8 ms·
How about a Genius Basic Income?
- hourago 4y agoWhat about not and just make life better for everyone? > In a sane world, Hairer would long ago have been given a healthy grant or a generous basic income, as well as a majestic set of lodgings wherever he so desired. Is this comedy?
- xwdv 4y agoThe world has limited resources, be realistic. Prioritization makes sense.
- birdyrooster 4y agoThe resources are limited because of undemocratic uses, largely thanks to wealth inequality (aka prioritization).
- RC_ITR 4y agoSure. And heuristically, society doesn’t prioritize geniuses. So I guess we are just all realistically sad, huh?
- quickthrower2 4y agoAnd, the point of writing is to spread ideas and change people's minds. Lobbying for the future state of what people think, effectively. There is also a difference between something being absurd and something we are just not used to yet.
- sinenomine 4y agoWhy doesn't society prioritize geniuses though? And does society really have a say in this decision process? Because it is pretty obvious that the ones deciding society-wide investment priorities are, for a lack of better word, the elites. As fellow HNer noticed in today's thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32120063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32120063 elites are very much used to having precise control over their environment, and known&unknown unknowns irritate them. From this POV natural geniuses are just such an instance of a hard to control variable, and so it's obvious that prioritization of geniuses would pose a problem to the elites. Who knows when a popular genius will decide to amass the political power and change the power balance? It seems that the current packaging of the brightest into the ivory tower of the academia is a compromise, where one side gets a certain amount of income and freedom, in return for giving away broader ambition. And at least to me, this is disappointing.
- xwdv 4y agoWe live in an anti-intellectual society. I doubt geniuses will ever be given the proper resources they deserve to make powerful contributions in this world. Seems like beautiful people are the only real priority in this world. People will bend over backwards to just give you things if you are attractive, especially if you are female as well
- hourago 4y agoTo prioritize people with mental health issues, disabilities, people excluded from society, etc. makes everybody better off. That seems the best investment. I'm sure that there are a lot of smart engineers here and they are doing fine. It's like giving free stylist to the most beautiful people, it seems a waste. It also seems a way of gatekeeping universal income.
- f17 4y ago[dead]
- eyelidlessness 4y agoPrioritization does make sense. The overhead of selecting who benefits deprioritizes the beneficiaries and those who are selected out.
- braingenious 4y ago>Professor Martin Hairer evidencing the correlation between head size and IQ. It would be insane if this wasn’t parody.
- sinenomine 4y agoIt's a joke, but the correlation is there, measured and replicated more than once.
- paulpauper 4y agoresearch in the US stopped because it was deemed politically incorrect but there is some correlation.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoResearch in the US is slow because there is no money to be made from knowing how much head size affects intelligence and because we know that education, which can be monetized, has far greater effect anyway. Your political correctness bogeyman is not the source of the world's ills.
- sinenomine 4y ago> because we know that education, which can be monetized, has far greater effect anyway Does it, though? No matter how hard scientists try (and do they try...), they cannot prove that education causally drives increase in fluid intelligence (g). At best it's crystallized intelligence, which is not the same. The research paints a different reality: education is about sorting, networking and acquiring crystallized knowledge. If one really seeks to find a way to raise g, one has to search elsewhere.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe rapid increase of Korean IQs demonstrates this very clearly. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235327743_The_Flynn_effect_in_Korea_Large_gains https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235327743_The_Flynn...
- sinenomine 4y agoThis could work, realistically, as a scheme to incentivize the geniuses to work on problems that matter. One incentive presented here is providing them with basic income to achieve their full potential. This question is very deep and has wide implications. One thing is sure: without harnessing the natural talent of the human genius qualitative progress is impossible.
- ksec 4y agoI think parent is arguing that everyone should be better off and everyone should get equal treatment. And may even be implying resources should be distributed equally.... To put it in mildly simple term, you are likely not in the same political spectrum as parent.
- braingenious 4y agoThey’re both suggesting that the government use public money to subsidize people’s daily lives. The main difference is one person is advocating for the government to administer intelligence tests and collect data around that. What’s the big political difference?
- ksec 4y agoOne is suggesting everyone should be treated equally, and not specially "genius", what ever that definition might be. The other is suggesting there are people with higher potential where this may be worth the effort.
