7 ms·
Fields Medal was never meant for ‘the greatest mathematical genius' (2018)
- cionx 4y agoBarany published his findings as a short article in Nature [1]. He also talked about the topic in an episode of the podcast “My Favorite Theorem” [2]. [1]: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-00513-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-00513-8 [2]: https://kpknudson.com/my-favorite-theorem/2020/11/12/episode-60-michael-barany https://kpknudson.com/my-favorite-theorem/2020/11/12/episode... (from 21:40 to 30:44).
- billfruit 4y agoAlso is there something of a pure-maths fixation with the fields medal? Did anyone win it for Wavelets( like Ingrid Daubechies for example) or compressed sensing?
- timoteostewart 4y agoIt's a pervasive misunderstanding. See, e.g., yesterday's ArsTechnica headline on an article about the Fields Medal: "How one institution keeps claiming math’s highest award: One institute has had 12 math faculty, and eight of them have won the Fields Medal." https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/07/how-one-institution-keeps-claiming-maths-highest-award/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/07/how-one-institution-...
- raincom 4y agoAfter Perelman’s fiasco, many universities have started offering professorships without putting people on tenure-track. For example, manjul bhargava and June huh are two examples. Also add Yitang Zhang, an adjunct lecturer became a tenured professor. Somehow, the American math tribe couldn’t offer a tenured position right away after his postdoc—-in fact, that’s what Grigori pereleman wanted.
- noisy_boy 4y ago> After Perelman’s fiasco I couldn't find anything on this - any links?
- texaslonghorn5 4y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/luismbat/status/1361127948401614848 https://mobile.twitter.com/luismbat/status/13611279484016148... Grabbed a relevant reference from Wikipedia: https://archive.ph/tL5oD https://archive.ph/tL5oD Perelman solved the Soul Conjecture. Then he wanted a tenured/research-only position, but Princeton only offered a tenure track job, so he declined. And then he took a (research-only) job elsewhere (in Russia), which gave him requisite time/space to prove the Poincare conjecture. So Princeton would have benefited from giving him tenure when he asked for it.
- mianos 4y agoI wonder if those people taught Google the idea of insisting famous candidates solve their pet leetcoder challenge before they can go another round of interviews? Perelman, when asked for his CV, "You have heard my lecture why would you need anymore information?" Then proceeds to leave.
- mhh__ 4y agoGoogle needs a million perelkids not one perelman
- chaoz_ 4y agoThanks for the link. I still do not understand why people call it "Fiasco" though. Princeton at least tried, pretty sure many other universities knew about the soul conjecture, but did not make any effort.
- noisy_boy 4y agoI think it meant "fiasco" for Princeton specifically and not in general - they had him ready to accept a immediately full-tenure position which they didn't offer and later he went on to solve the Poincaré Conjecture. Sure, one can say that they couldn't have known the future but considering the Soul Conjecture is described as an extraordinarily difficult problem that he solved in a short 4-page paper, they could have tried harder. Anyway, granted, hindsight is 20/20.
- boguscoder 4y agoNobel prize itself deviated quite a lot from original vision of worthy nominees. It’s pretty well covered in “Losing the Nobel Prize” book
- shusaku 4y agoIt almost seems inevitable. When a prize is new maybe you have the freedom to give it to young and relatively unknown mathematicians. But as the reputation and the coverage of the award grows, you end up leaning towards the more traditional pick.
- rob74 4y agoThe thing is, mathematics is nowadays almost the only science where someone can make a name for themselves at a young age, because they don't need as much funding (except to pay their own bills), research grants, associates to do grunt work etc. etc. So if the Fields Medal would really go to "the traditional pack", it would be especially unfair. Of course it's also unfair that many of the biologists, physicists etc. doing the grunt work for their higher-ups don't get recognized either until they manage to climb to the top, but such is life...
- hardware2win 4y agoWhat are the other sciences? I'd say CS
- throwaway5752 4y agoAs someone on the mathematics side, I had no idea this misperception existed. Why would the Fields Medal be capped to recipients under age 40, otherwise? It is idiotic to think that an award for "greatest mathematical genius" (which is a clumsy way of describing any prize) would just ignore accomplishments over a certain age, it is almost offensive. It has always been an award recognizing emerging talent, and it has always been entirely clear to anyone who paid attention to it. The Abel prize (https://abelprize.no/ https://abelprize.no/) and Wolf prize (https://wolffund.org.il/the-wolf-prize/ https://wolffund.org.il/the-wolf-prize/) exist to recognize general accomplishments in mathematics. A perfect example is Sir Andrew Wiles, who proved the Taniyama–Shimura and thus resolved Fermat's last theorem, who received Abel and Wolf prize. But he was 40 when he began presenting his proof and was too old to qualify by the time he fixed his initial issues with Iwasawa theory. He was recognized by the Fields committee with a special "IMU silver plaque", instead.
- rambojazz 4y ago40 seems incredibly old for an "emergent" talent in Maths
- sillysaurusx 4y agoYou’ve godda understand, most of us don’t pay attention to medals. The Fields Medal is prestigious, and prestige breeds misconceptions. I’ve been vaguely interested in mathematics for decades and never knew the Fields Medal was anything but a recognition of the greatest mathematical achievement. Thanks for the anecdote about Wiles. I had no idea mathematics didn’t have some way of properly recognizing achievements from the ancients over 40. So much for respect for one’s elders.
