5 ms·
> Unfortunately, the pop-culture misunderstandings about "low serotonin" can mislead a lot of people into thinking that research like this debunks SSRIs. It doe
by tsimionescu 4y ago
> Unfortunately, the pop-culture misunderstandings about "low serotonin" can mislead a lot of people into thinking that research like this debunks SSRIs. It doesn't. As I said above, we've known for decades that something else is going on. This isn't actually a surprise to anyone in the field.
The article itself quotes one of the authors of the study, who is attending medical school in psychiatry, as starting that his training explicitly made this claim, that his textbooks make this claim, and that he himself was later passing it down to other students.
Other sources quoted by the news article are similar to your own claims. Overall, it sounds like there are camps in psychiatry that have indeed long abandoned this theory, but others who still hold onto it.
Furthermore, the meta analysis being talked about in the article does make the additional claim that SSRIs are perhaps not necessary for the treatment of depression. I don't believe they are right, but it's also misleading to suggest that theur research is entirely in line with psychiatric orthodoxy.
- PragmaticPulp 4y agoTo be clear: The serotonin deficiency hypothesis has been floated for a long time as one of the possible underlying changes involved in depression etiology. It’s not even a stretch, given that we can find upregulations of the serotonin transporter in response to chronic unpredictable mild stress, the fact that 5-HTP (serotonin precursors) supplementation can boost mood, and the fact that many drugs of abuse operate through serotonin receptors to alter mood. However, like I said in my post above, we’ve know for decades that it’s not the explanation because SSRIs boost extrasynaptic serotonin levels within hours but their therapeutic efficacy is famously delayed by weeks. I suppose it’s possible that the author had some weird textbook that misrepresented the state of research, or that he misunderstood the relative confidence and significant of each theory presented. However, the state of research didn’t even believe that the serotonin hypothesis of depression was the full, accurate explanation when SSRIs were introduced for the reasons I stated above and more.
- hn8305823 4y agoI've tried lots of natural anti-depressant remedies. Background: I've suffered with major depression my entire life with frequent suicidal ideation and several near-suicides. It's fairly seasonal and wile it happens throughout the year the worst time is in the winter near the solstice. I've also struggled with difficulty falling asleep since very young childhood, though that has gotten somewhat better with age (over 50 now). ** warning ** If you are on any prescription anti-depressants, don't stop taking them or modify your routine without talking to your doctor first. 5-HTP: nasty side effects from unwanted metabolism in the gut and excess serotonin levels in the brain that border on serotonin syndrome sometimes. After the initial 8 hours or so of bad side effects the anti-depressant effects last for about two days followed by a very hard crash on day 3. During the 2 "good" days the quality of the effect is a bit "off" and gives me an unusually "comfortable feeling" that is while much better than depression is not the most productive or normal feeling (see melatonin below for contrast). Be extremely careful with 5-HTP, serious serotonin syndrome can easily develop, especially if you are on other anti-depressants and can be fatal. I don't take 5-HTP anymore because of these side effects and better options (below). THC: Very effective during use (edibles = 4-6 hours), but tolerance levels build requiring higher doses. mild anti-depressant effects trail off gradually after day or two and quality is generally good. Of course cannabis has some side effects: short term memory impairment, general slight cognitive reduction but I have found these side effects can be virtually eliminated with L-Dopa (see below) L-Dopa: Taken with vitamin B-6, this is one of the few things I have found that enhances the cannabis experience rather than taking away from it. This increases dopamine levels in the brain which enhances the high and for me also seems to miraculously eliminate the side effects of cannabis (maybe this is due to offsetting dopamine depletion by THC?). I have also found that L-Dopa even seems to increase general cognitive functioning beyond undoing the effects of THC (maybe reversing age related degredation? It makes my brain feel like it did when I was 18). L-Dopa does have serious side effects however: It dramatically and seriously increases anxiety/paranoia for several hours so I only take it with cannabis edibles and even then not every time, no more than once per week. It's very important to know how to manage paranoia since THC also frequently triggers paranoia and the L-Dopa seems to amplify that. My method is to consciously and affirmatively "acknowledge and disregard" any paranoid or anxiety related thoughts. I have found that once I consciously identify and acknowledge certain thoughts are caused by the drugs/supplements and are not real (or as important as they seem), they disappear and everything is ok. Melatonin: This is by far the best anti-depressant I have ever used. Essentially no side effects other than putting you to sleep 30 mins after use, which when taken before bed is a huge plus (I have had difficulty falling asleep my entire life). Anti-depressant effects last for a few days, gradually trailing off without the hard crash of 5-HTP. The quality of the effect is also excellent (much better than 5-HTP). The best way I can describe it is "feeling healthy, energetic yet relaxed, and normal" most of the time. It's like a miracle drug, at least for me. I take 5mg every 3-4 days as needed.
- cwkoss 4y agoI've heard people say that the serotonin deficiency hypothesis was invented by drug companies rather than academics. Is that true?
- heavyset_go 4y ago"Low serotonin" was a marketing simplification at one point a decade or more ago. Whether companies were the source of that simplification is up in the air, but they certainly leaned into it in their marketing.