7 ms·
Can the knees go over the toes? (2016)
- therealdrag0 4y agoThere’s also KneesOverToesGuy who focuses on deep lunges with knees over toes to get full range of motion in the knees and supporting tissues. https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCGybO-bWZ3W6URh42sdMQiw https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCGybO-bWZ3W6URh42sdMQiw
- emptyfile 4y agoI've always found something a bit off about this guy, so since finding out I feel I have to mention in regularly when he comes up: he's a Scientologist.
- cyri 4y agothanks for the heads up! Hopefully Marcus Filly isn't a Scientologist because they both sometimes do workouts together. I really like Fillys programming but ... if so, no money goes towards Scientology.
- Sheeny96 4y agoSeen this come up a few times - this may be true, but you have to separate the art from the artist in this case (in my opinion). What he teaches has solid foundations, with multiple testimonies from legitimate athletes. Whether he believes weak knees come from ancient alien souls is not my concern, but his methodologies to fix such ailments are absolutely credible.
- emptyfile 4y agoAs I said in the comment below, my point is more that I don't want to give ad revenue to people like him. >What he teaches has solid foundations, with multiple testimonies from legitimate athletes. There are many channels with similar advice, I'd rather give clicks to them. Fitness FAQ comes to mind first.
- qabqabaca 4y agoI've always found the way he talks about "world-class" and "bulletproof" knees to be pretty off-putting. These are nonsense terms with nothing but anecdata to back the claims
- emptyfile 4y agoWhenever someone is promoting "The Truth" which is so much better then the stuff other people offer, I'm immediately suspicious and repulsed. In my experience the best experts are humble.
- gregwebs 4y agoHe actually has objective definitions for world class: can perform a certain range of movement with a certain strength. Bulletproof is just another term for robustness or avoiding injury and here he sometimes refers to studies on injury.
- qabqabaca 4y agoWhat is the point of an objective definition if its subjectively determined by one person? Who is he to decide what is world-class and what isn't? And for "bulletproof", I know what it means. It's, again, just another subjective term he throws around carelessly. Something bulletproof is something near indestructuble. Does he guarantee no injuries for life if you complete the course?
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoTom Cruise is a scientologist, and he's a good actor. Maybe KneesOverToesGuy is a scientologist and knows a lot about knees! It's not like being a scientologist makes you completely incompetent.
- emptyfile 4y ago>Maybe KneesOverToesGuy is a scientologist and knows a lot about knees! He seems to have good advice, my point is more that I don't want to give ad revenue to people like him. >It's not like being a scientologist makes you completely incompetent. No, but the thing I've always disliked about him is the "cult-ish" (ha) tone of his videos, like he's showing us the secret sauce only he knows and not a series of exercises that people have been doing for decades but fell out of fashion. I'm not impressed by his boasting at all and I've seen similar advice to his on many channels.
- kojeovo 4y agoWhy does that matter exactly?
- matsemann 4y agoHis advice is good for one (albeit common) type of knee injury. It's a bit annoying he think he's solved all people's knee issues. Or, I guess it's just so everyone will buy his program. It also irks me how he sometimes play into a "big pharma" kinda conspiracy. That "everyone" says you shouldn't have knees in front of toes, but he is the single person looking through this ruse and selling you the secret. FWIW I've had patellar tendonitis before, and the rehab I got was doing eccentric squats on an inclined surface, explicitly to get my knees over the toes and help put a balanced load on the tendon. So his "secret" has been the common approach for at least a decade.
- gregwebs 4y agoBut my experience is concordant with the submitted article: always being told to keep the knees over the toes. I don’t know what this has to do with big Pharma and it’s not a conspiracy, but it seems to have achieved common knowledge status and needs to be changed.
- gmadsen 4y agonot sure what videos you watched, but he has plenty of videos citing his sources of work done in the 70s and 80s. He also recommends far more and varied movements than the split squat.
- simonsaysso 4y agoWe’re told that you need to squat with a vertical spine and vertical shins. Even high school kids figure out that’s impossible to do. I’m in full alignment with the article: squatting is just about balance in the end: how can you keep your center of gravity over mid foot as you bring your hips below (or near) your knees and back up again. You might find cues that help you find a good, repeatable position (break at the hips, stay tall, weight back, drop into your ankles, knees out, etc), but that’s personal to you. If you squat a lot, you’ll find the positions that knock you off balance, or bother your hips, or cause strain on your ankles, or whatever, and learn to avoid them with cues that help you find the groove where nothing hurts.
- fruit2020 4y agoSince this is HN, does anyone know of new advances in cartilage repair? I just a deep cartilage defect in my femur at the knee joint because one stupid squash game. Reading about osteoarthritis is so depressing. Take care of your knees!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t_mann 4y agoNutrition and regular movement. Don't worry, you'll be fine, had a similar thing a few years ago, all gone. Be careful about surgeries, last time I checked the consensus seemed to be converging on that in this case they're largely placebos.
