3 ms·
I have never used Gerrit, so I can't speak to it directly. My memory from folk who have worked on both seemed to prefer critique, but I am not sure if that's be
by rockwotj 4y ago
I have never used Gerrit, so I can't speak to it directly. My memory from folk who have worked on both seemed to prefer critique, but I am not sure if that's because of the tight integration with other tools like codesearch, linters, etc or something more fundamental to the review tool itself.
- surajrmal 4y agoGerrit UX has historically been subpar compared to critique, however it's seen a lot of investment in recent years afaict. A lot of the remaining benefits of critique are largely due to its tight integrations with other Google tools. Critique is fairly malleable so it's possible with enough effort to get a similar experience by integrating with your own tools, but it's definitely something that needs to be staffed to work that well.