6 ms·
It's bizarre that this can happen at the same time as widespread staff shortages are being reported in some sectors, but there we are. https://www.theweek.co.uk
by pjc50 4y ago
It's bizarre that this can happen at the same time as widespread staff shortages are being reported in some sectors, but there we are. https://www.theweek.co.uk/business/economy/956951/labour-shortages-urgent-problem-economy https://www.theweek.co.uk/business/economy/956951/labour-sho...
It seems to me that decades of industrial policy have been aimed at clamping down any means to demand nominal wage increases, especially through industrial action, so we are now stuck in a low-wage staff shortage situation; this would be a great time to invest capital in productivity increases, especially while interest rates are below inflation, but British management culture is too dysfunctional for even that. And the government are not going to do anything useful because they're busy competing for the top job, egged on by a press who don't care about industrial policy or wages.
- dazc 4y agoI remember looking for casual work ten years ago and a lot of jobs had hours arranged to specifically attract people who were happy to have their income subsidised by benefits. Since there were plenty of available workers it was a good game they were playing. Now the same employers are complaining they can't attract people to apply for the same shitty deal as if they are entitled to have a surplus of people to pick from. The problem is now that the cost of housing has more than doubled over the past ten years and now we have an inflation problem too. They can't double the pay and, even if they could, this would just be adding fuel to the fire. How this will play out, I don't know, but maybe we don't need multiple versions of the same kind of business and only those who can get the staff will survive and prosper?
- _dain_ 4y ago>hours arranged to specifically attract people who were happy to have their income subsidised by benefits. You don't know the half of it. I got stuck in this trap when I was a teenager: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/aug/30/poundland-work-free-government-scheme-dwp https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/aug/30/poundland-w... It was outrageous.
- pjc50 4y agoIt was illegal. Until the government lost in court and retroactively changed the law. Absolutely disguising piece of abuse of power by the Tory government. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/mar/15/dwp-law-change-jobseekers-poundland https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/mar/15/dwp-law-chan...
- origin_path 4y agoThe issue is the benefits system broke down during lockdowns. The sanctions/checking if you can actually work part was suspended and the civil service never really restarted it. Now more than 5 million people are claiming out of work benefits despite there being an abundance of work. Employers are complaining because they are competing against a benefits system that theoretically acts as unemployment insurance and encourages people to find work, but in reality is currently just giving out free money. It's a sort of real time experiment in UBI for the lower paid classes. The result is predictable: many firms cannot compete against the state paying people not to work. Lockdowns have had all sorts of weird side effects like this. COVID became a sort of wildcard justification for anything at all, and government departments used it to do whatever they secretly wanted to do anyway (give out free money without the "being mean" parts, working from home even as backlogs at their departments soar, etc).
- pjc50 4y agoI find this hard to believe given the history of things like Universal Credit. > working from home even as backlogs at their departments soar There's no evidence that this affected efficiency?
- origin_path 4y agoThere's an article here on the 5 million problem, that talks about Universal Credit and ponders what's gone wrong. Telegraph is usually paywalled but you may be able to find a way around: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/06/02/benefits-britain-back-condemning-millions-dependency/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/06/02/benefits-britain... Firstly, he tackles the bogus claim that it's to do with Brexit: "Immigration has bounced back. There is no Brexit-sized hole in our workforce; not anymore. Immigrants now account for one in five workers in Britain, the highest ratio ever." Then he tackles the definitions used for unemployment stats: "The low unemployment claim is a mirage. Britain has, in fact, been suffering a period of mass joblessness as big as any in our recent history. The proportion of people who are neither in work or looking for it is higher now than it was in the mid-1970s. More than five million people were claiming out-of-work benefits at the last count – a figure as big as the population of Scotland. But many of them don’t count as unemployed, because they’re not looking for jobs. So – presto! – they vanish from the national debate." Parts of the UK have become massively dependent on benefits: "In Blackpool, official figures show 26 per cent on out-of-work benefits. In Middlesbrough it was 23 per cent, in Hartlepool 22 per cent, in Manchester, it’s 18 per cent." Why doesn't the Universal Credit system fix that? It's as I said: "Why? How did we get here? How did Universal Credit, the flagship reform of the Cameron era, start to produce the problems that it was designed to solve? It was created with strings of conditionality on welfare payments, with sanctions imposed if people turned down jobs or missed face-to-face meetings. During lockdown, the conditions were abandoned – and never properly restored. So the new system has started to trap people in welfare as surely as the old one did. It has started to become an issue in Cabinet."
- boringg 4y agoIt also seems to me that companies are unwilling to raise prices because they are concerned about a recession and that demand is not robust for their product. Therefore they don't hire anyone since hiring has a long lead time and commitment. You end up in a situation where if supply is constrained but demand is strong enough and companies can, in the short run, raise prices but not have to employ more people which mitigates downside risk of adding additional cost structure and commitment of new employees. Not a great long run strategy though these are strange times.
