3 ms·
Renters are overwhelmingly living in properties that have mortgages against them and commercial loans are always deductible. The deduction for mortgages on owne
by sokoloff 4y ago
Renters are overwhelmingly living in properties that have mortgages against them and commercial loans are always deductible. The deduction for mortgages on owner-occupied property serves to put prospective owners (including current renters) on a more equal footing when bidding against landlords for property.
- tptacek 4y agoIt is an immense giveway to the top income quintiles, which receive between 70-80% of the benefit, and giving "prospective owners" preference over "landlords" practically by definition reduces density and thus affordability.
- sokoloff 4y agoIt's not about giving preference to owner-occupants; it's about neutralizing the preference to landlords that would otherwise result.
- tptacek 4y agoAgain, that is inherently a policy decision that reduces density and affordability; by definition, "landlords" are people that own and operate multi-family dwellings. You could just as easily ask "why not give more of a preference to landlords?" It's probably useful for you to understand my, uh, priors? about this, which include the fact that I live in an overwhelmingly SFZ community that actively works to prevent the construction of multi-family dwellings, often with appeals to the evil of "landlords".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 4y agoThere's plenty of landlords who own SFRs as well. Building for building, I don't think tax policy should favor landlords over owner-occupants. How zoning should work is an orthogonal question in my view.
- tptacek 4y agoMost owner-occupants own SFZ lots. Every owner of a multi-family dwelling is a landlord.
- sokoloff 4y agoI'd prefer that an owner-occupant be able to write off the interest on N/N units on a parcel, just the same as a landlord is able to write off the interest on N/N units. That's true for N=1 (SFR), N=2 (duplex, half-occupied by the owner), N=3 (triple-decker with owner living in one), or N=50.