- braingenious 4y agoOK. I still don’t get how “Give everybody free money” and “Give a subset of ‘worthy’ people as determined by a government agency free money” are that different. They’re both kind of bog standard socialist/communist ideas, just one has the self-dealing and nepotistic downsides to these ideologies explicitly baked into it by design. Edit: It’s kind of like arguing “feeding everybody is communism! Feeding everybody that is approved as officially My Buddies is Good Capitalism!” We’re discussing two different scenarios in which the government collects taxes and distributes that money to people without them being employed in any way.
- civilized 4y ago> What about not and just make life better for everyone? Well, that would cost thousands to millions of times more. I know that's a gauche point to make in contemporary America, where we don't have any concept of the difference between a program costing a million dollars and a quadrillion dollars, but I think it might be relevant here?
- paulpauper 4y agoPoe's Law strikes again
- paulpauper 4y agoget a job at a hedge fund for a few years, and then retire and have enough $ to do math and buy a home plenty of hedge funds would love to have a field's medalist
- andrepd 4y agoYes, that's kind of the point isn't it. It's a sad reality that the world's brightest minds have to help people with capital earn more capital (or go to some big tech company design the latest dystopian surveillance algorithm or whatever), or refuse and stay destitute.
- paulpauper 4y ago>help people with capital earn more capital Isn't that what a job is? Unless I am missing something.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoThose ten years would replace the ten years early in your STEM career which comprises your most impactful work.
- paulpauper 4y agoI agree. how much money should it be. 100k/year that should be enough for most areas or only expensive areas. but would this be for all math or physics degrees or just by IQ?
- quickthrower2 4y agoIt is quite a narrow discussion, all focused around this notion of letting them live anywhere. But to me it is simple. The genius probably doesn't want to live in London per-se. They want to mingle with other geniuses. So they want to be near the best universities so they are contunially interacting with the best when they want to. But also having private spaces to think. Really they just need a decent serviced appartment on university grounds, or in housing nearby. Which is something the government will probably already own or could build.
- dietrichepp 4y agoRecommended reading: Cyteen by CJ Cherryh. The geniuses in this universe are called “specials” and enjoy special rights. I still think that sci-fi novels are the best material covering the ethics of science.
- crikeyjoe 4y ago
- jrm4 4y agoI know it ends up not enough like this ideal in practice, but odd he never seems to mention "tenure."
- paulpauper 4y agothe problem with tenure is: it requires a spot be open, very competitive, requires a lot of published research, may require having to move, may have teaching obligations
- jrm4 4y agoSure, you're just getting started, I can think of many more problems. I just kind of think it speaks to how little the author has thought about the problem? As in, "you're really not describing a remotely new idea, and consequently have clearly also not thought about the drawbacks, either."
- JoeyBananas 4y agoIf you're such a genius why aren't you rich?
- metadat 4y agoWhy does this comment pop up so often on HN? Really disappointing.
- sinenomine 4y agoSome notable billionaires are in fact geniuses: https://pumpkinperson.com/2016/02/11/the-incredible-correlation-between-iq-income/ https://pumpkinperson.com/2016/02/11/the-incredible-correlat...
- danans 4y agoWhat's far better are things like the GI Bill, which turned WWII soldiers who (based on their high-school performance) would have been laborers into NASA engineers [1]. And it's still doing that. My anecdote: a relative who did poorly in primary school, but in the last 5 years has gone from enlisted service people to college educated engineer on the GI Bill. Genius grants are great (the MacArthur Fellowship funded the deciphering of the Maya Writing system [2]), but should be handled by private philanthropy, which has plenty of money these days to support the 140 IQ+ talent. 1. https://www.legion.org/magazine/242265/gi-bill-outer-space https://www.legion.org/magazine/242265/gi-bill-outer-space 2. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/mayacode/about.html https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/mayacode/about.html
- stn8188 4y agoI can't speak highly enough of the GI Bill providing this little bit of extra resource to those motivated enough to use it. Like the gentleman in the article you linked, I was applying for electrician jobs as my enlistment neared an end. The fact that the Post 9/11 GI Bill covered tuition plus enough allowance that my wife and I could pay rent means I'm now enjoying a career in engineering and passing that love of learning on to my children. Truly a Godsend in my opinion.