- ggm 4y agoPopular culture mis-informs a lot of things. Look at how people understand 'Turing Test' -benedict cumberbatch did an awesome job of being AT. Does that mean everyone understands the turing test? No. So blame Russell Crowe for mis-understanding of the fields medal.
- xcambar 4y agoI am very surprised at the article as the Fields medal has always been promoted as such: encouraging promising young mathematical talents. I am even more surprised that,of all places, here on HN I get to be the first to comment that. How did the general audience get such a poor perception of the medal? Is it scientific communication gone wrong?
- sweezyjeezy 4y agoIt's hard to argue that the spirit of the competition has not changed since it started. Roth would not have won the fields medal the way he did these days, he pretty much won it for a single paper.
- was_a_dev 4y ago> the Fields Medal, is often described as the Nobel Prize for math(s). This is the problem
- downboots 4y agoIs there a higher rank award in math?
- was_a_dev 4y agoIt isn't about the rank in this case - it is about the difference in how both operate. Equating the two, because of their similar prestige, misleads those to thinking the Fields Medal is awarded under the same merit of the Nobel Prize.
- downboots 4y agoSurprisingly common given the multitude listed here: List of prizes known as Nobel of X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prizes_known_as_the_Nobel_or_the_highest_honors_of_a_field https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prizes_known_as_the_No...
- js8 4y agoThe problem with "promise" is that it is ageist and hard to measure. And to be honest, being "promising" can actually put more psychological pressure on the recipient. I think in general societies should strive to have equal and realistic opportunities across the board rather than try to fix it with a prize for selected young men.
- throwaway5752 4y agoTo be fair, it's not awarded on "promise". It is awarded based on contribution, the Fields medal is phenomenally prestigious in that respect. It is just restricted to recipients under age 40, among other things.
- tomcam 4y agoDelightfully relevant HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35079 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35079
- auggierose 4y agoThank you for pointing out this nugget!
- sweezyjeezy 4y agoIt's just prizes guys. Everyone in mathematics knows that 'win a Fields medal' is not a realistic goal unless you're like Terry Tao or Peter Scholze - you need a lot of luck as well as talent. There are other math prizes available that try to fill the gap with the Nobel prize - most notably the Abel prize, and the Wolf prize, these should possibly supplant the Fields medal (or maybe the Fields medal should just lose its age restriction). There are also other prizes available for young 'promising' mathematicians, for example the SASTRA Ramanujan prize in Number theory / combinatorics, or Clay research fellowships. I don't know if it makes sense to move the Fields medal closer to this now, given how it's outgrown its original prestige.
- throwaway5752 4y ago"maybe the Fields medal should just lose its age restriction" I agree completely. The IMU should take a page from other academies and have prizes for lifetime accomplishments, substantial contributions during a year or some other period, and then maybe a more minor prize for new and upcoming mathematicians. The restriction that the Fields can only be awarded to a person once is equally arbitrary and needing to change. It particularly bothers me how the age 40 restriction puts women mathematicians who would like to have children at a disadvantage.
- DerekL 4y agoTitle needs (2018).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- atdrummond 4y agoIt’s worth noting that the Bohr mentioned in the article is Niels’ brother, so he certainly would understand the ramifications of the award using similar qualification standards as the Nobel Prize. He was also, on an unrelated note, a silver medalist in the Olympics of 1908 as a soccer player.
- P-NP 4y agoA good way of ending this article: "I was fascinated by the way in which the personal agendas of committee members were clothed in seemingly reasonable attempts to place restrictions on the prize," says Christopher Hollings, a historian of mathematics at the University of Oxford in the United Kingdom, who attended Barany's talk. "It is a nice and interesting reminder that mathematicians are people, too."
- daniel-cussen 4y agoThe 0th tier is a prize named after you.
- sweezyjeezy 4y agoGrothendieck is an interesting example of how quickly this changed [1]. If you have not heard of him, he is one of the two or three most important mathematicians of the 20th century, but his work was wildly abstract, so tends to be less well known. He was passed over for the Fields medal in 1958 at age 30 because his advisor was on the committee, and wanted more of his work to be published to prove it wasn't favouritism. Then in 1962, he was deemed to be _too_ established for the medal, no longer an up-and-coming star. And then in 1966, the attitude of the committee changed to "the Nobel of math" and he won it! [1] https://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/14250/grothendieck-and-fields-medal-1962 https://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/14250/grothendieck-a...
- ravi-delia 4y agoBut that "change" didn't persist. Another explanation is just that hewas an emerging talent, then he seemed to have done the thing mathematicians often do where he settled down to flesh out the brilliant ideas he'd already had, but then it became clear he was still producing innovative output!
- sweezyjeezy 4y agoSorry not sure I understand you post, but if I follow: - you're claiming that the Fields medal did not switch over in 1966 - I think many would disagree, that's generally cited as the year the change happened. - you're claiming that a good explanation why Grothendieck didn't win in 1962 is because he was just fleshing things out? I think that is also incorrect - he introduced etale cohomology in 1960 - from 58-66 Grothendieck's output was pretty ridiculous.