4 ms·
IANAL but this seems like a bit of a shaky/grey area - you couldn't make your decision not to let the room on the basis of someone not being/identifying as LGBT
by OJFord 4y ago
IANAL but this seems like a bit of a shaky/grey area - you couldn't make your decision not to let the room on the basis of someone not being/identifying as LGBT right? So this is kind of facilitating avoiding that 'problem' arising?
I mean, imagine 'mystraightflatmate.com', the site to help you find a non-LGBT flatmate.. :/
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoAs OP said [1], this is for LGBT persons looking for an LGBT-friendly flatware. They make be gay, trans, straight or a kitten. What they (CLARIFICATION: the flatmates advertising) aren’t is homophobic. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32154272 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32154272
- OJFord 4y agoI understand that and I sympathise, but a similar/opposite case of B&B owners not wanting a homosexual couple has been tested in UK courts: though as business owners they may refuse custom, they may not (under the discrimination act) do so on the basis of (among other protected characteristics) homosexuality. (I'm certainly not saying OP's homophobic - I don't know where that came from.)
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoLegal protection versus social comfort. I, too, would take issue if the site were only for LGBT landlords or tenants. But it’s not. It’s for those comfortable broadcasting their comfort. Given the distance between the letter of the law and reality when it comes to LGBT rights and safety, this is a practical concern for e.g. gay youth kicked out of their homes who won’t be fighting anyone in court. For historical analogy, consider American hotels in the 60s advertising they’re Black friendly. They’re not only for Black Americans. But they’re welcoming towards them in a way others, following the letter but perhaps not spirit of the law, are not.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoNo; the site does not reject people on the basis of sexuality, but it does advertise places which are not homophobic. It's very clearly different.
- OJFord 4y agoRight, and in doing so facilitates avoiding that 'problem', as I said top-level. I don't really have a problem with it personally, for what it's worth, I find that law a bit problematic (it seems to preclude 'positive/affirmative action', not that I like that much either, for one thing: can a male applicant sue for being passed over in favour of a lesser-qualified female candidate because a firm wanted to improve its diversity?) I was just discussing it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bergenty 4y agoA little common sense is required here. Almost no one discriminates against straight people in any way that is debilitating. So it isn’t really an issue (yet at least) and going down this path is similar to the “All lives matter” in response to “Black lives matter”. It manifests as a way to passively express bigotry rather than a genuine, sincere claim.
- OJFord 4y agoI slightly regret the 'mystraightflatmate.com' analogy, because that wasn't my intent at all, I was just thinking about the law - which is I suppose necessarily 'all lives matter' if you like; it's the enforcement of it that (either through nonexistence of certain groups being wronged, or it not being 'in any way that is debilitating' so never sued for) species it - not really making a personal judgement at all.