3 ms·
I think the correct solution is to buy hardware whose firmware is free software under your control so that you're safe from manufacturer-pushed malware. As lon
by kragen 4y ago
I think the correct solution is to buy hardware whose firmware is free software under your control so that you're safe from manufacturer-pushed malware. As long as people keep using the hardware, they can share firmware updates with each other. And that way your device gets better over time instead of worse.
If you're designing a speaker with a built-in amplifier, you can probably get better performance at lower cost and lower power consumption by designing a microcontroller into the amplifier circuitry. Once you do that, you have firmware, and then it's just a matter of whether users (or the manufacturer) can update the firmware or not.
- capableweb 4y ago> hardware whose firmware is free software I like the idea, but as someone who makes music, I'm having a hard time finding anything that is professional-grade and ships firmware that is free software. Brands I'm using now is Adams Audio, Novation, Mackie, Elektron, Korg, Novation and more, and I don't think a single one of them ships FOSS firmware. It would limit my options considerably, even though I think it would be better long-term.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, I didn't mean to suggest that "the correct solution" is actually feasible right now. We are in a really bad situation with respect to user freedom of software, as I predicted we would be in this essay I wrote late last millennium: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/kragen-software.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/kragen-software.html
- capableweb 4y ago> Yeah, I didn't mean to suggest that "the correct solution" is actually feasible right now Ah, I understand. I guess starting your comment with "I think the correct solution is" and not including the disclaimer of "you can't actually do this today" is prone to making people believing you could do something like that today :) No harm done though, thanks for explaining.
- kragen 4y agoThis is a political problem, not a technical one, so the solution is collective action, not individual action. 300 years ago you could reasonably have said, "The correct solution to the poverty of the Russian peasants is for them to move to the cities and start an industrial revolution," and you would have been right, but if as a serf you attempted this you would have in most cases been beaten and sent back to the feudal estate you came from, if not killed. It took a century and a half plagued with serf revolts and bloodshed before serfdom was abolished, and even today the Russian peasants are subject to conscription, arbitrary detention, and many limitations on their freedom.
- tpm 4y agoModules from Mutable Instruments do, though MI is now sadly (for the modular world) ending its business for personal reasons.
- School-Cotton 4y ago> I think the correct solution is to buy hardware whose firmware is free software under your control Does such audio hardware actually exist in the real world? If not, this is hardly a “solution”.
- dsr_ 4y agoCertainly. * Passive speakers: no microcontrollers at all. Prices from tiny to extravagant. * Class-D amplifier: no facility to update the firmware. Prices from small to extravagant. * USB DAC: no facility to update the firmware. Prices from tiny to extravagant. * Laptop running anything that outputs to USB Audio spec: pick your poison. At the low end, this could be a pair of JBL A130 (under $200/pair on sale), an Aiyama A07 amp ($80), a $10 Apple DAC, and $20 in wires. It's loud enough for a living room, not for an outdoor party. Substitute in Behringer B215 powered speakers for the JBL and Aiyama components, adding about $400 to the total bill, and you should have a pretty good outdoor small-concert system. You'll need power for all this. There are an infinite number of solutions in this space; the above two are just examples.