10 ms·
Still paying according to location for the same work?
by belter 4y ago
Still paying according to location for the same work?
- rnk 4y agoI saw a list of companies that paid the same regardless of location. There were even a few bay area companies that didn't cut your pay when you moved away, I wish I had that handy.
- codegeek 4y agoCan you name a few who will pay a Senior Software Engineer the same salary in Bay Area vs say Bangalore, India ? I am curious.
- wwarek 4y agoJust a few months ago this[0] jobs platform for exactly that - remote, location-independent salary - was discussed on HN [1]. [0] https://remotewide.co/ https://remotewide.co/ [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31225138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31225138
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- codegeek 4y agoOk I will bite. I randomly checked one company called "MotorK" [0] and I found this line in the job description "Work remotely from any of the countries we operate in". So thats not work from anywhere in the world. I am sure devil is always in the details. I know this is 1 example but I doubt a company will hire from anywhere in the world and pay the same salaries to you. There always will be restrictions. Ok now I am more curious. I looked at another company "Expensify" [1]. They actually want you to ideally relocate to one of their office locations :). So again, not fully remote anywhere in the world. I think employers say it casually but in practice, it is extremely difficult. Why would I pay the same salary to a good developer in NYC vs India/Thailand. If that's the case, why would I hire from a totally different timezone and not to mention add legal, HR and compliance issues. [0] https://remotewide.co/listings/6IBsLC9CWYb4sO8h8xAT https://remotewide.co/listings/6IBsLC9CWYb4sO8h8xAT [1] https://remotewide.co/listings/ncCWVkYCZx0dhK0m5Z8v https://remotewide.co/listings/ncCWVkYCZx0dhK0m5Z8v
- throwmisinfo388 4y agoMaybe Fly? Not sure. https://fly.io/about https://fly.io/about
- yencabulator 4y ago> and I found this line in the job description "Work remotely from any of the countries we operate in". Outside of contracting and business-to-business deals, I think we're still in a world where it's hard to legally employ people in countries where you don't have a legal presence (outside of cases where that has been explicitly agreed-upon, like EU). Something as basic as tax withholding can be literally impossible without creating a subsidiary in that country. Looking at remotewide.co, they don't say anything about having to accept applicants from all over the world. That is, think SF vs Idaho, not SF vs Siberia.
- robertlagrant 4y agoPay remote.com $500/mo per employee in a country you don't have a presence in and you're done.
- flicken 4y ago> Ok now I am more curious. I looked at another company "Expensify" [1]. They actually want you to ideally relocate to one of their office locations :). So again, not fully remote anywhere in the world. I think employers say it casually but in practice, it is extremely difficult. Out of curiosity, what makes you think Expensify wants you to relocate? Relocation was not required or suggested when I interviewed with them last year. Their current job ad shows that they support working from anywhere: "Our employees work from all over the world" and "we spend a month abroad working from a remote location as a team". I hypothesize that the part about visa sponsorship / relocation assistance might give the wrong impression: > if you're looking for a change of scene we offer visa sponsorship and relocation assistance to join us at one of our rad locations...
- JulesRosser 4y agoThanks for sharing this. That's correct, we are 100% remote first and you are not required to move to a city where we have offices. It's an optional perk.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoIf you want to get the same pay for remote work no matter where you are, just become a contractor.
- sprkwd 4y ago37 Signals. https://37signals.com/19 https://37signals.com/19
- fooster 4y agoLast I checked they only hired in the US
- flicken 4y ago37signals hires outside the US, see their HN ad from June, 2022[1]: > The salary for candidates matched as Programmer is $165,410. The salary for candidates matched as Senior Programmer is $197,819. Irrespective of where in the world you live. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31583175 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31583175
- tenarshins 4y agoWe're US only, but our salaries are flat across the US. Same salary in the Bay area and say, Moscow, Idaho.
- BeetleB 4y agoCompany?
- mxstbr 4y agoWe do at Stellate: https://stellate.co/blog/one-job-one-pay https://stellate.co/blog/one-job-one-pay
- jrockway 4y agoDo you guys share the distribution of title by location? Maybe Engineer 2 gets paid the same everywhere, but maybe San Francisco is all Engineer 10s and India is all Engineer 1s.
- JulesRosser 4y agoWe do at Expensify. A good % of our team works fully remote: https://we.are.expensify.com/benefits-perks https://we.are.expensify.com/benefits-perks Also, check out remotewide.co for a list of remote companies with location independent pay. I think this is exactly what you're looking for.
- BerislavLopac 4y agohttps://primer.io https://primer.io
- emerongi 4y agoWhat's the problem with that? If Gitlab is not paying top of the market salaries, then they're just going to miss out on top talent, and clearly they're fine with it. It's a free market after all, you don't have to join Gitlab.
- chrisan 4y agoAbsolutely nothing is wrong with it. Just don't call yourself a world leader.
- lucideer 4y agoIf there's nothing wrong with it, why would it preclude one being a world leader. (not saying GL are, there could be other unrelated things precluding it)
- rschachte 4y agoBecause being a world leader in remote work would imply they don’t do that?
- wowokay 4y agoThat doesn’t make sense? Just like universal pay doesn’t make sense unless there is a universal cost to everything.
- rschachte 4y agoIt makes sense relative to actual world leaders in tech that do not adjust pay based on location.
