5 ms·
I feel this sort of black-and-white thinking about morality is responsible for a lot of problems. Short of moving into the desert and becoming some sort of Hesy
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
I feel this sort of black-and-white thinking about morality is responsible for a lot of problems. Short of moving into the desert and becoming some sort of Hesychastic hermit, it's difficult, near impossible to lead a life where you do no evil.
The conclusion many draw from that is not to even bother trying. I think the better conclusion is to be forgiving of the failings of others, because they too struggle with this. Maybe the point isn't to be perfect, but to reach for what's good.
- Epa095 4y agoPerfect is the enemy of good!
- chiefalchemist 4y agoBlack and white? Or is the publisher + author being a hypocrite? Feels like the latter. "Do as I say, not as I do" is rarely forgivable. One or two lingering trackers? Maybe. But that's not the case here.
- lolinder 4y agoOP's point is that we're all hypocrites to some degree. Expecting someone to be doing everything right before they can comment on how we can all improve leaves us waiting for deity to resolve our problems.
- alex_sf 4y agoI don't think it's ever fair to expect someone to do everything right, but if you want to pontificate on a specific issue, you should act in congruence with that.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoYes we are. Agreed. But in this case the publisher + author are on the wrong side of the grey area. The number of trackers is not an "oops".
- tannhaeuser 4y agoI don't think writing a piece about privacy and then including dozens of trackers is honest and helping the case at all; "evil publisher" isn't an excuse. Can't have your cake and eat it, too.
- haswell 4y agoThis assumes the author has any control over this. On a web dominated by tracking, the harsh reality is that the avenues capable of reaching the widest audiences are going to bring with them some…baggage. To conclude that this is dishonest is missing the forest through the trees. Since tracking is the dominant reality, one of the best things a smart consumer can do is use tools that help counteract it. An article like this is using the medium available to help people similarly unable to change that medium navigate it a bit more safely. > Can't have your cake and eat it, too. What is the cake here? What double standard does the author benefit from if his writing encourages more people to switch to a browser that is more resistant to the tracking people are accusing the author of (endorsing? It’s not clear what the accusation actually is). Let’s examine an alternative: The author tries to convince the publisher to forego the apparatus that currently drives their business model or they’ll threaten to publish elsewhere. The publisher calls this bluff, and the author self-publishes instead. Fewer people read the article, fewer people switch to Firefox, and fewer people gain a modicum of protection from tracking. What about this outcome is better? If you gatekeep the act of publishing privacy awareness content in this way, the only thing that happens is fewer people become aware. The only thing that can weaken tracking (aside from regulation) is making it less effective. This mindset that only the pure/virtuous/perfect implementation is acceptable, and anything else is somehow unacceptable seems like a really good way to make no progress at all. Refusing to acknowledge the situation we’re in is just denial.
- wnevets 4y agoReminds of "You say you want to improve society and yet you live in one, how interesting"
- alex_sf 4y agoI still don't understand why that's a bad argument. In context, it's generally used to oppose hard leftist ideas (Marxism, etc). It's rarely a criticism leveled at reasonable reform or change; more when it nears outright revolution. In that case, it's not an unreasonable criticism.
- js8 4y agoIt's a bad argument, because validity of a critique is not predicated on critic's life choice. It's like arguing that you cannot critique a movie because you have never made one.
- alex_sf 4y agoIt's not a critique of the idea alone, it's forcing it into context. If we take a common example of how I've seen this play out: A: iPhones and Apple are evil because they require child slavery. B: But.. you own an iPhone? A: Oh so I'm just supposed to go live in the woods? I don't think B supports child slavery. B is pointing out that even people espousing this idea participate in the system because the alternative (not owning the iPhone) results in a worse outcome.
- js8 4y ago> It's not a critique of the idea alone, it's forcing it into context. Exactly. But switching to individual context around societal question is the problematic argument here. Properly contextualizing means to use individual cases to explain impact, but that is not done here. Society is formed by many individuals, and it doesn't necessarily matters what most of them do to address a particular problem. We have division of responsibility.
- virgildotcodes 4y ago
- zelphirkalt 4y agoMeh, it's quite easy to set up a website without third party (or first party) trackers. Even some github.io kind of website is better than a website with loads of tracker spam on it. It is not about black and white thinking, it is about putting in minimal effort and sticking to ones principles. Maybe it also involves greed for viewership, "wanting to make it big" with some article, who knows. There is not much preventing people from setting up a blog by themselves or ask someone else to help them publish in an ethical way, at least in many countries. I guess at least some positive outcome can be concluded: People, who read on those websites might learn a thing or two.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoWell it's a trade-off. Let's hypothetically say you have an important message that could save the world or something, but scream as loud as you can, you can't make everyone hear about it. You realize the only way to reach people is to do compromise with your principles, like publishing it on a major website that doesn't align with your values; which is the lesser evil, not spreading your message, or spreading it using those corrupt channels? I don't think there's an easy answer to this. It's easy to focus too much on not doing evil that you miss the opportunity cost of doing good.