6 ms·
What I find interesting is that if you give employees a choice of 100 units of currency per year as salary plus 1 unit of currency for each week on call with an
by sokoloff 4y ago
What I find interesting is that if you give employees a choice of 100 units of currency per year as salary plus 1 unit of currency for each week on call with an expectation of 1 week on call every four weeks versus 115 units of currency for the year with the same on-call expectations, some employees will feel better about the first arrangement and some will feel better about the second arrangement.
Some people want to see everything broken out and take a very transactional approach to work; others prefer the simpler approach but with less clear linkage to a specific piece of work.
- DoughnutHole 4y agoI'd say the issue for people who are inclined to pick the first arrangement is one of trust. If you don't trust your employer not to abuse the second arrangement then you'd be a fool to accept it. With the first arrangement the employer is incentivised not to exceed the agreed upon expected number of on-call weeks because they are financially penalised for additional on-call time. With the second arrangement the employer can demand as much on-call time as they think they can get away with. It's really a case of if you expect your relationship with your employer to be in some way adversarial - if you trust your employer not to screw you than go ahead, but you can't necessarily reliably make that judgement going into a new job.
- bornfreddy 4y agoI am firmly in the camp that would pick the first arrangement, but not because of (lack of) trust. It is partially due to psychological effect on me (get out of bed, you are compensated for this) and partially because the incentives of the employer are better aligned with mine. They should view 24/7 operation as something that costs money, so that they are more willing to invest in robust solutions.
- sam0x17 4y agoThe problem is once you consider it part of your standard comp, you take it for granted. If emergencies almost never happen and then one does, you will inevitably feel cheated when you have to wake up at 2 AM on a Sunday. Much better familial optics if you can tell your family "hey we got an extra $500 for that" versues "oh, dealing with these is included in my take-home salary". Even worse, if emergencies happen all the time, your family is going to hate you if you don't have some reward you can show for each one, especially if there are other jobs at your salary range that don't have an on-call clause.
- HelloNurse 4y agoWhat do you mean by "expectation"? One day on call, one day paid overtime; anything else is abusive. There should be no incentive to require or avoid "free" work, only advance planning of who'll be on call (with more available engineers doing more turns).
- mlyle 4y ago> What do you mean by "expectation"? One day on call, one day paid overtime; anything else is abusive. I don't think being available for work if an unlikely emergency comes up usually justifies the same comp as actively working that entire time.
- reddiky 4y agoIf you're having to actively shape your real life to accommodate your work life then you should be compensated (Not attending events / bringing your computer with you to dinner, etc). Do firefighters only get paid for the amount of time actively fighting fires?
- mlyle 4y agoAgain, I didn't say that you shouldn't be compensated-- just that you shouldn't be compensated at the rate if they were having you actively doing work the entire time (else, why not just have you actively do work the whole time?). > Do firefighters only get paid for the amount of time actively fighting fires? I believe firefighters tend to do 24 hour shifts, where they actively work 8 hours and are paid full rate for that (during which time they have responsibilities in maintenance, etc)... ...and are paid a reduced rate for the other 16 hours they are on standby. (Here, in my jurisdiction, it's 10 hours + 14 hours). During this time they hang out at the firehouse, but may be eating, watching TV, sleeping, etc. They do 3 of these 24 hour periods per week.
- sam0x17 4y agoMany orgs do comp their employees for the entire time they are on call. DoD does this for on-call employees due to past labor law issues, so it probably is legally required but rarely enforced.