3 ms·
> Similar to how some indigenous people in the Arctic have special permission to hunt whales, or how some Native Americans may possess eagle feathers. > Plus,
by josephcsible 4y ago
> Similar to how some indigenous people in the Arctic have special permission to hunt whales, or how some Native Americans may possess eagle feathers.
> Plus, we've seen how Neo-Druids have right to worship at Stonehenge, and that's a relatively new cultural tradition.
Again, all of those special permissions are fine since they can be granted without making it illegal for the rest of us to do things that were previously legal. A better comparison would be if the neo-Druids were given exclusive right to visit Stonehenge.
- eesmith 4y agoWhat are you talking about? The new Hawaii law doesn't grant practitioners of Native Hawaiian cultural traditions the exclusive right to visit or use Maunakea. They now have a seat at the table, rather than having decisions be the exclusive right of the University of Hawaii. Anyone used to be able to whale. Now it's illegal in the US except for Alaska Natives and the Makah of Washington State.
- josephcsible 4y agoShould the previous owner of your house get a seat at the table to decide what home improvement projects you now are and aren't allowed to do?
- eesmith 4y agoYour question is completely irrelevant. The University of Hawaii does not own the Mauna Kea Science Reserve. The owner is the State of Hawaii, who leased it to UH in 1968. The owner of a piece of land can generally decide to switch to another steward, which is what happened here. So far every issue you've raised seems to at odds with established legal precedent and common practice, and some drastically misunderstand history or, if true, would totally destroy the remaining Native American treaty rights. To be clear, I'm pretty ignorant about these topics as well. But it's not hard to research, which is what I did for my answers.