on their banking product, they don't have to follow laws, and by doing this all the fraud will just all suddenly disappear for no clear reason. That overwhelmingly isn't true. Don't let them get away with this. "Self-custody" in crypto is also a lie, there's no such thing. All activity on a blockchain is completely dependent on the miners to run the network.
- rvnx 4y agoInstead of a court, in crypto, the operators of a coin decide on what happens to your funds. They can freeze your assets to make their assets seem more valuable, or they can agree to create an infinite amount of currency (ex: dogecoin)
- hackinthebochs 4y ago>Can't you see this defeats the whole purpose though? By this logic, traditional banks are also decentralized because you can also take your money out and go to a different bank. The point isn't that centralized exchanges are decentralized, but that the network is decentralized in spite of the existence of centralized exchanges. Crypto provides financial democratization by way of an open permissionless financial network. Large entities can't collude to lock in customers or lock out competition. Centralized exchanges offer convenience over the base network and so they see a lot of use. But your freedom to transact with the network can't be taken away by centralized players. There is no analogous "base network" when it comes to bank transactions.