5 ms·
Well, that makes sense. An ebike is really a light motorcycle, and needs similar safety systems. Harleys from the 1920s look like modern fat-tire ebikes.[1] [1
by Animats 4y ago
Well, that makes sense. An ebike is really a light motorcycle, and needs similar safety systems. Harleys from the 1920s look like modern fat-tire ebikes.[1]
[1] https://www.hdforums.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/1920sHarleyPolice.jpg https://www.hdforums.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/1920sHar...
- rich_sasha 4y agoThat's true, and i suppose safety is good. Equally, I'm dismayed at people with no road awareness and, seemingly, concern for their own and others safety, bring given these "light motorcycles" and riding them as if they are bikes... On pavements, on roads down the wrong way, through red lights and parks. People aren't any smarter on purely mechanical bikes but there is a higher bar to being dangerous.
- rchaud 4y agoE-bikes are illegal in Toronto, yet they are everywhere because the police rarely enforce the rule.
- afontaine_ca 4y agoThis is so patently false it hurts to read. The city has an easy website explaining the rules[0], and the bike share system provides ebikes[1]. [0]: https://www.toronto.ca/services-payments/streets-parking-transportation/cycling-in-toronto/cycling-and-the-law/electric-bicycles-e-bikes-e-scooters/ https://www.toronto.ca/services-payments/streets-parking-tra... [1]: https://bikesharetoronto.com/e-bikes/ https://bikesharetoronto.com/e-bikes/
- rchaud 4y agoI meant e-scooters. I guess I conflated them all together.
- jylam 4y ago> An ebike is really a light motorcycle, I understand why you say that, but no no no. A motorcycle is 200kg+, capable of 150+km/h, and really needs proper training (Unlike as in the US, where it seems being able to steer it is sufficient to get your licence). E-Bikes should need a proper licence, very very different from motorcycles. Both are very dangerous, but in different ways. In Europe we have <50cc licences, where you still need to learn a dumded down version of the road code, and that's not even enough to my taste. (Almost lost my life, with proper motorcycle training, full equipement, in Paris, just getting to confident). Please do not take motorized 2 wheels lightly, an e-bike can kill you very easily.
- belorn 4y ago(Speaking about EU here...) E-bikes has a maximum speed is 25 km/h, and from the few studies done on the subject there doesn't seem to be any increase risk from e-bikes compared to regular bikes. One significant data point is that the average speed of e-bikes has been observed to be similar as of regular bikes with two exceptions: up hill has a higher speed than regular bikes and long flat stretches has more even speed. Most accidents involving bikes and e-bikes alike occur at very slow or even still speed, with the rider falling off and landing badly. There are two factors however that those studies have found. More disabled people use e-bikes, and when they end up in accidents they tend have worse injuries. E-bike users also tend to use their bikes more often and thus have more accidents with their bikes than people who ride their bikes less (looking at accidents per person rather than accident per mile). Going based on accident rates, any license that e-bikes should have should also apply to bikes, e-scooters and likely also people who jog in cities. There is simply no data that support a law treating e-bikes as different from regular bikes, as long they are limited to 25 km/h. A motorcycle weighting 200kg+ and operating over 150+km/h is however a very different beast which the accident rates also demonstrate, which is why they need a proper license to operate safely among other human being.
- rich_sasha 4y agoIn the former EU country of UK this is totally abused. I believe a vehicle can be capable of exceeding these limits, so long as they are enabled while on roads. So you can have a powerful ebike so long as there is a switch that makes it less powerful, and you switch it on while riding eg on a bike path. Lots of people seem to ride with it disabled though, confident that if the police catch them, they just push the switch and pretend it was on. This stems, AFAICT, from mobility scooters for the disabled. On pavements they have to be limited to 4mph for pedestrian safety, but on roads it is probably in fact safer to ride faster, which they do. Hence a flippable speed limiter.
- makeitdouble 4y agoFrom the pictures the system looks small enough it could be set on a standard cross-bike as well. If it really improves braking, that could be welcome addition to any situation where a bit more weight is acceptable.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoRegulating ebikes like motorcycles is a great way to make them just as popular for regular commuting as motorcycles (which is to say, basically not at all except for enthusiasts). This is exactly what many states have intentionally and successfully done to mopeds so it's not like you can say I'm speculating.
- antisthenes 4y agoWell, yes... Except for just the Harley motor weighing more than an average person and the e-bike combined. So no, not really.
- rngname22 4y agoE-bike is a whole category, from bikes that offer pedal assist only and don't see speeds that are really higher than normal bikes, just offering higher speed for lower human effort all the way up to e-bikes that are like you said just light motorcycle. But regulation and safety needs vary widely depending on category. This is an e-bike: https://ride1up.com/product/roadster-v2/ https://ride1up.com/product/roadster-v2/ So is this: https://www.eskuta.com/products/sx-250-series-iii-eapc-electric-bike https://www.eskuta.com/products/sx-250-series-iii-eapc-elect... (at least it's being marketed as one). Really, we just need more terms. But it'd be nice if we could keep the label e-bike for the...bikes. Not the light motos.
- grepfru_it 4y agoThere are definitely regulations for full-assist ebikes, which is why pedal-assist ebikes top out at 20mph and cannot go more than 5mph on its own power. Check with your local state laws