4 ms·
Was hoping that they would address one big contributor to friendly fraud, which is that credit card descriptions are so ridiculously inscrutable that a cottage
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Was hoping that they would address one big contributor to friendly fraud, which is that credit card descriptions are so ridiculously inscrutable that a cottage industry of fintech startups has emerged just to translate these ridiculous codes into something a human can understand.
I mean, I think we've all dealt with the "WTF is SQ *SMTHNSMTHN on my credit card statement?" issue. If credit cards just showed actual merchant names it would reduce a lot of these problems. Granted, there are some issues with privacy (e.g. most companies know you don't want to see "Butt Plug Emporium" on your CC statement so instead show "A Plus Billing"), but even then I think that issue is solvable.
- thathndude 4y agoI had this experience recently. Had a $1000 charge for “AE.com.” Go to AE.com and it’s American eagle. I didn’t spend $1,000 at AE. I was all ready to dispute, but then checked my Apple wallet, and I saw the charge at Allen Edmonds. Yeah Allen Edmonds truncates it’s online orders to “ae.com”
- kstrauser 4y agoHonestly, then Allen Edmonds has no one to blame but themselves. That’s insane.
- thathndude 4y agoI really get into disputes. It’s an occupational hazard. So I was putting together a whole presentation with a video of AE.com loading, ICANN data, and the whole sink, to send to Amex. But, just as I am about to start the dispute process, I checked a couple more places and solve the mystery. Someone might be reading this and think “you couldn’t remember where you spent $1000 just a week ago“. But I was genuinely flummoxed. I’m sure some psychologist can explain it, but if you had just asked me where I spent $1000, I probably would have remembered. What threw me was the “ae.com” representation. It wasn’t so much that I forgot where I spend money, but a certainty that I did not spend money at AE.com. But I really should reach out to Alan Edmonds and tell them to fix this. They don’t even say “ae.com shoes” literally the entire description was “ae.com”
- kstrauser 4y agoWow, I don’t remember writing this, but it sure sounds like I did. I could also see my wife making the purchase. A few weeks later, as I’m reconciling our statements, I see a transaction from American Eagle and ask her about it. She reasonably denies it, and has no reason to even consider that I might actually be talking about her Alan Edmonds purchase. I dispute the transaction online, and probably end up getting a new credit card issued because our old one seems to be compromised.
- thathndude 4y agoLol. Always nice to know we’re not idiots (or, at least, idiots together). I mean, seriously, “Ae.com”
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoNever heard of them, had to go look it up. Going to assume you got 3 pairs? I suppose I could see not remembering the $1000 charge for clothing if you had been looking at it like 3 or 4 purchases… IDK, I don’t own fancy shoes so I’m having lots of trouble getting in your head space.
- jrockway 4y agoThe problem is the abbreviation. Imagine you saw "NEWEGG" on your statement. You'd think "I didn't buy $1000 worth of computer hardware". But that transaction was actually Newton's Egg Farm and Trucking, a contractor that does grocery deliveries, and indeed you did buy $1000 worth of groceries online three weeks ago. That's the problem here; ambiguous transaction descriptions. Sure, you don't buy clothes, so you aren't confused by an Allen Edmonds purchase being marked as American Eagle on your statement. But this can happen in many, many domains.
- kstrauser 4y agoAnd to make it worse, suppose it was “NEWEGG.com”. By my reading, that’s the same as saying they’re the same company that owns that website. It removes any ambiguity, which is usually a good thing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vecinu 4y agoI hope I don't come off as rude but do you really not remember spending $1000 on shoes? Basically any transaction over $100 stays in my mind for a while and I never get confused when I see my CC statement. I guess if you're making $1M/year your threshold is different but I feel like larger enough transactions should still register.
- dazbradbury 4y agoAllowing longer description lengths would be a huge improvement! Most chargebacks we see are "didn't recognize transaction", then we explain what the charge was for, and have to go through the chargeback cancellation process (which is a whole ordeal in itself). On that note... Why can't customers cancel a chargeback as easily as they can create one? The whole system is a UX nightmare for all parties involved.
- protomyth 4y agoI wonder how much changing the field size of the description would cost and what most banks would estimate the timeline would be?
- Someone1234 4y agoIt would be quite expensive to be honest. The best way to do it would be to leave the short description and add an additional large description, therefore those on legacy mainframes can just continue to work until they've able to conduct a spec update and those on modern systems can add it immediately. Still will cost money though, particularly those paying EDI/VAN data-rates.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoLonger description lengths wouldn't change the fact that a lot of merchants use names that are unrecognizable because they're a corporate name, not the common name of the business. Instead of Bob's Bagel Company, it's 1132 Fifth LLC, and only after a bunch of googling do you happen to hit upon a corporate database and discover the LLC is for a restaurant. Merchants shouldn't even be allowed to set this field. It should be set by their merchant bank, and the bank should require that the name on a reader at a business location match the common name of the business, followed by their address or store number if it's a chain, and zipcode. Ideally the business phone number as well. Or there should be a merchant ID, cross-referenceable against a publicly database maintained by credit card companies.
- dazbradbury 4y ago
- supertrope 4y agoCardholders are supposed to call the merchant first to confirm what the charge is and request a refund. So charging back anything they're not sure because it's easy is not following the payment network rules. However many businesses have half hour hold times ("We are experiencing higher than normal hold times due to the Coronavirus") and take weeks to respond to email if at all. I don't blame people for reflexively clicking dispute charge.
- dataflow 4y ago> Cardholders are supposed to call the merchant first I think you're missing the point. The entire point is you don't know whom the merchant is when see SQ *SMTHNSMTHN. I literally had that exact problem myself before. [1] I called every entity that I could possibly imagine calling, including my card issuer itself, to try to figure out whom the merchant was. Nobody could tell me. I therefore disputed a charge. Only after I incurred another instance of the same charge did I figure out what merchant was generating that name. I had to call my issuer and let them know to cancel the dispute. [1] With a different processor than Square.
- supertrope 4y agoSquare is an exception. Most charges aren't through an aggregator. A lot include a phone number or store ID.
- dataflow 4y agoThe person you're replying to was literally talking about Square though. And it's not just a random exception. Lots of merchants use it. Moreover phone numbers are not common. And I'm not sure what you call store IDs but the ones I recall frequently have no way to look them up. Instead of phone numbers what you frequently see is a city and state. In fact I just went to double-check one of my cards right now to make sure, and exactly 0 of the 8 transactions on it had phone numbers. (This may differ by card issuer.)
- 4y ago
- kelnos 4y agoI can only assume that all of this is backed by some ridiculously old data storage system that has something like a 15-character limit on these names. And then you have the problem of aggregators like Square (your example), where they have their own prefix, and then apparently do a pretty bad job of making sure their merchants pick reasonable names. And then there are regular merchants who use their company name, which might be wildly different from the name of the store. I do wonder how much "friendly fraud" is just someone looking at an inscrutable charge description on their statement, having no idea what it is, and disputing it on those grounds, even when it was a valid charge.