5 ms·
How silly: using last century's centralised, radio-based, publisher-controlled popularity index to measure anything after the widespread adoption of the interne
by jeroenhd 4y ago
How silly: using last century's centralised, radio-based, publisher-controlled popularity index to measure anything after the widespread adoption of the internet. Nobody cares about the top 100 anymore because there are too many possible source to run into any songs that'll get listened to enough to form a generic top 100.
Music has both specialised and generified over the years. The "pop" numbers are all the same, as they have been for the last 70 or 80 years now. Pop music isn't produced out of a desire to make art, it's produced to sell as many copies to as many people in as many countries as possible. Engineered lyrics are exchanged between agencies and used and reused until an artist makes a breakthrough. It's brute forcing culture to make a profit.
That's not a recent thing either. Listen to older songs and you'll find that a lot of it is safe, generic, uninteresting stuff, even from the big bands. We've filtered down about 100 years of music to the stuff that's considered good, but back in the day there was a lot of crap that was in the top of the charts for a single year and then disappeared.
Today, we have a choice. For pennies we can listen to any type of music by bands we've never heard of all day long. Good luck finding a Mongolian throat singing metal band in 1980 if that's the music you're interested in. Good luck finding anything made by someone who's in it for the art if you're in a small town with a small record shop before the internet came along.
The top 100 is no longer centralised by publishers advertising to radio stations. They're still trying, desperately even, to keep this business model going, but by these measurements, it's just not working. You can say that "people don't know how to make music anymore" but you'll have to back this up with actual statistics, not some useless measurement of corporately engineered preferences. Count the total amount of songs you can get your hands on instead. I wouldn't be surprised to find that more music gets added to Spotify in a month than got made available in an 80s record store over an entire year!
And you know what? I don't see the problem with liking older music. We've got almost a century of crisply recorded music available to us right now. You can find enough music to develop and expand your musical preference for a lifetime even if no new music gets published ever again. People will always make music and these days that involves more remixing and more derived work, not because we don't know how to do it, but because we have the tools available to us.