2 ms·
> it's a really weird twist to ask Google to effectively intentionally and automatically detect when someone might be breaking a specific law, and then specific
by pessimizer 4y ago
> it's a really weird twist to ask Google to effectively intentionally and automatically detect when someone might be breaking a specific law, and then specifically delete just the data that they think could be evidence of law-breaking so that law enforcement can't get the evidence.
To leave with only this interpretation of the article involves ignoring both the headline and the four suggestions that it argues for, which don't concentrate on abortion, but clearly call for rules that would protect women who have abortions to also be applied generally, to 1) all searches and history (possibly qualified with "health-related" exclusions by default in the spirit of HIPAA), 2) all location data, 3) 'incognito mode' in general, and 4) all chat and private messaging.
Abortion is what motivates him (or at least what he decided to hang the article from), but that's clearly one of the few issues that motivates wealthy elites because it has the potential to affect them or someone they love. Any truthful angle that gets anybody riled up against ubiquitous surveillance is good.
- Closi 4y agoIt actually argues for the scope of data deletion to be data specifically around sexual reproductive health, for the explicit purpose of deleting evidence of abortions for Roe vs Wade. I agree that the other points are more broad - but I also think that these issues have to be looked at via more than a single lens. Just using the lens of 'abortion' for these data privacy issues leads to a much more limited scope of discussion than is ideal.