- doix 4y agoDepending on how far off the deep-end you want to go, you can look into: peptides (BPC-157, TB-500), Human Growth Hormone and Platelet-Rich Plasma injections (PRP). There might be more stuff out there now, it's been a few years since I looked into it for a SLAP tear in my shoulder. If you are in the USA, look into "anti aging" or "longevity" clinics. It's basically gymbro MD's that will prescribe you that stuff for money. Then at least you can be fairly certain that you know what you're injecting. Otherwise, you're at the mercy of the dodgy websites/alibaba for acquiring the stuff. Obviously there is no definitive proof that the stuff works or if it's safe, otherwise it would be significantly more common. You can google, there are many small scale studies done on those compounds of varying degrees of quality. It all depends on your risk-tolerances etc. Ideally you'd be somewhere in the US near one of those clinics and could speak to a real doctor about your options, and not a random idiot from hackernews :D.
- gavinray 4y agoBPC-157 is your best shot, have loads of experience with it and nothing but good things to say. Have also used TB-500, and a dozen other peptides, but for injuries there's nothing like BPC. Unfortunately the feds are starting to crack down both SARMs and Peptides so they aren't as easy to get as they were 5 years ago =/
- nonrandomstring 4y agoI was way too heavy when I started getting fit again so squats hurt my knees and I frequency lost balance. Switching to supported squats with a table and executing them really slowly worked wonders [1]. Now my legs are strong again and some weight has come off, my form for unsupported bodyweight squats is great and I can do dozens without joint pain. [1[ advice in Wade's convict conditioning programme.
- dvt 4y agoIf you're doing ATG squats and you're over, say, 5'10"ish (though there's skeletal variation), it's impossible to do a squat without the knees going over the toes (simply because of the proportions of your femur to your tibia). I'm pretty sure this myth started on idiotic bro-science forums like bodybuilding.com or the like.
- sinisterfeller 4y agoOn the contrary, there is absolutely no way this started on bodybuilding.com. Even a quick Google search attributes Karl Klein with this brilliant myth
- cosgrove 4y agoSupposedly started with this study from 1978: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Kinetics-of-the-parallel-squat.-Mclaughlin-Lardner/9c60878a8a382f05e73fd26f302b8ba571d8c00b https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Kinetics-of-the-parall...
- ehnto 4y agoI was wondering why I had never heard of this advice, and it's because I started lifting in a powerlifting focused circle so the advice was always hips back, weight on the heel. We also only go past parallel in depth, we can get impressively deep but you don't tend to see that transitional moment where the body shape changes and weight shifts to get ATG. There is also no way I would want to be in that transitional phase with the amount of weight powerlifting asks of you, I think you'd be pretty compromised with the low bar squat. I have never had trouble with my knees using powerlifting technique. My first injury was actually when I tried to transition into a general strength focus and started doing highbar squats, it was probably just my lack of experience with highbar and an overconfidence from my previous lifting lowbar, but I tweaked my back. It took over a year to recover fully.
- mudrockbestgirl 4y agoLooks easy and obvious, but getting the ankle and hip mobility required to squat properly this is quite difficult for us who spend most of their in front of computers. When I started lifting, my squats sucked, and I didn't even realize before I hired a trainer who told me. I had to significantly reduce my squat weight and start from scratch paying attention to doing deep squats with good form. It took me about a year of consistent mobility training to get the ankle mobility and hip internal rotation required to squat right. Though if you wear lifting shoes that's a nice shortcut. It can reduce the mobility requirements significantly. I prefer to squat without lifting shoes just because I want to be able to do it naturally, and I don't compete or anything like that.
- djmips 4y agoHow to improve ankle mobility?
- imperistan 4y agoCheck out ATG split squats
- digdugdirk 4y agoCheck out the Squat University youtube channel for instructional videos on "Banded Ankle Mobilizations". Completely changed the game for my squats, with instant results. I incorporate them (along with a similar hip mobilization drill) before all of my squat workouts. Highly recommended.
- mudrockbestgirl 4y agoYou can find lots of good exercises and drills on YouTube, but are you sure you are asking the right question? Are you 100% sure that ankle mobility is your problem? In my case, I thought that ankle mobility is my problem but after working on my ankles for several months I didn't see the huge improvement I expected, and only then I realized that I have other mobility deficiencies such as hip flexion and rotation and my spine. If you are not sure what your problem is, you should hire and expert for an assessment. A lot of the stuff you find online is great, but only if you exactly know what you're looking for.
