2 ms·
> The Supreme Court is expected to rule soon on election related issues. The Supreme Court rules all the time on election related issues. > I wouldn’t be surp
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> The Supreme Court is expected to rule soon on election related issues.
The Supreme Court rules all the time on election related issues.
> I wouldn’t be surprised if they rule (correctly, based on the constitution) that every state can manage its own voting laws.
That's the status quo, except for certain element of various federal elections for which there is an explicit Congressional role.
What the pending case is about the independent state legislature theory, which is a legal theory that the State legislature, in deciding various election-related matters assigned to it by federal law and/or the US Constitution, is not bound by the State Constitution as interpreted by the State Supreme Court but instead has sole and unreviewable (so long as exercised within federal constraints) authority. This extends to things like redistricting; assignment of Presidential electors, including by retrospective nullification of a vote of the people for that purpose; setting process for Congressional elections; etc.
> What is also often overlooked is that each state is self-governing.
The ISL theory contradicts that idea, and essentially holds that the State Legislature, in conduct of federal elections, is an arm of the Federal government, outside of the mechanisms by which the people of the State have circumscribed the powers and exercises thereof by the State government.