- mandmandam 4y agoDo the people on the receiving end of America's military factor into these effusions?
- batch12 4y agoYes. My education benefits all of humanity.
- mandmandam 4y agoThat must be fantastic news to the millions dead and tens of millions displaced by our fun ventures in the Middle East, the democracies destroyed in South America, and the countless millions suffering from proxy wars fueled with US arms.
- steanne 4y ago> having to compute demeaning mortgage rates if it's demeaning for him, it's demeaning for everyone.
- spacemanmatt 4y agoIntelligence is a poor social construct on which to build social policy. We already know how to do better than that.
- mandmandam 4y agoHa, as if people in America don't hate the intelligent enough already. Forget it! The tech is there for basic income for all. The resources are there. They've been there for a long time. What's holding us back is that the powerful LIKE US SCRAPING BY. Billionaires pay millionaires to convince the dumbest of us not to help people too much. "We are not going to be able to operate our Spaceship Earth successfully nor for much longer unless we see it as a whole spaceship and our fate as common. It has to be everybody or nobody." - Bucky Fuller "This crippling of individuals I consider the worst evil of capitalism. Our whole educational system suffers from this evil. An exaggerated competitive attitude is inculcated into the student, who is trained to worship acquisitive success as a preparation for his future career." - Einstein Buckminster Fuller was a certified genius. So was Einstein. MLK, James Connolly, Helen Keller, Bertrand Russell, and many others said similar things - not that you'd hear much about that side of them in school. They supported the idea that we ought to make things better for HUMANS, for the planet, for all beings. To try and sum up - I don't think any genius worth the title would want to be part of an elite class, while their so-called less worthy brethren can't afford school lunches, or are getting bombed by genius-made weapons. Basic income - yes, let's do it. Basic income only for people who will feed the beast - fuck off.
- sinenomine 4y agoIt shouldn't be exclusively about the America. In Europe we don't have this level of anti-intellectualism, but still aren't doing our best at harnessing our top talent.
- mandmandam 4y agoAll true. I single out America because we are hurting the world the most (according to most global opinion since 2001), and because we have the most severe anti-intellectual streak (for like the last hundred years at least). Still, even in Europe, the idea of separating potential "cream" from mere worker drones ought to make the hair rise on the back of your neck. Again - basic income is very cool. Supporting talent is very cool. But let's not pretend that there wouldn't be huge resentment from something like the OP's proposal, everywhere and not just the US.
- mbg721 4y agoI suppose it is in fact possible to say "Super Genius" without prefacing it with "Wile E. Coyote..."
- WalterBright 4y agoThe public schools are getting rid of their gifted programs because they are unfair. How would a genius basic income fare?
- rhexs 4y agoYou’re exactly right —- the genius grant would be scrapped right after they got their list of the top 100 IQ individuals and realized the makeup is quite “problematic”.
- sinenomine 4y agoWhy should we, as taxpayers, tolerate this? Wouldn't it be great if some smart, driven, altruistic people used a small ratio of our tax money to create something qualitatively new, with a potential of providing a better future to all of us?
- mandmandam 4y agoIt would be fantastic. However, tptb want us in the dirt. There's no other way to explain the legislative choices of the last 50 years. And many - most, if not all - of the paths to creating a better future would fuck with their business. They pay very competent people in diverse fields to deal with such "threats" to their way of life. And we tolerate it, because 50% are caught up in the faux wrestling match that is American politics and the other 50% have no representation outside like 6 Democrats, some tiny independent media, and a handful of ethical businesses.
- sinenomine 4y agoIt is precisely because of this self-defeating trend such programs are needed.
- rufius 4y agoNo. Float all boats. This is stupid.
- tyronehed 4y ago
- organsnyder 4y agoThere's an assumption being made here that higher IQ will translate into greater societal contributions.
- sinenomine 4y agoThere is a lot of research on this, and one of the largest results [1][2] shows that this association of IQ and societal contributions is robust even at the far end of the spectrum, with top quartile of already very bright SMPY cohort exceeding expectations. Instead of plain FUD and denial of this inequality, we should develop sophisticated means of cognitive enhancement and make these available to all. 1. http://www.nature.com/news/how-to-raise-a-genius-lessons-from-a-45-year-study-of-super-smart-children-1.20537 http://www.nature.com/news/how-to-raise-a-genius-lessons-fro... 2. https://infoproc.blogspot.com/2016/09/smpy-in-nature.html?m=1 https://infoproc.blogspot.com/2016/09/smpy-in-nature.html?m=...
