4 ms·
The trouble with these comparisons is that they assume the world remains static while only prices change. But the positional status of the same kind of product
by rayiner 4y ago
The trouble with these comparisons is that they assume the world remains static while only prices change. But the positional status of the same kind of product or the same brand can also change in the market. For example, movie theaters used to be the only way to watch movies in 1960. Today, big screen LCDs and streaming are affordable to the median family. As a result, theaters have had to move upmarket to offer a compelling alternative to watching movies at home. It’s not just that the theaters are way nicer, which they are, but that they necessarily occupy a higher end segment of the entertainment sector because other products have filled in some of the mass market segment.
Cars are another good example of this. A 1985 Honda Accord is just not as nice of a car as a 2022 Honda Accord: https://www.netcarshow.com/honda/1985-accord_sedan https://www.netcarshow.com/honda/1985-accord_sedan. Not only in absolute terms, but in relative terms. The Accord occupies a premium segment of the market today compared to 1985.
Disney, likewise, is much bigger and better today. The hotels are much nicer. Tech conditions people to expect better products for less money every year, but that doesn’t translate into meat space. A bigger park with more attractions, nicer and cleaner hotel rooms, etc., all cost more to build and maintain even in inflation-adjusted terms.
- havblue 4y agoI agree that cars are better, but are vacation destinations like Disney really better? If you see parade footage from magic kingdom in the nineties you'll see that the crowds are far less. Sure there's more variety, more thrill rides and more alcohol, but I'm not sure the crowds and increased expenses are worth it. Ditto on Las Vegas as far as prices are concerned.
- rayiner 4y agoI mean “better” in material terms. Things were just more bare bones back then: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/the-old-disneyland-hotel-photo-taken-late-70s-to-early-80s--388013324121927086/ https://www.pinterest.com/pin/the-old-disneyland-hotel-photo...
- thrashh 4y agoThere’s definitely more quality to the park. There’s also more people but I think that’s an entirely separate issue. There are just more people on Earth than there was 10, 20 or 500 years ago. Maybe we aren’t building enough new attractions. There is probably money in it.
- ROTMetro 4y agoWhile Disney is amazing, the hotels (15 years age at least) were awful, yet totally worth it. The kids visiting with characters at breakfast and the characters remembering their names when they saw them in the park later you would not think that was worth the money but after seeing the joy on your kids face, holy moly, some of the best spent money in my life. Reliving those moments will sustain you as an old man. Make bad financial choices when it comes to your kids, because when you are older and it finally makes more sense financially, it's too late.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd spend the money on experiences vs things - this is where the "adult preparation" can come into play, and deciding which things to aim money at. And also abuse every single possible thing you can, birthdays, etc, and don't be afraid to ask.
- mbfg 4y agoyou make rational arguments here, and i don't disagree. The issue is, there are no "cheap new cars", for any rational definition of cheap, as could be compared to cars in the 80s. and while you don't need a movie theater experience, a car is much more a requirement for large segments of people. Sure you can get a used car, but the point of the article is a comparison to what you used to be able to have. i'd love to get a $12K 1985 "New Civic" now.
- xyzzyz 4y agoYou can buy cheap used car. A 5 years old used car today will be nicer, more convenient, safer and more reliable than new Civic in 1985.