- elric 4y agoThere's so much "bro-science" when it comes to exercise. I suspect many of this nonsense comes from people getting injured by doing too much too soon, and then generalizing it. Like toes in squats, or pelvic tilt in squats, or locking knees in leg presses. There's some truth that all of these can be dangerous if you're a beginner and you're handling more weight than you should. But the whole point of exercise is that your body adapts. You need to give it time. Tendons, ligaments, and joints take much longer to "get stronger" than muscle does.
- justsomeuser 4y agoTwo things I have found that improve my squat technique are: - 1. Push the sacrum-point as far back as possible for the entire movement, keeping your back straight. I have found this reduces the number of things I am focusing on and seems to be comfortable. - 2. Focus on explosive-like movement from the bottom. I find exerting my effort at the bottom of the squat to the first 20% of the lift creates momentum, and avoids slow and unnatural pauses which seems to cause me injuries.
- gpestana 4y agoThis is a super interesting case of how outdated ideas (ie. knees can _never_ go over toes) become pervasive in people's minds, almost to the point of a myth that is very hard to dispel. The story of kneesovertoesguy is amazing btw, I recommend checking his podcast episodes/youtube channel and training program (https://www.atgonlinecoaching.com/ https://www.atgonlinecoaching.com/) which focus on knee and lower body strengthening that uses exercises that were a no-go for many experts not too long ago. (EDIT: sorry for the plug, I'm not related to kneesovertoesguy or his business in any way -- I just noticed the landing page I shared above is literally a call to pay for his courses. I'm not and never been a subscriber but do enjoy and have been seeing real benefits from doing exercises he goes through on his youtube for free. So I hope it helps!)
- codingdave 4y agoI always heard the guidance to not put knees beyond toes in the context of kung fu - that it won't hurt you when you are young, but that avoiding it will force you to practice proper stances and gain the correct strength and flexibility when you are young, so that poor technique doesn't become habit and you will remain strong into old age. I have zero actual science or research behind that guidance - it is just what I was taught. But it does make me wonder if that would be a better way to explain it - not to avoid injury but purely as a marker of proper technique. (And clearly, weight lifting has different markers than kung fu.)
- jmilloy 4y agoThe simple thing that I think is missing here is that you can squat in an upright position with your knees in front of your toes or with your torso forwards with your shins vertical (or anywhere in between). And both are okay! What you can't do is vertical shins and vertical torso! As you sit more upright, your knees have to go forwards (past your toes) for balance. Kelly Starrett: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4QJ36zMt5bc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4QJ36zMt5bc
- philoinvestor 4y agoYes, that dogma is wrong and outdated. What matters is a full-functioning healthy body, not preconceived notions such as that.
- xwdv 4y agoI only do squats with a safety squat bar and elevated heels. The SSB helps prevent injuries and the elevated heels allows me to sink very low into the squat. Because of the reduced risk of injury, I could squat confidently far more often with more weight and see much better gains in strength and size. After a certain age, learning to do exercises while minimizing risk of injuries becomes a much higher priority if you plan to continue working out for a long time. Seen too many people mess up their backs with barbell squats.
- jasonladuke0311 4y agoSSBs are awesome (I bought one), especially for us computer touchers. Doing proper squats with a SSB requires a lot of thoracic extension which helps counteract the bunching we do all day. Thoracic mobility tends to suck in desk-bound people and it can contribute to a host of mobility issues throughout the rest of the body.
- nunez 4y agoSame. I always shake my head when I see people at the gym use the power rack to squat _outside of the rack with no safety rails_. It's slightly less annoying to see than those who use the rack to do curls, but it's still annoying to see. I also do bench presses with safety rails. still get full upper body activation but significantly minimize the chance of a tweaked back. also lets me bench heavier since i don't need to worry about getting a spot.
- mattferderer 4y agoExcellent video that discusses how different body types reflect how you can do squats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Av3LO2GwpAk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Av3LO2GwpAk
- mynegation 4y agoI lift weights, recreationally and that immediately sounded bogus to me. One has to keep the center line of the mass over the middle of the feet. I can squat without knees going over toes and maintain that maybe up to a point where thighs are horizontal, by leaning forward with a bar. Past certain point, in a deep squat, no amount of upper body hinge allows me to maintain proper center of mass and knees go over toes to compensate.
- philipwhiuk 4y agoI inherently distrust places that aren't academically recognized but try to imply they have academic credentials. "Squat University" Bunch of rubbish. This has been posted by the same guy repeatedly every 6 months for the past 5 years. Shilling for clicks.
- goldenchrome 4y agoI think you inherently distrust something else, perhaps places that don’t look like they were created for nerds. The man behind Squat University and the author of this article is Dr. Aaron Horschig who has a PhD in physical therapy and a bachelors in exercise science. He also wrote the Squat Bible with over 1000 5* reviews on Amazon. He’s trained many world class athletes including multiple World’s Strongest Man winner Martins Licis. Aaron is known for being a leading expert in sports science.