4 ms·
> When vigilantism is the only justice available you’re living in a failed state. What you're observing isn't a 'failed state'. The apparatus of the state is w
by vkou 4y ago
> When vigilantism is the only justice available you’re living in a failed state.
What you're observing isn't a 'failed state'. The apparatus of the state is working quite fine, and the state is completely capable of enforcing its will on its subjects. [1]
What you're observing is the police doing their job[2] (Which is protecting the state), and not the job you want them to do (protecting you and yours.)
[1] The definition of a failed state is one that is incapable of enforcing its will on its subjects. Which is what you see in, say, 2021 Afghanistan, where the central government is only theoretically in charge, with Taliban rebels actually being able to enforce their will on the country. There's a categorical difference between 'can't' and 'can't be arsed to' - and you're observing the latter.
[2] Why doing that job entitles them to half of your municipal taxes is an exercise for the reader.
- carbadtraingood 4y agoDon't know why you are downvoted, you're 100% correct. Police do not exist to help individuals, they exist to maintain the state monopoly on violence and to protect capital. If individuals get any benefit from this it's either accidental or police trying to protect their image.
- astrange 4y agoThe anecdote above is about police not "protecting capital", stopping a store robber is "protecting capital" as opposed to "helping individuals".
- mmmpop 4y agoI thought we lived in a democracy, aren't rulers also subjects???