4 ms·
> It's sad that despite all the warnings, people are so myopic and apathetic that it takes something this big and obvious to make them react. The problem is, t
by mschuster91 4y ago
> It's sad that despite all the warnings, people are so myopic and apathetic that it takes something this big and obvious to make them react.
The problem is, the very same data that anti-abortion fundamentalists or the police in the pointless "war on drugs" use against the population are what makes many services possible or usable in the first place.
A real-time traffic map only works with a large number of devices transmitting location and movement data that are then evaluated to detect a traffic jam. An app to help fertility or contraception only works with people entering very detailed data about their periods. Cell phones only work by having the phone register at each cell during roaming around.
Boycotting Google or deleting your period app is a stopgap solution - the real fix is we all need to get the right to privacy enshrined in our Constitutions, Basic Laws (the German equivalent) and international treaties, in a way that matches the reality that our phones and computers are direct extensions of our minds. We don't allow police to use brain reading (=polygraphs) as evidence in court, so tell me, why the fuck should we allow police to use digital representations of our brains?
Oh, and we all have to literally fight for the separation of church and state that basically all Western nations have in their constitutions to be actual reality. Fuck churches, fuck religion - the immense amount of influence both have on politics is completely unhealthy.
- ekianjo 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 4y agoEveryone should be free to believe in whatever the fuck they want. All I want is churches or any other form of religion completely banned from political consideration.
- trelane 4y ago> Everyone should be free to believe in whatever the fuck they want > All I want is churches or any other form of religion completely banned from political consideration. That's rather an astounding amount of irony right there.
- ekianjo 4y ago> All I want is churches or any other form of religion completely banned from political consideration. So you want things to go your way. That's not really how a republic, or even a democracy, actually works.
- mschuster91 4y agoThe US Constitution, the German Grundgesetz or the French Fourth Republic's Constitution all prescribe some sort of laicism - even the Turkish Constitution does so, following Atatürk's work many decades ago. It's time for societies to actually follow their principles and constitutions and get religion out of the way in politics - but most certainly not to roll back centuries of progress in ridding the world of religion. Erdogan's Turkey is rapidly devolving into a horrible mixture of nationalism and radical Islamism in order to secure Erdogan's grab on power, and the US is on its best way to follow suit, with fanatic Evangelicals banded together with neo-Nazis and generic anti-semites having taken power in the GOP.
- candiodari 4y agoBut as this current crisis clearly shows, the problem is not privacy invasion by FANGs. The problem is government privacy invasion, everywhere. And there, sorry to say, Google is not the problem. Perhaps some changes to their policies is warranted, but a total turnaround? Why? Hospitals and doctor's effectively report on women's periods, contraceptives and pregnancies when women visit. This is not optional, this is important for correct diagnosis and care for women, as well as for emergency care for women when necessary (many drugs and life-saving treatments, including emergency ones, MUST NOT be used during pregnancies, not because religion, but because they would harm the baby, or mother, or both). And unlike Google searches, Facebook chats or Amazon orders, medical provided information about periods has actually been used to convict women getting abortions. Something similar goes for social workers providing women with feminine hygiene products. The first thing we need is for police to stay away from medical records, and to go back to outlawing doctors, and any medical and social services (esp. mental care of any kind) giving any information to the police. But that would this information is inaccessible to law enforcement and the next time some teenager disappears for a week we'd need to show backbone ... The next divorce proceedings we need to show backbone, and WHATEVER mental health history any of the partners have needs to stay out of it. We need to make police, justice, some medical procedures and social work harder, and accept the costs that will come with that.
- mschuster91 4y ago> But as this current crisis clearly shows, the problem is not privacy invasion by FANGs. The problem is government privacy invasion, everywhere. And there, sorry to say, Google is not the problem. I literally said that boycotting Google and period apps is a stopgap solution and the real fix is to get rights to privacy enshrined in constitutions?
- briHass 4y agoJust to note that separating medical records from government's prying eyes would also include (lack of) vaccination status and would neuter most 'red flag' laws that restrict gun access based on mental health.
- 4y ago