7 ms·
That describes me and I've made that exact argument before. I'd ask that anyone who feels gross at the idea that the government should have the authority to man
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
That describes me and I've made that exact argument before. I'd ask that anyone who feels gross at the idea that the government should have the authority to mandate organ donation or blood and tissue donations to save a life or disallow backing out of these procedures to understand that this comes from the same place.
- hgomersall 4y agoNot really, any mandated organ donation is always going be from dead donors. If you know of any forced donations from live donors in a democratic state, I'd be interested to know.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThere isn't any, but if we take pro-life to its logical conclusion, there should be, at the very least from parents to children, and at least in cases where it doesn't lead to your death. Also, mandatory organ donation after death should be obvious table stakes for a pro-life person, if they were logically consistent.
- throwaway894345 4y agoI don't think this is true at all. Pregnancy ("creating a life that requires birth" since we're not debating "when does life begin" at this point in the thread) is a predictable consequence of (voluntary) sex. "Organ donation" is not a predictable consequence of sex. There's nothing inherent to the pro-life position that would require mandatory organ donation between parents and children or anyone else whether before or after death.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoTo jump a few steps ahead in the dialogue, I'll posit that simply the medical reality of our ability to perform organ donations, and the consequence of donations saving lives makes have-ing organs a sufficient condition for forced donation. Medical realities currently play a role in viability calculus so it is a perfectly valid analogy in that medical advances in organ donation being a possibility are equally valid.
- throwaway894345 4y agoRather than reiterating arguments, I'll just link people to the thread where you and I debated this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32142968 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32142968
- tsimionescu 4y agoI'm not sure what sex has to do with it. The pro-life position is that human life is so precious that preserving the human life of the fetus it is more important than any right the mother may have. There is no logical reason this argument would stop after birth - the mother (and presumably father as well) should maintain this obligation of preserving the life of their child by any means that don't require them to give up their own life. Being legally required to, say, donate blood for their child should be a no-brainer, if you bleieve that the preservation of your child's life should be a legal requirement that trumps any other right you may have (except your own right to life). Donating their organs to their child after death should also be an obvious legal requirement.
- throwaway894345 4y agoWell, that's not "THE pro-life position", it's an extreme example of a pro-life position (nut-picking, effectively). A more moderate pro-life position argues that consensual sex constitutes a waiver of the right to forego birth (except in cases where birth puts the mother's life at great risk--for some value of "great").
- tsimionescu 4y agoI think you'll find that this position is actually less common among pro-life people than the one I am describing. Exceptions for rape are rarely accepted by those who want to ban abortion entirely. Even less so among those who also oppose classes of contraceptives that immediately kill fertilized eggs, such as the Catholic Church. Exceptions for rape are much more common among those who also accept at-will termination of pregnancy up to some gestational age (e.g. at-will abortion up to 12 weeks, or up to 20 weeks in cases of rape). Edit to add: the vast majority of active pro-life campaigners are also opposed to sex education and free contraceptives, once more proving that the question of consensual unprotected sex is not in any way at the forefront of their ideology.
- throwaway894345 4y ago> I think you'll find that this position is actually less common among pro-life people than the one I am describing. Exceptions for rape are rarely accepted by those who want to ban abortion entirely. It seems like you're conflating "pro-life" and "people who want to ban abortion entirely". The pro-life position includes people who want to ban abortion in the general case even while allowing abortion for exceptional cases. > Exceptions for rape are much more common among those who also accept at-will termination of pregnancy up to some gestational age (e.g. at-will abortion up to 12 weeks, or up to 20 weeks in cases of rape). Agreed, but that doesn't refute pro-life people having rape exceptions (multiple groups can allow for rape exceptions). > the vast majority of active pro-life campaigners are also opposed to sex education and free contraceptives, once more proving that the question of consensual unprotected sex is not in any way at the forefront of their ideology Can you source this claim about the majority of pro-life campaigners (also, why does that seem indicative of pro-life people in general)? Also, even if it's accurate, I don't think it constitutes proof of much--in particular, they could hold that it's not the government's job to provide sex education or free contraception (I personally favor the government providing both of these, by the way). In any case, rather than arguing about ONE pro-life position, it seems like it would be better to acknowledge that there can be multiple specific positions within a movement. I'm certainly happy to concede that the pro-life movement includes many people with extreme positions, why can't we agree that it includes some more moderate positions as well?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoAnd that's really the point. The idea of forced organ donation is abhorrent. The same visceral reaction to the idea of forced organ donation extends to forced birth by way of bodily autonomy. No one, not even the government, should have more authority over your body than you.
