3 ms·
> That's either alot of corruption that's been caught due to whistleblower rewards or an indication of the amount of corruption in the US if you are more cynica
by gumby 4y ago
> That's either alot of corruption that's been caught due to whistleblower rewards or an indication of the amount of corruption in the US if you are more cynical.
Given a stock market of around $100T (and the SEC covers more than stocks) it would argue for a rather small amount of corruption, were it the only signal.
In fact I believe the corruption at this level is quite small. Really, why bother when you can do it wholesale (e.g. telecoms simply capturing the regulators)?
> Whsitleblower's are eligible for 10 to 30% of the money collected from fines, so the SEC is also making alot of money from this as well.
These fines go to the treasury; it's not like they fund operations from it.
BTW civil forfeiture, if you even believe in it at all, should go to the state or federal general funds. The current system is simply legalized theft.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> In fact I believe the corruption at this level is quite small. Really, why bother when you can do it wholesale (e.g. telecoms simply capturing the regulators) That is still corruption. Sufficiently provable and easy to convict corruption might be small. Quid pro quo corruption where nothing is in writing is huge.
- soledades 4y ago
- elil17 4y agoThere is a very interesting podcast episode on "Freakonomics" where they interview a researcher who posits that there are forms of corruption that speed economic growth at the cost of fairness and other forms which do not speed economic growth. https://freakonomics.com/podcast/season-11-episode-12/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/season-11-episode-12/
- gumby 4y agoSure it is, but my point is you’re not getting any information from signal (the number of SEC whistleblowers) when the real corruption is elsewhere.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI have a feeling that a system with no corruption would be far less efficient and productive than one with some corruption
- thatguy0900 4y agoA system can be more effecient and more productive and still be worse for the common person in it. Probably a lot of people on hns lives would be better of if they could reliably grease the palms of people around them with some pocket change, but the average person?
- dahart 4y agoThat might be true according to some of the economic measures we’ve used in the past. But why should maximum efficiency and productivity even be the goal if it does damage? How efficient and productive is enough? If things could be efficient enough to support society without corruption, maybe we should prioritize safety over corruption even if it is less efficient? This idea that a little badness is more efficient than no badness has played out multiple times in the past and one thing we’ve learned repeatedly is that humans are pretty bad at understanding and accounting for the full and true economic costs of a little badness, especially the humans that are making money. More often than not the damage done by badness is externalized and the costs ignored by the people who are profiting from the environment that tolerates the badness. There are plenty of examples of this from the environment to product safety standards to the stock market. It was argued (fiercely) that the costs of seatbelts in cars was too high a price to pay for something that wasn’t helping every driver - most people, after all, don’t crash. This flawed thinking completely failed to capture the economic costs of car accidents, and today very few people even in the auto industry would disagree or even think of arguing against seatbelts. We still don’t grasp the economic costs of pollution. We’re just starting to see the economic damage that allowing a little badness has had over the last century, and it’s already many orders of magnitude higher than most people thought several decades ago. Similary, we’ve not really tallied the economic costs of poor people who’ve been pushed into bankruptcy by financial corruption. The growing inequality driven in part by lack of financial regulation is almost certainly fueling our political unrest, which we of course haven’t measured economically, and might not end well.
- sgjohnson 4y ago> BTW civil forfeiture, if you even believe in it at all, should go to the state or federal general funds. The current system is simply legalized theft. It’d still be basically legalized theft even if it went to state/federal treasury. There should be no such thing as a civil asset fortfeiture.
- gumby 4y ago> There should be no such thing as a civil asset fortfeiture. Well yes, I agree, I;m just pointing out the perverse incentive in how it is done.