3 ms·
I would submit that part of the problem is that nobody really has a clue how to use your hands. Are we going to have a thingy for every subtask that we want to
by jerf 15y ago
I would submit that part of the problem is that nobody really has a clue how to use your hands. Are we going to have a thingy for every subtask that we want to do? Are our computer workstations going to resemble carpenter workbenches? Probably not, if for no other reason that lack of cost effectiveness. We've got something like the Wiimote as pretty much the epitome of hand-based interaction, but it's not very precise for anything that isn't a game.
I don't mean this as a criticism of the post, I mean it as a stab at an explanation. It is a good point and I've been complaining about the primitive point and grunt interfaces[1] we've had for a while, but it's not even remotely clear where to go from here without (touchscreens are only an incremental point & grunt improvement over mice, you get a couple more gestures at the c another huge leap in processing power and hardware, at the minimum encompassing some sort of 3D glasses overlay for augmented reality or something.
[1]: The mouse is point & grunt. You get one point of focus and 1 - 5 buttons (including the mousewheel as up, down, and click). For as excited as some people have been about touchscreens, they're only a marginal improvement if they're even that; you still have only a couple kinds of "clicks", and you lose a lot on the precision of your pointing. Interfaces have papered that over by being designed for your even-more-amorphous-than-usual grunting, but when you look for it you realize that touchscreens are a huge step back on precision. They'll probably have a place in our lives for a long time but they are hardly the final answer to all problems, and trying to remove the touchscreen and read vague gestures directly has even bigger precision problems.
- jodrellblank 15y agoSimilarly, how would we use touch feedback? If physics and technology was no objection, would you want your phone to have more mass and inertia when you turn it when it has more email, and be less massive when you've read it? If you could simulate sloshing water in a glass, what general infomanipulation would map well to that feeling? What sort of mapping is there between hand manipulation and "next song" or "post Facebook status"?
- eavc 15y agoA relatively near-term possibility is the recognition of natural gestures. If it's too loud, I pat my hand in the air downward a few times or put a finger to my lips for mute. If it's too bright, I shield my eyes. If it's too hot, I jerk my hand back. If I want to see the time, I look at the clock, and it turns on. There's also plenty of room for big, dumb controls too. Hit the phone to make it stop ringing. Or squeeze it or shake it or tap it on your palm like a pack of cigarettes.