4 ms·
I have been in the military, I know very well how different skills correlate with intelligence since the military relies heavily on that. Removing the top 50% w
by Jensson 4y ago
I have been in the military, I know very well how different skills correlate with intelligence since the military relies heavily on that. Removing the top 50% would have a huge effect, and that is exactly what we did in manual labour.
- lelanthran 4y agoI am not claiming that it does not have an effect, I am contending that this assertion: > But today we have ensured that basically no smart people are left is wrong.
- Jensson 4y ago
- uoaei 4y agoWhy do you insist that high school test performance is a valid metric for intelligence? Why do you think the kind of intelligence tested for in high schools is readily transferrable to conclusions about the ability of someone to get their job done?
- namecheapTA 4y agoThere are many smart people in construction. I went to Cal and know some classmates that went into it as management. There's also tons of people that went to "good" schools and studied construction management and I would put them up against CS majors from "average at best" schools any day. To say that the average cs grad got straight As in highschool is laughable. I know tons that couldn't even get into Cal or Stanford.
- lelanthran 4y ago> How many construction workers do you think got majority A's in high school? There are many smart people who did not get majority A's in high school. High school performance is not a good metric for problem-solving skills (AKA, general intelligence).
- biorach 4y agoMaybe in your middle class bubble all the smart kids graduate high school with good grades. From meeting people in a variety of walks of life in the USA it seems to me that what actually happens is that your grades are determined by zip code lottery with smart kids in underfunded school districts set up to fail by poor schools.
- Jensson 4y agoHalf of my high school class dropped out and I got a good view of the average of society in the military, I have seen a ton of people struggle from all walks of life. Also it is so strange that people here don't think that poor wages has any effect on the quality of workers in construction, even though they believe that to be true basically everywhere else. I strongly believe the reason we see so many problems with construction is simply that the wages today are so skewed and that greatly impacts the availability of talent, since people who can choose to go elsewhere mostly do so today. Only reason I can think of is that most here assumes construction work is so easy that you don't need to be that smart to do well there. Otherwise I don't understand these comments.
- coldtea 4y agoI don't think millitary experience is a good starting point to base assumptions about society in general or unrelated industries. It's a whole microcosm with its own constraints... In fact, since you piss on construction, one of the oldest running jokes is how dumb the millitary people are, and how illogical millitary is.
- kortilla 4y ago> In fact, since you piss on construction, one of the oldest running jokes is how dumb the millitary people are, and how illogical millitary is. Wow, that is a really funny joke. “How illogical military is!”
- coldtea 4y agoIs it? The half-joke/half-truth that "millitary intelligence" is an oxymoron has been widely circulated - heck, there are even Quora layman questions that take it for granted. [1] https://www.quora.com/Why-is-military-intelligence-considered-an-oxymoron-Is-this-a-correct-classification https://www.quora.com/Why-is-military-intelligence-considere... And of course all kind of insider jokes about such illogicallity and inefficiency (including long standing acronyms, like S.N.A.F.U), about how high command has little understanding of the situation on the ground in any real scenario, things dressed-up to look good, and so on.
- bumby 4y agoPerhaps you’re conflating general labor to construction? Construction involves all kinds, from general labor to skilled trades to project managers to engineers