- Domenic_S 4y ago> No one, not even the government, should have more authority over your body than you. The government already has rights over your bodily autonomy in many ways; just the right to incarcerate someone is controlling their body pretty dramatically. They regulate where your body can go, and to an extent what you can put into your body.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoYes I know. Doesn't it seem backwards though, to you, to make the argument that since the government has bodily authority over you in matters of imprisonment, that the government should also have authority over all aspects of your body? I'm over here trying to find a minimum amount of government authority over our bodies while others are basically saying, "let 'er rip!"
- Domenic_S 4y ago> Doesn't it seem backwards though, to you, to make the argument that since the government has bodily authority [...] the government should also have authority over all aspects of your body? Yes it does seem backwards. However, nobody here is making that argument. > I'm over here trying to find a minimum amount of government authority over our bodies Perhaps I'm just splitting hairs at this point, but "No one, not even the government, should have more authority over your body than you." is just such a broad brush that it's trivially refuted for certain scenarios. Maybe you're talking about medical authority? In any case the rule of law is very concerned with what happens when rights collide. It is possible -- perhaps common -- for individual's rights to be in conflict.
- throwaway894345 4y agoRespectfully, I think this analogy breaks down pretty fast. First of all, pregnancy is overwhelmingly a choice (of course there are exceptions)--it's not our hypothetical organ donor's fault that the hypothetical recipient needs an organ, but it is the parents' "fault" that an unborn child (recall we're not debating point-of-life at this point in the thread) needs to be born insofar as the child's life is the result of a risk the parents knowingly entered into (again, there are exceptions). Secondly, if our hypothetical organ donor backs out, our hypothetical recipient can get an organ from another donor--with few exceptions, there's no way to transfer a pregnancy (at least not outside of some extremely early window).
- kelseyfrog 4y agoSorry, i just don't see those as compelling arguments. The ability or non ability to alternatively source organs doesn't logically lead to a change in consequence. If anything, our inability to fully supply donation requests makes it a greater imparative to force organ donations to save lives e.g. organ shortages with life ending consequences are a present reality.
- throwaway894345 4y agoYou may not find them compelling, but your analogy fails to account for them nevertheless. > The ability or non ability to alternatively source organs doesn't logically lead to a change in consequence. But your analogy doesn't capture the responsibility of the donor for willfully creating the circumstances in which the recipient needs a kidney. Moreover, abortion is a procedure which actively kills a child which would likely otherwise live (without intervention); your analogy supposes a person who would naturally die without intervention. I'm sure we could contort your analogy to make it account for these things, but doing so would exhaust its utility.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIt easily captures compelling parents for organ donation using the same voluntary sex mechanism we're examining for forced births. Should parents be compelled to donate their organs to their children when not doing so would result in the recipient's death? At this point we've added mode of consequence to the analogy, but it seems you're introducing yet another constraint: active and passive intervention. I'm afraid I'll have to stop this here. It appears as though you will continue adding complexity until with the intention of forcing your result. Sorry, I don't debate with people acting in bad faith.
- scarmig 4y agoThe abortion relevant scenario would be something like: a person has a bad liver, and you agree to donate part of yours to save her life. Doctors remove the other person's liver, and you decide you don't want to donate part of yours anymore after the bad-but-functioning liver has been destroyed. There are no other possible donors, so the patient dies; if not for your initial agreement and subsequent backing out, the patient would be alive and could have found an alternative donor. My intuition is that most people would say the would-be donor is at least immoral in this scenario, and many would say should be subject to punishment. Curious where you fall on this.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoWhile I would hope that people earnestly enter into donation agreements, it would be a far greater violation to subject reconsiderate[1] donors to the horrors of forced donation. What would a forced donation look like? A person strapped to a bed and involuntarily sedated so their organ could be removed? Truly a hellish prospect. 1. for lack of a term for people who have changed their mind.