3 ms·
It looks like this newly submitted article is reasonably thoughtful and informed. The distinction between job categories vulnerable to globalization and those l
by tokenadult 15y ago
It looks like this newly submitted article is reasonably thoughtful and informed. The distinction between job categories vulnerable to globalization and those less vulnerable is interesting, and points out that some college-degree-requiring jobs may be increasingly outsourced.
But degree-seekers decide whether or not to get degrees at the individual level, and sometimes after already deciding on a career. I've not posted in some of the other recent threads about the supposed uselessness of college degrees, and I want to provide a different perspective on the issue. While reading about IQ testing research, specifically directed to the issue of IQ tests as qualifications for being hired for full-time employment, I saw the striking statement that at ALL levels of IQ, an engineer will enjoy better career prospects than a technician. In many business corporations and government agencies (perhaps there are some exceptions), the distinction between being hired as a "technician" and being hired as an "engineer" is mostly determined by the absence or presence of a college degree. The lifetime earnings difference (remember, this is for persons with the same IQ) between a technician and an engineer is more than enough to justify investing in getting a college degree in engineering.
I do not claim this generalizes to the difference between an "office assistant" and an "office manager" (which perhaps is also defined mostly by higher education credentials) but that would be an empirical issue to look at. If college study has signaling value in the job market, and perhaps also provides some practical training for being in one job category rather than another, whoever you are, however smart you are, you may be well advised to seek a college degree.
For the more college-skeptical view of Charles Murray, see "Down with the Four-Year College Degree!":
http://www.cato-unbound.org/2008/10/06/charles-murray/down-with-the-four-year-college-degree/ http://www.cato-unbound.org/2008/10/06/charles-murray/down-w...
- asolove 15y agoThe real question is whether this earnings difference is justified (the college degree adds enough value to the employee to put them on an entirely separate tier) or a "bubble" (perceived by hiring managers to be that important, but not actually). If the latter, many companies are making expensive mistakes by not hiring less-educated but intelligent workers. The costs of training would be far lower than the salary savings . My sense is that most employers today have no interest in serious training and career advancement for their employees. They hire technicians, engineers, and managers, rather than hiring technicians and letting them work their way to being engineers and managers. As a result, individual workers have far less space to grow within the company, loyalty is lower, the management has no personal experience of the day-to-day operations of the company.