You can always imagine situations in which any approach would be preferable to another, which is why they're terrible for determining the correct way to act. W

You can always imagine situations in which any approach would be preferable to another, which is why they're terrible for determining the correct way to act. What is more important is how society will act with said regulations/decisions, and then you'll have no choice but accept that the best way forward is the one that's hardest to abuse. The aggressive approach is extremely easy to abuse and there are currently no dangers associated to the abuser, which is why SWATing is on the rise.