4 ms·
There are complicated moral issues at the "zygote" stage, as you mention. But the article clearly shows that the vast majority of the developed world--most of t
by rayiner 4y ago
There are complicated moral issues at the "zygote" stage, as you mention. But the article clearly shows that the vast majority of the developed world--most of those countries being far less religious than the U.S.--has achieved a moral consensus around the beginning of the second trimester, 12-14 weeks. (Incidentally, that's also around the point that much of the Islamic world believes that a baby gains a soul.)
The immediate political debate in the U.S. isn't about zygotes, but rather fetuses. The Dobbs case involved Mississippi's 15-week ban. Under Roe, states cannot ban elective abortions even at 15 weeks. At 15 weeks, the baby is a fetus, it has hands, feet, a face, and thumbs that it can suck. https://visitantlit.com/2012/11/19/pregnancy-week-15 https://visitantlit.com/2012/11/19/pregnancy-week-15.
Most of the developed world has deemed that a human life at that stage warrants a certain level of protection. Most of the developed world acknowledges that society has a right to intervene after that point. Even if they recognize exceptions to that rule, they simultaneously recognize that society has a right to protect those lives and a good reason is required to extinguish them. For example in liberal and non-religious Denmark, abortions after 12 weeks require unanimous approval of a special committee, with an appeals process that kicks the decision up to the Ministry of Justice: https://abortion-clinics.eu/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/Denmark_Pub_AbortionlegislationinEuropeIPPFEN_Feb2009.pdf https://abortion-clinics.eu/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/Denma...
- czzr 4y agoThis is true, but omits the fact that several states have or are contemplating even more extreme measures - such as 6 weeks or earlier, or total bans.
- zaphar 4y agoIn a sense, the refusal of most of American media to even give airtime to the discussion of when a fetus should gain rights/protections is why such extreme measures are being on the table. They painted this as a binary issue with no nuance or even discussion as regards the status of an unborn fetus so the reaction has been similarly binary with total lack of nuance.
- forgingahead 4y agoThis is unfortunately every issue in American discourse now though - the media obfuscates and confuses, instead of illuminating and hopefully educating. The media is the biggest cause of conflict in the US system now, because it's just become hyper-partisans shouting at each other and otherizing the other 50%.
- zaphar 4y agoI don't think anything disturbs me more than the effects of American public discourse. It's gotten impossible to have reasonable conversations on most things.
- t-3 4y agoDenmark isn't in any way or form "non-religious": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Denmark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Denmark
- lelandfe 4y ago> immediate political debate in the U.S. isn't about zygotes It's not just debate – it's already in law. Oklahoma HB4327[0], signed into law in May, outlaws abortions on "a human fetus or embryo in any stage of gestation from fertilization until birth." (It explicitly permits contraception, Plan B, etc) The National Right to Life Committee, the largest and most important anti-abortion group in the US, has created a model law that likewise classifies an "unborn child" to mean: > a living individual organism of the species homo sapiens throughout all stages of the unborn child’s development within a pregnant woman’s uterus from fertilization until birth [0] https://legiscan.com/OK/text/HB4327/2022 https://legiscan.com/OK/text/HB4327/2022 [1] https://www.nrlc.org/wp-content/uploads/NRLC-Post-Roe-Model-Abortion-Law-FINAL-1.pdf https://www.nrlc.org/wp-content/uploads/NRLC-Post-Roe-Model-...
- rayiner 4y agoOklahoma has less than 4 million people and a bit over 1% of the U.S. population. Roe applied a radical viability standard to the whole country.
- lelandfe 4y agoIs a state passing a law, and the most influential anti-abortion group in America proposing the same nationwide, not enough to count as "debate?" A very odd counter. It's worth pointing out that the GOP is beginning to follow the NRLC's playbook on this in Texas: https://www.npr.org/2022/07/15/1111383520/texas-abortion-laws-prosecutors https://www.npr.org/2022/07/15/1111383520/texas-abortion-law...
- rayiner 4y agoAnd there are six states without any term restrictions on abortion whatsoever, and prominent pro-abortion organizations are advocating those positions. But the fact remains that such extreme positions are unlikely to get nationwide traction. The central territory of the debate, and what the Dobbs case actually involved, is second trimester bans (12-15 weeks). I understand why folks want to focus on the radical position that some parties have advanced, and not the fact that the actual law in the US for the last 50 years was quite radical in the opposite direction.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIt should be noted that even the Bible only seems to recognize the importance of the being inside a pregnant woman after quickening, which is essentially when the mother can start to feel the motions of the fetus, so around 16-20 weeks. The notion that life begins at conception seems to be quite modern.
- throwaway_4ever 4y ago> The immediate political debate in the U.S. isn't about zygotes, but rather fetuses. No, it's already law that currently 10 states have bans on all abortions past 6 weeks, restricting women's control over their own body. But feel free to move to Texas where a 12 year old daughter could be raped and forced to carry a baby. Sounds like freedom to me. /s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_law_in_the_United_States_by_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_law_in_the_United_Sta...