What I was commenting on was your categorical claim that the selected portion of the original comment was false and you have not provided that mathematical "pro

What I was commenting on was your categorical claim that the selected portion of the original comment was false and you have not provided that mathematical "proof". As for a single counter example, you need to demonstrate that the counter example is applicable. I don't think you have. At least not to the degree that would support your categorical claim. In regards to both of your views, I am making no statement as to validity or otherwise of those statements. This is simply a matter of asking for you and him to provide supporting evidence for your respective positions. This would then allow further discussion on the views and their evidence.