- drewcoo 4y agoThey raised prices. We called it "inflation" and blamed COVID and Putin.
- kyrra 4y agoMy understanding if you ask a university of Chicago economist is that you need to follow the playbook of Paul Volcker, and raise interest rates above the rate of inflation. The fed is slowly working their way there, but they are doing it super slowly because they worry about shocking the market too hard and stopping all investment. But many believe that inflation will continue until interest rates are much closer aligned to it. This is also a failure of the Fed to raise interest rates when times weren't bad. Interest rates should have been at 2% before inflation started taking off, but people were addicted the cheap, almost free money but they didn't want to give it up. This works because having interest rates at the rate of inflation will cause more people and businesses to slow down their spending as they feel like they aren't losing money by not spending it. I believe the Keynesian approach to fix high inflation is to just raise tax rates to get money out of the economy. I believe this doesn't work as well because the extra tax dollars are then spent by the government, which are them competing for goods and services, though probably in different areas, but it's still keeping that money in the economy which will keep prices high. The only way I could see this working is if the extra tax money was used to pay down debt, which I doubt anyone in the US government would do.
- kergonath 4y ago> I believe the Keynesian approach to fix high inflation is to just raise tax rates to get money out of the economy. But this tends to lead to recessionary behavior within the economy. Build some infrastructure with these taxes. In this case, also massive investments towards improving productivity. That’ll put the money to good use and at least prime the pump for recovery, and private businesses do not seem willing or capable of doing that.
- kyrra 4y agoI don't think our Congress actually cares about our economy enough to do something that smart. But you also have the problem of those dollars then going towards labor and materials, which will keep demand there high, continuing inflationary pressure in those areas.
- 4y ago
- Zenst 4y agoI can't help but feel that many aspects of manual low-skill manual labour have seen managment drift along with plasters with some dream that robots that will do it all are just around the corner and soon. Which has lead to just plicating enough and getting away with what they can to tick along the current labour they hope to replace soon. Certainly decades of fruit picking robots been bounced about as if it's how it will all be done very soon. Indeed, been many aspects of that which have fed into this mindset in upper managment. More to the extent that the relationship with the employer and employee has seen the employer view employee's as an assit on a balance sheet along with their anual cost of MS Word. Indeed, may find with the EULA that MS Word is better protected than some employee's. After all if Microsoft increases it's rate, users don't go on strike or have a uninion to say stand up and voice concerns. Some employees do have unions and yet, the media will only jump upon their strikes which are born out of failure of the employee to act and always end with them changing their views to some degree.
- turns0ut 4y agoDecades ago, Mitt Romney and crew once made employees build the stage he stood on to announce they’re all fired. Seeing employees as nothing more than a cost center is not new. Unions were busted, pensions ransacked, through decades of leveraged buyouts, intentionally torpedoing worker savings. This was no accident; in the US, just like Brexit, it was intentional on the part of business and legislators. Consolidated power over agency is their goal.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt is possible because the people in the bottom deciles can experience increases in pay, while people in upper deciles experience decreases in pay (in real terms). A wealth transfer from richer to poorer. I view it as a good thing. Even in the US, I see stores/restaurants closing earlier, closed on Sundays, and job advertisements on the side of buildings advertising pay rates. That means the people at the bottom are finally gaining negotiating power.
- pjc50 4y agoI've heard of this happening, but to what extent is this true in the UK?
- tlocke 4y agoWhenever someone says, 'we have a staff shortage' I hear, 'we're not paying a high enough salary'.
- rightbyte 4y agoYe. Unless it is like welders or nurses we are talking about. Then you might have a shortage for not paying enough historically too.
- tzs 4y agoHigher pay usually can get someone to take the position, but if it does so by getting someone to leave their job at one of your competitors to fill your opening it has just shifted the shortage from you to your competitor. If you are in a competitive market and you were able to raise pay, your competitors will probably be able to raise pay too, and so they will also raise pay to fill their shortages. Someone will raise pay to be higher than yours and then you are the one gaining a shortage to provide a worker to fill someone else's shortage. Net short term result: you and your competitors still have shortages, but are now all paying more, and are possibly in a feedback loop that will continue to raise pay without fixing your staffing problems. You may have to raise prices, and then not only did raising pay fail to solve your staffing problems it increased inflation. Whether or not that is also the medium or long term result depends on how easy it is and how long it takes for the new higher pay in your industry to bring in new workers to your field instead of just shuffling existing workers between companies. Even if it does bring new workers to your field if those come from other fields it might be shifting the shortages to those other fields, which might then go through their own cycles of raising pay that only accomplishes shuffling shortages between them.
- drewcoo 4y ago> It's bizarre that this can happen at the same time as widespread staff shortages are being reported in some sectors No. It's exactly the same condition, but people are telling the story from different points of view. Workers aren't getting paid any more, and with inflation, it's effectively a lot less. Companies who scoop up cash via inflation just can't find workers who want to work for what the companies are willing to pay. This is the result of neoliberal policies leading to a return of robber barons.