3 ms·
1. I'm not sure the Full Faith and Credit Clause works here. For example, say some state (Louisiana? Utah?) legalized marriages of adults to eight-year-olds.
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
1. I'm not sure the Full Faith and Credit Clause works here. For example, say some state (Louisiana? Utah?) legalized marriages of adults to eight-year-olds. And such a "couple" moves out of state. Does the state have to recognize that "marriage", just because of the Full Faith and Credit Clause? I kind of doubt it. For that matter, before Obergefell, some states had recognized same-sex marriage, and nobody said that the Full Faith and Credit Clause required other states to recognize them.
2. "A president sending in troops" is going to overrule a lot more than one Supreme Court decision. It's, probably, the end of the United States and the start of a civil war... if the military obeys such an order, which they should not.
- jfengel 4y agoWhen it comes to "marriages to eight-year-olds" you get into the fact that minors have very limited autonomy. The overriding law would (presumably) be that it's not legal in any state, even the one that permitted it. But of course I'm just guessing there; the Supreme Court makes up whatever rule it wants. The Full Faith and Credit Clause was widely discussed before Obergefell. Many people went to Massachusetts to get married when they were the only state, and were pushing precedents that it meant they were married in every state. Test cases often involved divorce. As for point #2, yes, I concur. That's my point: the Supreme Court has absolute authority, and nothing shy of destroying the Constitution can override it.