- organsnyder 4y agoThese links show the correlation between high IQ and reaching positions of power and influence. Have we established that having higher-IQ people in those positions leads to better societal outcomes?
- sinenomine 4y agoIn this discussion and in SMPY study political power is besides the point. It's the amount of quantifiable social contributions: patents and PhD theses that's interesting, and the association is obvious. Some of the societal outcomes could be explained with elite IQ distribution as per "Smart fraction theory" though.
- ta988 4y agoHow do you qualify a genius? We know IQ is biased and not a good measure. And you could just grind the tests like people grind leetcode and look like they know how to code...
- missedthecue 4y agoWhat is IQ biased toward? I went to a psychiatrist once and he administered the WAIS-IV test to me. It didn't really seem biased toward anything.
- pretendscholar 4y agoThat wouldn't exactly be a basic income now would it?
- willnonya 4y agoThe idea that people need patrons is patronizing at best. If you're really a genius you'll have an employer...until you don't need one any more. There are plenty of private endowments that recognize genius if you really feel too good to have a job. The idea that these should I stead be funded by taxpayers misses rhe forest for the trees.
- archagon 4y agoThis feels to me a bit like laundered eugenics.
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoThere's an old saying: if you're so smart, why are you so poor? This sound like a call to bring back aristocracy. Meritocracy rewards actual contribution as opposed to potential contribution. Even if your IQ is 160, if what you contribute to society has minimal tangible benefit, maybe you shouldn't be given a mansion and butler. Not to mention the practical problems of who decides who and what constitutes genius and who pays for the patronage. Just a thought.
- mj3 4y ago> Meritocracy rewards actual contribution as opposed to potential contribution. the word "meritocracy" has an interesting backstory that you might find interesting (tl;dr the creator of the word intended for it to be used as satire). relevant link: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment
- foogazi 4y ago> Even if your IQ is 160, if what you contribute to society has minimal tangible benefit, maybe you shouldn't be given a mansion and butler. How can you measure the tangible benefit of research - isn’t that the essence of it ? Research is placing bets on future unknown returns
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoThe benefits of fundamental research are apparent to me. And I would also argue that much fundamental research does have obvious tangible benefits with organizations already in place to pursue them. Take Bell Labs as just one example. My claim is that we already have mechanisms - imperfect as they are - to compensate those who wish perform it. Imposing a new layer of bureaucracy to decide who is worthy and who is not of receiving public money seems, at best, wasteful and highly to open to abuse. I disagree the premise of the article - It seems to me that more individuals than ever who choose to devote their careers to basic research are able to do so while also living a comfortable lifestyle.
- FrozenVoid 4y agoIt won't work: Left doesn't acknowledge the benefits of meritocracy. Right is anti-intellectual and suspicious of progress. There is no social movement supporting intellectual achievement: the public is focused on cheap infotainment and sensationalist science that is 'group-activity' such as "scientists from X find Y, due being funded for Z". Lone genius/inventor doesn't have such appeal as 'Big Science', which is actually collectivist mediocrity rewarding social climbers and salesmen: Academic science has to justify itself financially and 'discoveries' are usually coming from the above(Y found but funded for Z). In the past the idea of scientific progress was understood as necessarily, but today the status quo is more comfortable
- mj3 4y agothe word "meritocracy" has an interesting backstory that you might find interesting (tl;dr the creator of the word intended for it to be used as satire). relevant link: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment
- throwoutway 4y agoIronically, the mathematician moving from a rented flat to a house would result in more irrelevant work. Home ownership consumes so much free time on petty tasks that become huge problems if you dont
- foogazi 4y agoHaving both owned and rented I don’t see ownership consuming that much more time
- throwoutway 4y agoMaybe it’s just me and all my friends but: when things break, pests, foundation issues, plumbing issues, door issues, lock issues, appliance issues, mold… you have to do it yourself or research & get quotes for it. Big hassel When I rented I had one phone number to call and they had to deal with it.