3 ms·
The most recent Australian experience is that this demands more $ than you think, and invokes more engineering risks than you wanted, and in economic stress can
by ggm 4y ago
The most recent Australian experience is that this demands more $ than you think, and invokes more engineering risks than you wanted, and in economic stress can wind up almost there, but a million miles away.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_power_in_Australia#Geodynamics_Cooper_Basin_Demonstration_Plant,_South_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_power_in_Australia#...
It's really sad. It should work, and it had massive upsides. I don't think the investment was a waste, where I do think CCS for sequestration is generally a giant boondoggle by the oil and gas extraction industries.
There is a lot of emotion around fracking. Given its almost exclusively used to enhance well extraction, and against local farmers wishes, its hardly surprising. Water tables are complex, and people visualise them as something different: I was told by a geologist sleeving a drill through the water table is normal and common and there should be no necessary pollution of one by the other (deep fracking) but there's a lot of nervousness about it. They use heinously wierd mixtures to force the fracking.
A lot of power investment decisions are basically linear optimisation: there are umpteen competing tensions, financial, political, energy cost/benefit, pollution, distance to consumer, longterm future, royalty, capex, opex, it's not that unusual for good science to be drowned out by politics (for instance). Right now, my sense is that Wind and Solar are in the ascendent, and that the politics of looking at other forms of energy involve most of the non-tech, political, layer 9 aspects of energy planning. I truly believe other forms of energy are worth exploring, but not if they interfere with deployment of low-carbon wind and solar and battery, and are just being used as a battering ram to preserve oil/coal energy income streams.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoI feel like it's really common for people involved in energy extraction to tell the people living in a community "we promise it will all be fine". And then suddenly when things aren't fine, they'll pay the absolute legally enforced minimum (usually nothing) to those in the communities they've crippled. People are right to be afraid, giving money to a few well owners in exchange for your entire water table potentially getting destroyed is a bad deal
- ggm 4y agoYes. It's an exceptionally bad deal. Especially when you consider fugitive gas release from gas extraction is a huge, under-reported problem. All this does is contribute to wild, uncontained methane release. But fracking for heat, I think may still be worth arguing for, and discussing as risk issue. It's not unlike cancer treatments: anti cancer drugs are wildly toxic, and you would never, ever give them to a patient otherwise. None the less, until the newer anti-cancer vaccines came along, they were the gold standard for treatment: Arguing for testing demanded doctors justify giving people toxins. Was it worth it? Yes.