2 ms·
I don't get your point. You don't get to pick the language other people speak. "Fuck" is a word. It has meaning and connotation, just like other words. To m
by ajross 15y ago
I don't get your point. You don't get to pick the language other people speak. "Fuck" is a word. It has meaning and connotation, just like other words. To most people, it does not mean "very" or "awesome", and if it did you'd see them use it that way.
Surely you choose your other words carefully, right? And you do them based on the definition that all of us English-speakers have agreed upon, right? Why should fuck be any different?
Basically, get your fucking attitude out of my language. I'll interpret the words the way I want to, based on my experience with other English-speakers; it's not my fault if you're an asshole about it.
I suspect you really wanted to post a diatribe about why profantiy shouldn't exist. If so, you need to go a whole lot deeper than "get off your high horse".
- pbiggar 15y ago"You don't get to pick the language other people speak. " And yet that's exactly what you've done, when you've decided the meaning of another person's speech. You say that "it has a meaning and a connotation", but both the connotation and meaning depend on context and speaker (and also, as you've noted, on listener). It's simplistic to think that the only meaning of words is your interpretation. In a presentation, speaker and audience may interpret what the speaker said in different ways. And your notion that "all of us English-speakers have agreed upon is laughable" - I would challenge you to visit a culture outside your own. Hell, just watch The Wire to see how wrong this idea is. I'm not sure whether you noticed that "I'll interpret the words the way I want to" directly contradicts "You don't get to pick the language other people speak". I wouldn't say that profanity shouldn't exist, merely that "fuck" in its modern usage is not profane. If you disagree, I'd challenge you to find a profane translation of "get your fucking attitude out of my language". It conveys aggression, but it's hardly profane.