- codegeek 4y agoWhy should the definition of "World Leader in Remote" be based on how they pay. Why can't it be based on the fact that they allow fully remote and pay reasonably well for your area. Who decides the definition ?
- mountainriver 4y agoLast I heard they were which makes them NOT a leader in remote work lol They underpay in general which is why their product is buggy
- tapanjk 4y ago> They underpay in general which is why their product is buggy I understand the sentiment but I am not convinced that underpay is the cause of buggyness. They compete with a behemoth and it is quite a feat to stay in the game in spite of having a fraction of resources at their disposal compared to thier completion.
- mountainriver 4y agoYeah fair it's somewhat cultural, in that they are trying to roll out an insane number of features to best Github, but aren't building them with high quality
- Tao3300 4y agoMy gut feeling is that "a higher salary will make me care more" is one of things that is such common sense that the silent majority doesn't even feel like it needs to be pointed out. I find it difficult to be convinced of the contrary every time someone thinks they have a survey that says otherwise.
- ROARosen 4y agoYou pay according to location for the same bottle of Coke? How is work pay different? Why shouldn't payment for work be tied to local price ranges and cost of living?
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoWell, it is great way to make talent in HoCL areas get priced out of the market, should the market reach a point where there's enough talent in LoCL willing to work for lower rates. Theoretically, anyway.
- vernon99 4y agoBecause physical goods are subject to differently priced logistics and local ingridients and remote work is not? Seriously, how can you even compare?
- sixo 4y agoin the tech job market generally, the value of the work to the company puts an upper bar on a salary, but competition with other employers for the same worker puts a lower bar on salary (obviously along with other factors like the company's reputation, mission, benefits). In practice all salaries are set by the latter rule, which means they depend on the job market, which varies by location. That salaries should not depend on location is a fantasy based on some weird idea of people getting "paid what they deserve"—a fallacious association between your salary and your worth as a person, which people would do well to get over.
- chrisseaton 4y ago> which means they depend on the job market, which varies by location Aren't you commenting on a post about remote work? Their job market is global (within limitations.)
- nemetroid 4y agoIt’s only a global market if there’s a meaningful number of employers treating it as one. From what I’ve seen, and what the comments on this post have been able to show, such employers seem few and far between.
- deltree7 4y agoIncredibly naive to assume that in the knowledge industry, you can compare two people's work. How do you measure this?
- codegeek 4y agoIsn't that Capitalism 101 ? If employees are happy, company is happy, why does it matter ? Why should a company worry about pleasing everyone who is not necessarily part of them. If someone likes what Gitlab does, applies there and gets the salary they want, what's the issue ? If they don't like Gitlab's offer because someone else in a HCOL area may get more, you are essentially comparing with someone else. Not a good idea.
- joshmanders 4y agoIt's because talking about your salary is so widely taboo that you may think your rate of $40k salary is good because it's comfortable in your area, but most chances are you don't realize that your co-worker who has the same skill level and workload is getting paid $80k and that's a good way to piss off your employees. Pay for skills not for cost of living. You hire someone for what they can bring to the table not how much you can profit off them.
- jrochkind1 4y agoI have no opinion to express on adjusting pay for area of residence, but note that Gitlab's salaries appear to be unusually exceptionally transparent, so your story of taboos about discussing salary and secrecy of colleague's salaries probably does not apply to them. https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/total-rewards/compensation/compensation-calculator/ https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/total-rewards/compensation...
- codegeek 4y ago"You hire someone for what they can bring to the table not how much you can profit off them." Not sure if I agree with this naive view. Yes, you hire people and give them what they want in exchange for work but at the end of the day, I am absolutely trying to save money as a company and increase profits as long as I am doing it reasonably.
- webdood90 4y agofascinating how people come to the defense of corporations like this. why? do you feel that someday you'll be in their shoes and have the power to dictate salaries? you are likely a worker like everyone else here. demand better.
- Vinnl 4y agoWhat I don't get is: why would they pay more for someone from San Francisco? I'd expect the incentive to be to indeed pay the same for the same work, but that pay would be the lowest they can get away with. (i.e. I wouldn't expect that to lead to Silicon Valley salaries all over the world.) Unless it's not actually the same work, and location affects work. It does at least affect gross pay in any case, I suppose.
- rr888 4y ago> why would they pay more for someone from San Francisco? Because they probably want someone from the area working in the company. If they pay a flat rate globally, they only have to pay average or lower and get great people in LCOL areas. But then you have a company with no people in CA or NY, which means you dont have contact with local trends or contacts in the big tech companies.
- Vinnl 4y agoRight, so then location does affect the quality of the work provided. Although it then still is weird to base differentiated pay on cost of living / local market rates; surely those don't all correlate with the quality of the work delivered? If you can get an engineer with the same skills from Spain for less money than you'd pay for the equivalent in Germany, why would you hire the latter?
- kodah 4y ago> why would they pay more for someone from San Francisco? I can't answer for GitLab, but widely, people often believe that San Francisco has an "exceptional" talent pool and that companies pay a premium for that because of competition.
- Vinnl 4y agoBut in that case, it's not the same work, no? You can simply pay more for exceptional talent regardless of location, just as how org (theoretically, at least) already differentiate pay based on skill level within the same location.