4 ms·
If that isn't wanted, why even bother with having separate states in first place? Just place everything directly under federal government. You could even get ri
by Ekaros 4y ago
If that isn't wanted, why even bother with having separate states in first place? Just place everything directly under federal government. You could even get rid of all other levels.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThe 10th amendment gives states power to regulate tons of things. Different states can have different laws without the senate.
- School-Cotton 4y agoGood question. It’s not clear why the US being a federation is important or valuable — it seems to be true for purely legacy reasons: that the states were already pseudo-independent colonies prior to 1776.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoI think it is an important question: what are states for. I don't mean the historical sequence of circumstances that led us to have the system we do, but why we might or might not want them. Why not just designated administrative districts of a federal government. One thing that Trump's presidency has taught me however, is that, despite the shenangigans of some of the election apparatus in individual states, it was much much harder for Trump to subvert the election process than it would have been had everyone worked for him.
- Ekaros 4y agoOn other hand the election fraud that lead to election of Biden might not have been possible with stronger central government. Just think of same rules through the country. No postal voting. Mandator IDs from central database, updated live based on movement of citizenry.
- School-Cotton 4y ago> administrative districts of a federal government FWIW it wouldn’t be called the federal government in that case, since the country wouldn’t be a federation. It’d just be “the government”.