3 ms·
What made them so confident in their assessment of a low micrometer density in the first place? Even as a freshman engineering student I remember that the expo
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
What made them so confident in their assessment of a low micrometer density in the first place?
Even as a freshman engineering student I remember that the exposed mirror design seemed oddly overconfident.
- tekla 4y agoWhat does this even mean? Are you saying as a freshman student you had insight into the statistical modeling of micrometeor impact probability and impact? The design of the optics was more or less finalized around the early 2000s. The exposed optics were kind of the entire point of the entire design. A very low quality post.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI usually don't reply to obvious trolling but I rather not see any eager freshmen mechanical engineering students be discouraged by a random troll. The basic principles of mechanical engineering have remained mostly unchanged for the last half century. NASA, including the mirror designers, have not discovered any new principles in the process of making JWST. Since even the most advanced technologies derive from these well established principles, at least in mechanical engineering, a sufficiently motivated and inquisitive student can learn enough within a year to formulate reasonable hunches.
- belter 4y agoJWST FAQ still says Q: "Will micrometeoroids damage the beryllium mirror?" A: "We tested beryllium discs for micrometeoroids using test facilities in the US and showed the micrometeoroids have negligible effects on the beryllium. Cryogenic beryllium mirrors have been flown in space exposed to micrometeoroids without problems. The Spitzer Space Telescope, launched in 2003, has a beryllium primary mirror. All of Webb's systems are designed to survive micrometeoroid impacts." https://www.jwst.nasa.gov/content/about/faqs/faq.html https://www.jwst.nasa.gov/content/about/faqs/faq.html
- MichaelZuo 4y agoPublic facing FAQs are not accurate descriptions of the actual engineering decision making. For example, 'All of Webb's systems are designed to survive micrometeoroid impacts.' is clearly only true below a certain bound, and untrue for a large enough impact event. There's no way JWST as designed, as launched, can survive 1 million micro meteorite impacts over a 1 minute duration. Maybe it could survive 100 or 1000, but the threshold is certainly there.